Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

Looks sharp and wide fits like a regular width however the back of the boot rubbed on the back of my leg so sending back.

I love the shoes but I have a wide foot and the wide wasn't wide enough for my feet. I was so sad.

Bought the 7W in black matte and 8M in black shiny. I usually wear 7 - 7.5 and feet are on the wider side. The 7W turned out to be a good fit, but I really wanted the shiny pair, which was sold out in 7W. The 8M was wide enough but my heel was coming out. Decided the matte pair is too similar to a pair of tall boots I already own. So returned both.

These shoes are great and exactly what I was looking for -- something to keep my feet dry that still looks stylish. I am normally a 7.5 so I ordered an 8 based on the reviews. These fit perfectly, especially with thick socks. They're a little loose with thin socks but not enough to be annoying in my opinion. I do have pretty narrow feet, though, so I could see these being too tight on someone with wider feet.

I've worn Sam Edelmn boots before, and know I need to go up a half size in them. I usually wear a 9.5-10, and so got these in a 10 and fit perfectly. Wore them a lot walking around rainy London in the summer - are a nice blend of stylish and unobtrusive while being smaller to pack and wear than higher rain boots. Not as comfortable as I would have liked, but overall nothing an insole doesn't fix.

I love these boots so much I'm hoping for rain! They have great style (not clunky like most rain boots) and fit true to size. I have very narrow feet and these fit me really well in the medium width - if your feet are average width you might want to go with the wides.

Great shoe for that everyday wear.

I'm between sizes and wear a 5 1/2. I also have a very narrow foot and because of the previous reviews and no availability of my actual size, I ordered a 6M. The boots were gorgeous but turned out to be way too big for me. I was disappointed but then I decided to return them and get a 5M instead. I was skeptical as I thought they would be too small but they turned out to be great and fit me perfectly!

versatile bootie. can dress up or down

I am so thankful i found this. Zappos is the BEST!! SO BEAUTIFUL. Im 4'10 and this fits my small feet. 5 is great thankful to all the reviews, for all the buyers who spend time to give their reviews.

Not only am I in love with these shoes, Zappos is now my go-to shoe shopping site. I ordered a size 10 to wear with thick socks but decided to return them for my actual size, 9, and be able to wear them all year. I called and they helped me do everything!

Very cool boot. Great for on the go style

These are a stylish alternative for rain boots. I have narrower feet so these fit perfect. I am going to add an cushioned insert, just to make them more comfortable.

I purchased these for a trip to DC. I knew there would be a lot of walking in the rain, and I was looking for something more comfortable than my regular rain boots. These fit the bill! Very stylish and comfortable. We walked all over the city, close to 20k steps and these weren’t terribly painful. They are a bit tight in the toe bed so I put moleskin on before leaving for the long day... this really helped. For everyday running around, I do not need the moleskin and find these to be super comfortable. My only gripe Is that the elastic on the sides is fairly snug and pushes my leggings up so they start looking a little slouchy. I wish they made these in regular booties/leather because I would definitely buy a pair!

Very cute boot - liked the sleek profile of it, especially compared to clunky rain boots. Held up well in the drizzly Scottish weather. Only issue is that the top of the boot can chafe your ankles a bit if you're walking major miles. Otherwise, great, sturdy boot!

I love these shoes! Comfy and stylish. I ordered the black matte in a 6 and 7. The 7 was way too big and 6 fit just right. I've lived in Oregon the past 3 years without rainboots and dont know how I've made it! Ill survive the rainy season this year thanks to these great shoes.

THESE ARE MY GO TO SHOES FOR FALL!! I live in oregon and so it rains a whole lot, but those big tall rain boots are practical for every outfit. but these shoes work with everything!! i love them and i’m so happy i found them

Great rainboots! I was looking for something that would hold up in rainy weather, but that also looked cute. They are very tight around the ankle, and I have skinny ankles and still experienced some rubbing and discomfort the first few times I wore them. But they are completely waterproof, and have good arch support and a lot of grip. I would recommend!

I usually wear a size 6.5 but I knew I'd be wearing cushy socks with these so sized up to a 7 and they fit perfectly. Wonderful for rainy days and since they don't look specifically like rain boots, I wore them throughout the winter even when rain was iffy or unlikely. Slogged through mud and rain in these through California, Oregon, and Washington and they were very easy to rinse and clean. Good for city or light terrain walking for up to 3 miles... any more than that and it starts to feel uncomfortable for me. Absolutely need to wear socks with leggings or pants or they'll rub the back of your ankle.

I've only worn these once so far but they did the job! Cute, fairly comfortable and lighter than my tall Hunters. One thing I do not like is the intense rubber smell but hoping jay will wear off after a few rounds in the rain.

I love these shoes. They are the least obtrusive rain boots I've ever owned. I'm able to wear them as boots throughout the day as needed! Not a ton of ventilation so be prepared to have warm feet all day, but super cute and comfortable.

These are super cute and stylish boots! Very comfortable and fit true to size. I'm on the borderline of having a wider than normal foot and got the wide width and they fit perfectly. I absolutely love these because they are versatile as everyday boots and rain boots

I love these little boots! Since there's no option for half sizes, I ordered 8 and 9 (normally 8.5). The size 9 fit best, so order up a size. They are quite narrow, but I have narrow feet, so they fit fine. Wider feet would have a problem. Otherwise they are very cute and pretty comfy for a rain boot. I love the glossy black look.

Great boots! I wore them in the rain and hosed down bikes, and they've held up really well! The pointed toe does give the illusion of a larger foot, and they're narrow. After wearing them all day I could feel where they had rubbed on my ankles. But overall - great boot!

Very comfortable and stylish