Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Button

Uhm, I was on the fence about these boots, because I was not sure if I wanted to "break them in." They are difficult to put on. However, as I was walking around the room, I slipped on the quite slippery sole. The boots were returned because they are too expensive to have the headache of breaking them in and worrying about falling. I wonder why Frye did not think about the hassle of the slippery sole.

I've wanted to get a pair of Frye boots for a long time, but couldn't decide on which style. The classic look of these finally won me over, and I'm glad I took (the costly) plunge. The leather is extremely soft, inside and out, and the padded foot bed is extremely comfortable. I can see myself wearing these for many winters to come. The calf area is just the perfect amount of snug, they help hold pants down if I tuck them in, and I can still wear leggings, socks, tights, etc comfortably underneath. My number one warning to those considering buying these boots is that you are going to have to spend more money to get them resoled immediately. The leather bottoms are extremely slippery and the rubber heel part does nothing. If you aren't prepared to spend more on these boots, do not buy them. You can not wear them with the soles as is or you'll be slipping all over even if the surface is not wet or is rough. I'm not sure why Frye makes them with the leather soles; they get scratched up immediately, but it does nothing to help with traction. I also recommend buying the Frye cream to condition them. It works great on other leather shoes as well.

These are beautiful and well made. I ordered the black, and ultimately returned them only because I thought they would look better in the burgundy color. They are great "equestrian" style boots. So if that's what you're looking for, then order these. Oh, and they were a bit too tall for my leg and went all the way up to my knee. I am 5'3".

I love the look of these boots. I was so excited when they came but very disappointed in how they fit. I have skinny legs and narrow feet and I had to struggle to get my foot in the boots!

This is a beautiful boot (I got the color Fawn, which is essentially medium brown with grayish and greenish undertones), but it is not comfortable for me. Length and width wise, it was true to size. However, I had a terrible time getting the boot on because I have a moderately high instep. I put a plastic bag over my foot and was able to get the boot on, then tear the bag away. The main fit problem occurred when I began walking. The heel is situated on the boot so that it puts pressure painfully and awkwardly on the bottom of my foot between the outside edge of my foot past the heel. I have never felt that issue before. I think that if I wore the boots, the heel may wear down and eventually be comfortable, but I am returning them. Too expensive not to have a perfect fit and be difficult to put on.

I have big feet (11) and what I would consider average calves. These boots were way too big for my legs, even with jeans tucked in. As for the style, I think it's just okay. I don't like how the shaft dips down on the front of the leg. I don't think it's flattering and made my legs a little more stumpy. I much prefer the Frye Chelsea for a sleek and classic look.

I love the look of the Frye Melissa Button boots but I'm not thrilled with the fit. I ordered two sizes and kept the smaller of the two. After three wearings, the boots have stretched so much that they are almost impossible to wear. Very frustrating!

I love Frye boots so it pains me to write this review. I received these boots from my husband for Christmas. I immediately tried them on, starting with the right foot. The boot was my size, but I could not get my foot in. No matter what I tried. But the left boot went on smooth as a glove with a little bit of room to spare. The more I fiddled with the right boot, I realized there was something wrong with the heel it kept collapsing in. It was not a matter of size as there was something fundamentally wrong with the boot heel. As usual, Zappos had another pair in the mail right away. This time, same size mind you, the heel was fine but the boots were so wide it was like I was wearing a different size altogether. You do not want to start out roomy with leather because it will stretch as did my other Fryes (went from tight to perfect fit and they are my favorite boots. Ever.). But they were the same exact size, and certainly not marked as wide. I even put on a thick pair of socks but my heels kept sliding up halfway up the boots when I walked. I am in the process of now sending these back, and as much as these boots are gorgeous (and they really are), they are going back for good. Broken heel aside, not sure how the first set of boots can fit vastly different from the second when they are supposed to be the same exact size? They are beautiful, but I do not have time to be the Goldilocks of boots.

Whoa, are these ever too narrow in the shaft! And very surprising how small they run overall. C'mon, Frye, I expect more accurate sizing out of a premium brand like you. I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 as a nod to the quality of the leather & construction.

These boots are beautiful, and of excellent quality. Unfortunately, they didn't fit. I'm usually a 9 and the 9 seemed to slip off my heel to much...so I exchanged for an 8.5, can't even pull them on! I'm so bummed...the cute boot hunt continues!

I have been lusting after a pair of Frye boots for forever and finally ordered these last week. So sad when they arrived and I found that they aren't wide enough for my calves...which is extra sad because I do not have large calves at all. I could just get the boots on but there is no way I could have worn them over jeans. The foot portion fit just fine (I'm a size 8) so I couldn't go up a size in the hopes of getting a bigger calf circumference. I didn't want to take a risk on stretching them, in case they didn't stretch enough. So they're going back.

Was surprised how very wide the calf is! I am a runner with quite developed calves and I had about 2 inch gap! The boot was quite narrow in the ankle and difficult to get on with a very pronounced fold on the seam that rubs uncomfortably. Surprised at the poor fit from such a reputable company. Disappointed that I had to return.

