Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Petra

These are great shoes for working in an office. They are very comfortable and stylish, yet conservative enough for an office. I really like how the footbed is slightly padded. Cobb Hill is a brand owned by New Balance, so that says a lot to me about why these are so comfortable. As far as fit and size goes: I have wide feet and I wear a 9 1/2 when wearing Asics running shoes. But from the Cobb Hill brand, a size 9D fits perfectly! It's really hard for me to find cute shoes that won't hurt my feet. But these are great, not one blister ever! The price has gone up since I bought my first pair about 2 years ago, but I'm willing to pay the cost because these reliable shoes perform very well. I'm planning to buy another pair.

I Love this show. Very Comfortable.

I am keeping this item # 8565272. I LOVE this shoe, so VERY Comfortable. Thank you.

I like these shoes a lot. They are pretty cute and very comfortable. I wear them with and without socks. They are comfortable without socks. They have decent arch support, and the wide is actually quite wide with a generous toebox.

So far, so good! I have worn these around the house. I do not even know that I have a bunion, and the strap holds the shoe in place and does not allow heel slippage. I am in the process of donating my heels and wearing flats. These shoes are pretty and can be worn dress up or down. Thank you, Zappos, for dressing my skinny chicken feet!

This is just about what I am looking for. Its attractive and extremely comfortable. The adjustable band has velcro which works on my foot that is narrow everywhere except across the bunions in the front of my foot. Sometimes the velcro straps aren't sized to actually fit across a narrow foot and have velcro that misses itself so won't stick. The shape of the toe box covers the bunion comfortably and doesn't bind there the way so many other shoes do. The metal button is a cute plus. They are somewhat dressy but very casual. My only wish would be for some other colors. I got the brown which is a very rich chocolate. I may look into dying it.

Very comfortable shoe. Although my true width is AAA, this adjustable strap made this shoe work. Cute design. Very roomy toe box, but with a thin foam insert, they fit great.

These are well-made and light weight. I ordered a 8w to avoid tightness across the top of my foot and that has allowed me to use an extra gel insert. I am pleased with these shoes. This is my first pair of Cobb Hill shoes.

These are soft and comfortable, these shoes offer a little height and lots of dressiness. They are so fun to wear. I do not even realize that they are brand new. They are just exactly what I need for standing all day.

I have the hardest time finding closed toed, comfortable, somewhat dressy shoes to wear at work. After ordering and returning about 20 pairs of shoes, these are the ones that finally fit. I have a narrow foot and sensitive toenails (anything pressing down in the toe region is uncomfortable). These look nice, are comfortable (wore them all day right out of the box without socks and no issue), and fit my feet. I'll be ordering another pair in brown.

The Cobb Hill Petra looks very nice on, the brown is a rich color, it runs true to size, and it has a really comfortable insole. However, even in a narrow, it was too wide in the heel for my very narrow feet. Sadly, they'll have to go back to Zappos.

These are fantastic mary jane shoes. They are super comfortable right out of the box. I wore them all day at the office and they were comfortable the whole time. I have purchased a few pairs of boots from this brand and these shoes feel just as good. The straps are secured with Velcro under a cute silver button and the Velcro is great for adjusting the tightness of the shoe to your individual foot.

LOVE-the best fitting shoe ever! I literally put them on right out of the box- by far the best and most comfortable shoe I have ever had! I just may order another pair for back up.

This shoe is adorable. There is a seam in the insole under the ball of my foot that I was afraid would be problematic for me, but after a day of wearing them to work and walking 1 1/2 miles home, they've stayed comfortable. Now, I want one in every color.

This is a beautiful leather shoe. It is stylish and very comfortable. I ordered a wide in my regular shoe size, 8.5, but it is too big.

overall a very nice shoe. Didn't care for the embellishment, looks juvenile. the problem was the depth of the toe box, it squeezed the big toe and the stiff leather didn't bend well.

Just got them. Seem comfortable

Strap is too short to completely cover the rough velcro strip, even in the "Wide" option. I am returning the shoes for this reason

Too big, but very nice shoe.

I have pronation in my feet. These shoes didn't have enough arch support. Also, the heels slipped when I walked. They'd be great for someone without foot issues. They are well-made and would go well with skirts.

I have very hard to fit feet and this shoe probably comes as close to a good fit as any I have worn for a long time. Seems pretty comfortable and gpes with about anything

A little grandma-ish IMO but still a solid Mary Jane. I have a wider foot the medium accommodated. Can wear barefoot with powder or very thin sock.

comfortable but need more height

I’ve had these several years and they’re pretty good, though they went from smart enough for church with some outfits to too casual looking as they got broken in. I guess it’s the finish that doesn’t hold up as well as I’d like. That really wouldn’t be an issue if they’d offer a dressier version. Then I could have these for casual and a comfortable pair that’s nicer for dressier days. That would be great.

Fits great. Comfortable and well made. But even though I am relatively old, I am not as old as I hope to some day be, and so hope to find something more youthful looking for right now. I think the brown color adds to the mature woman look. I am immature.