Customer Reviews TOMS Seasonal Classics

These are a weird shape. Wide toe box going in, and then narrows to squish the toes. Top of shoe is low and rubs. Yet the back heel slips. Very meh.

This is my 5th pair of Toms, I always wear the same size (7.5). These ran a full size larger.

These shoes are adorable and I wish I could've kept them but I have a wide foot so unfortunately these didn't work out for me. These shoes are quite narrow and feel a size smaller than marked. Even going up a size didn't help with the width. If you have a wide foot these most likely won't be a good match :/

These are my tenth pair of Toms and the first to give me blisters!

When I see the word Metallic, I think of silver. The underlying color is gold. Does not match what I need it for so I’m returning.

Nice looking shoe but it scratched the top of my foot and was a half size too big. Sending it back.

Color says "Black" but really more a dark blue. 5.5 is sloppy on foot but have worn them so cannot return. Most Toms fit with no problem, so am disappointed in this pair. Be double sure you like them before wearing outside so you can return.

I had originally bought these in my usual size and found that they were too loose. The length was right but the fit was not snug like the Toms alpargatas with the white rubber sole. So, I exhanged it for half a size smaller. Big mistake. The canvas material on the smaller pair shrank whenever it rained in got wet and felt so tight my foot was in pain! Luckily, Zappos' super nice policy allowed me to exchange the smaller pair for the larger ones that I had originally bought. Hoping these will eventually mold to my feet like the white rubber sole pair. Advice: stick to your standard size though your foot might feel a little loose in it for a while.

I usually ware 8 1/2 - 9. Other Toms a 9 was great. This leather was very narrow. I loved the leather side stitch look accent, but with being narrow tight was very uncomfortable on my foot. Also these were longer than other 9s I have. I know they are expected to streach, but then I think the length would have made them sloppy, and an 8 1/2 would have been even more narrow. So no luck, back to canvas for me. #8639483

These shoes are beautiful and the leather is super soft. The color is exactly as described. Unfortunately, like the cloth version of these, I can't wear them due to being too narrow in the toe box. A half size larger would have made them too long and I would have encountered heel slip. If you have a wider forefoot these aren't for you. If you have narrower feet - I envy you! This is a comfortable, beautiful shoe that I can see transitioning from jeans on the weekend to a casual business attire during the week. For my wide foot friends, stick with the TOMS Avalon sneakers!

Size 12s and cute seldom go together, add the TOMS mission and I really wanted to at least like these shoes. Unfortunately they're too wide in the heel and I found no arch support. They're going to have to be returned.

Toms shoes can be inconsistent since they are hand made. The ones I got of these were at least half size too big. The pale pink was nice but they felt too plain to me. Returned them.

Not as comfortable as I had hoped. The fabric was rough and I didn't have time to wear an uncomfortable shoe to break it in.

Sole of the shoe was very slippery. Different than other version of this shoe. Had to return.

I was really excited about receiving these shoes. When they arrived, I could not even fit them on my foot despite ordering a size and a half larger than I normally wear. I purchased a 5.5 and usually wear a 4. They were very narrow. Unfortunately they don't offer a wide version, which I have never had to purchase before, so I am disappointed.

Ran very small, did not fit

I found the sole to be slippery, even on our rough tile floors.

I love the way these look and I have owned Toms in the past but this pair were too narrow and a half size too big. So back they go. ??

Love the pattern of these but didn't realize how slippery Tom's soles were. To the point of feeling in peril walking on hardwoods because I am a klutz! True to size. Maybe a little snug around the ball of the foot but I think the fabric would have some give over time.

I have a very high instep, and the top of these shoes is so long that I can't comfortably get my foot in.