Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

This was the best I could find for the price range, color and gloss I was looking for - I ideally wanted a rounder toe. With that being said, this boot will serve its purpose of keeping my feet dry on days I have to work. This boot is not the most comfortable to walk in, so I will be removing the boots upon arrival to work. Of note, I typically wear a size 8 and need a wide shoe to accommodate my flat feet and mild-moderate bunion. I purchased a size 8 (not an 8W). I could've used more width. It's cute compared to a typical boot but still looks pretty awkward with casual dress clothing. Hope this helps.

They are not super comfortable, but they keep my feet dry and look pretty nice.

These are more narrow than expected. They don't bother me when I'm walking, but when I'm sitting, my feet are in pain. Maybe Sam Edelman just runs small? They also still have this strong funky rubber smell after months of having them that I just can't get rid of. I've left them outside, put shoe balls in, and nothing works. You also have to wear taller socks (at least mid-calf height) or they'll dig into the back of your ankle/calf. They are cute though.

Loved the look and feel of this rain boot. It's very chic. But I feel the floor through the sole. There's barely any sole and it's too uncomfortable.

Very cute. Easy to slip on. Length was perfect for my size. Width is large and swallows my feet up.

Not wide enough for my feet.

The shoes are beautiful online. I read the reviews. Some were good some were not so good. I ordered a pair in my size but when I try to put them on it was a struggle. Finally when my foot was inside the fit was very tight and small in size so I returned them for a refund

Very narrow for a person with wide feet

Very narrow, and runs small. Had to return.

Super cute, but very uncomfortable. They were very rigid and dug into the top of my feet.

Have not had these boots for a year and the soles of both are falling apart making it extremely uneven and uncomfortable to walk in. They are very cute, but cannot recommend as even a 5 minute walk was uncomfortable.

I would order a size up if you wear a half size, this is a snug shoe. Also, it would have been great if the heal was a bit higher.

I tricked myself into liking these only to discover after a few months that they weren't good for my feet. No support, oddly high ankle length with a hard material that awkwardly cuts pants off, even when cuffed. Just stopped enjoying them and found they wore out too quickly. Good price if they were more durable.

I have lots of Sam Edelman shoes, so I'm perplexed as to why these didn't fit. Maybe the rubber is too stiff?

Fit was odd due to the firmness of the material. Not comfortable at all. I returned them.

No arch support at all. Very narrow in the box of the foot. After very little time in them, my feet were killing me!

I like the overall style of the boot & it definitely repels water, but they don't fit correctly. I don't have a particularly wide foot and never by a wide size in shoes, but when I originally ordered the regular width ones I had to return them and exchange for the wide size because I couldn't even get my foot in. Now with the wide ones, the left boot feels fine but the right is extremely tight, making it impossible to wear for long-term. This reflects poor quality in manufacturing seeing as 2 shoes that are marked the same size do not fit the same.

This boot was really cute but being a Wide size, I could hardly get my foot into it. Very disappointed, cuz they are cute. Returned them.

VERY narrow. Difficult to get on and when I did every step was painful. The material is very stiff and they are simply too narrow for a normal foot. Attractive shor and the rubber looks almost like leather if you squint, but the fit was all off.

These were the sleekest/slimmest/least-clunky of any of the similar styles I tried. However, I am returning them, as they are just too tight around the top of the foot & toe box. They are also a little too tall, which makes it awkward-looking for some pants and just not very flattering in general.

I had to check the size inside the shoe it was so small! Order one size up.