I have had my eye on these boots for two years! I had ordered them from an alternate provider and, due to weather, the boots would not arrive by the date I needed them. Therefore, I ordered them from Zappos VIP. The service was amazing and next day delivery FREE! However, the boots themselves appear like Frye outlet products. I understand that genuine leather may have color and texture differences from boot to boot BUT mine were a completely different color on the foot portion compared to the shaft. The shaft is also very "weathered" looking. Not at all like the picture. The other pair of identical boots I ordered arrived and were just as I had hoped and one color and one texture, beautiful! Unfortunately, I had already worn the Zappos pair with the hope they would wear in to be one color. It has improved but still appears two tone. I will not order Frye boots from this seller again.

I love this boot. I am sad to have to return it. I ordered a size 10. It seems to me a 10 is very tight in this boot. I first tried it on with a sock couldn't get it to zip up. Took off the sock and it zipped. If I cannot wear a sock with this boot, I had to return it. It's a wonderful looking boot. I am so sad that I cannot keep it.

These boots were a no for me...reasons being the leather was not impressive for a Frye boot..distressed yes but some areas very shiny and the leather was pretty thin in my opinion. Seemed shorter than other Frye tall boots.. Comfort level wasn't really there either..I have been trying several Frye boots lately and so far I'm really leaning towards the Jenna Studded Tall.

I love this boot but unfortunately I think that it has gotten so popular that the quality as gone down. I ordered the same boot 3 times. Zappos customer services is perfect! The boot however is not. Each time there were some serious defects with them. The first pair had bubbles inside the boot, so the leather was separating and had huge scratches. I did call Frye directly and they told me that the inside should not have any bubbles or air pockets. With the second pair, the nails on the bottom of the boot where sticking out and the leather on the inside was separating. I hoped the last pair I got would be the charm but not my luck. One boot was great. I wish the other was but the stitching on the inside pushed threw to the leather on the outside and made an impression all the way around the boot. The shaft looked like it had a half inch ring around it. Also one tab was sewn wrong so the leather was messed up. Hopefully Frye will look at their quality control and get back to making a quality product. I'm totally disappointed. I love these boots. For sizing, I am a true 7.5 and ordered a 7.5 and they fit great. I tried them with thin socks but if I wanted thicker socks they would have been way to snug. I ordered the black vintage soft leather.

I disagree with a lot of the reviews for this boot. Though the leather is amazing and clearly the Frye brand speaks for itself, I find these boots incredibly uncomfortable. I have average width feet and they rub both my big toe and my little toe. The slip in the shoe bed (despite all my efforts to prevent slippage). And, they are really hard to get on and off (and I have small calves). I've had them for two years and have only worn them 5 times. I wish I could sell them or something to get something else. They take up too much space in my closet.

I am very disappointed in the quality of these boots. I have had two pairs where the stitching has come apart. For the price I would expect better quality. Otherwise, the boots are very comfortable and stylish.

I could not get these boots on or off without a major struggle. I am so disappointed! Why can't Frye make more boots with a zipper!

Despite the rave reviews, I did not like this boot for the following reason: I thought the leather was cheap compared to my other Frye boots. The color tan was a bit too yellow for me. The style was cute and with effort I could get my feet in them, but overall I was disappointed in this style.

I'm surprised about all the rave reviews for these boots. I have two pairs of Fryes, one pair that I bought two years ago and one pair that I bought years before that, and these Melissas come nowhere near the quality of my other pairs. The leather is thin, the boots have no traction on the bottom, and the style isn't flattering. No way are these worth the money. I returned them immediately. I think Frye quality has suffered lately.

This is the first time I have ever been disappointed with Zappos. And I'm really disappointed. My anxiously awaited new boots arrived today, only they weren't new. When I pulled them out of the box, it was obvious from the worn-in creases in the leather and the pockmarks in the soles that the boots had been previously worn ... a lot. To make matters worse, the soles had been covered up with black shoe polish which left black marks all over my beige tile floor when I tried them on. I understand someone trying them on and returning them (like I am doing), but the extent of the wear indicates that the boots were worn outside on more than one occasion - and then sold to me at full price as if they were new. That's why I'm disappointed, Zappos. I have no issue with the quality or workmanship - they're Frye boots. The condition in which I received them is very disappointing.

I received not one, not two, but THREE used pairs of these boots. All pairs looked well worn with scratches on the bottom. The boots themselves are beautiful, and I would give them 5 stars. However, the fact that they were used is unacceptable. If I wanted used shoes I wouldn't shop at Zappos, and when I spend over $350 on a pair of boots, I expect perfection. I called customer service each time I received a used pair and while the reps were very sorry and friendly, they were unable to guarantee that they can ship me brand new shoes! Not the type of response I would expect from Zappos. I appreciate Zappos for having great customer service, but I am disappointed in their packaging and shipping department for being careless and not adhering to quality standards...if there are any. And to those customers who abuse Zappos's awesome return policy, shame on you!