Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

Love these boots! I ordered a size up (normally a 7.5 but I ordered an 8). The 8 fit perfectly! They’re very stylish and very comfortable with the exception of the back rubbing a bit. Beware that if you wear colored or patterned socks you’ll see them through the non-printed areas.

I absolutely love these boots. From afar, they almost look like chic leather booties, but keep my feet dry. My feet are on the wide side, and they are super comfy.

I always go a full size up in rain boots & these were no exception.

I got a half size up after reading reviews and wanting to wear thicker socks with these and I LOVE THEM. They're so cute and so comfy and keep my feet super nice, dry and happy during this awful Chicago winter. I love them so much!

Cute shoes. Based on advice of other reviews, I ordered a wide size for my feet since I have trouble with shoes being a bit too narrow, and I'm glad I did as these definitely run narrow.

The size was too small but i got a different pair . I like the look and the style of the boot.

I love these boots! I only wear them for the style, not the function. They are cute when paired with thicker socks and leggings/skinny jeans. I wear a 7.5, but sized up to 8 just in case. They fit better with thicker socks and they are comfortable. You can walk long distances without issue. 10/10 recommend.

Super comfy, casual and cute rain boots. Being a long time owner of Hunter rain boots, these are a nice alternative, which can be dressed up or down. Plus, they’ll be great for days with lighter rain. I suggest going down half a size.

I am usually a 7.5, so I decided to order an 8. I'm closer than an 8 than to a 7. Overall, I am pretty pleased with my purchase. They're comfortable and the elastic band around the ankle helps give it a tighter feel. There is definitely some toe wiggle room, but it's not excessive. It's actually kind if nice and better than having really tight boots to where you want move your toes at all. I did scuff them in my first day and I can't take it off no matter what I do. I like that I can dress them up and down. Also, I was hesitant about getting ankle boots but I think it was a good choice because I have big calves.

Listen to the other reviews! Get the wide fit! My feet are a true 9 and a little narrower than average, but I usually wear the regular fit. I ordered the 9W and there is plenty of room to wiggle all my toes. However, these boots are tighter than I would prefer across the top of my foot around the arches. Be cautious if you have high arches! Mine are low so it still fits ok. I can wear them with thin socks, but when it gets colder I will not be able to wear warmer, thicker socks. The opening of the shoe is tight to get on, but the goring on the side stretches and the sizable pull tab on the back helps so it is not impossible. The bottom also doesn't have much traction for walking on smooth surfaces, walking on my wood floor is slippery so I wouldn't trust these on ice. I havent tried these in the rain yet, so I can't say for sure if they are leak proof. The insole is also completely removable, so if you're like me and have long days on your feet but still want to look cute, these will do well if you want to switch them out for thin, orthotic insoles. HACK: These are made of plastic, so I was able to stretch them out by wearing them with thick socks and carefully (don't want to melt them) blowing hot air on them with my hairdryer and proceeding to walk around the house. Boots fit fine now!

These would be cute rain shoes for someone with normal feet. Unfortunately, I have extremely long, slim feet, and it is pretty much impossible for me to find rain shoes that will stay on. I was hopeful that these would work because they are a bit more narrow than a lot of 11 mediums, but no such luck. My feet rise up off of the insole with every step. Fortunately, Zappos has a great return policy -- just wish my feet didn't make me have to avail myself of it.

I wear a 9 1/2 and the 10 is perfect. I have a wide foot and got the W(ide). Fits well. A good inexpensive rain boot. Easy on and off and I have a very high instep. The tab at the back is a big help to pull boot on.

The boot is comfortable and what I like about it is that it doesn't look like a rain boot. Plus I love purchasing from Zappos - They have the best customer service!

After reading the reviews, I decided to order my size in W and am glad I did. They fit just like a regular width 9. They're stylish and the quality is quite good, especially for being made from polyurethane. I don't plan on wearing them without a pant tucked in or long socks/tights, as they do come in direct contact with the ankle. Overall, pleased with my purchase!

gud

????????????

I bought these so I could get rid of my tall, heavy, clunky rain boots. These are great! They are not bulky or too heavy. They are easy to put on. They look nice. Sizing: I wear 6 in sneakers and 5 or 5.5 in boots/flats. I bought these in a 5 and they fit perfectly. I wear them with a regular sock. I don't plan to wear a super thick sock with them.

These are really cute & can almost pass for regular boots. Great for spring, very light weight. I’m usually a 9.5 in most shoes, with a wide foot. The 9W fits perfectly.

These are perfect for rainy spring days!

These are lightweight and cute but NOT WATERPROOF. I upgraded to hunter. Save your money