Customer Reviews Naturalizer Michelle

Most uncomfortable pair of heels I have worn nicely made but I’m on my feet a lot and these are not the shoes to walk around all day in

Did not fit my foot. Slipped on my heels as I walked. Not as comfortable a shoe as I had hoped.

The shoes look nice! And I wish I could keep them as they also feel comfortable in my feet. But they are not the same size .. one of them is about 1/4inch longer at the heel so this makes it shoe slip out with every step. I would love to just order an other pair but feel that is too much work incase they need to be returned as well. Will have to try to find them at a shoe store when I can try them on first.

Loved the color, but they felt a bit large - ended up returning. Bought my normal size (10W), and they slipped off my feet immediately when I tried to walk in them.

Really lovely shoes but seem to run very large

I love this shoe, but it slips off the back of my heel.

I'm between 9.5 and 10 in narrow and ordered these in 10N. They were HUGE. Both in length and width.

Very attractive shoe. Purchased an 8N. Heel not narrow enough. Toe box not wide enough. Gaps on sides of shoe. Heel height was very comfortable

These shoes are very pretty on, and are fairly comfortable. But I have to return them because of my narrow heels which pop out of the shoes regardless of any padding added to the heel/toe. I have kind of given up wearing pumps, sadly, unless they have an ankle strap.

Didn’t like the rounded toe...returning

I really wanted to love these shoes... The 9.5M was a bit too snug (toes smashed) and the 10M was far too long (gapping in heel). I’m either going to try the 9.5W or send these back. YMMV

I loved the style and quality, but had a difficult time finding a good fit. Size 8, my true size, was too small, but size 8.5 was too large. The small increase in size also meant an increase in width at the toe and heel. Reluctantly returned both pair. So wanted this shoe to work!

Sizing is inconsistent between styles. I ordered 6.5W (I’m usually a 7W) in the Natalie and those fit perfect. Ordered the same for the Michelle and they squeezed my foot and toes to oblivion. Will need a 6.5WW in these as they run pretty narrow. The length also runs large so order a half size down.

They are very comfortable (I have then in navy) but the color is off. They are almost shimmery plastic rather than leather. Not at all what the photo shows.

I wear 11 AA. The toe box is not large enough if your great toe is longer than your 2nd toe, as mine is. I will be returning these; the 12AA would be too large.

It is a beautiful shoe - however even with the Narrow it was too wide in the heal and kept slipping off my foot. Disappointed that it was not more narrow.

The fit and size is good and, being a size 11, I find it very difficult to find that in a dress shoe. There's usually something off and selection in the upper sizes being what it is, I have to live with less than ideal fit all the time. I like it enough that I was thinking about buying it in the nude, as well, but I'm leaning against it because the synthetic liner is very uncomfortable. My feet are clammy and sweaty (not usually a problem with me), and I'm sure they'll smell bad before long, too. It's too bad... You'd think for the price, they could have put a natural liner in an otherwise leather shoe.

I bought this shoe in 3 different colors. The first I got was the Navy 8N. They fit perfect! I was so excited about the fit that I didn't really wait to see the quality. I then ordered the Black and the Nude colors. I received the Black recently and the 8N is tighter than the 8N in the Navy. Also, I noticed these scuff more easily than any leather pumps I've ever had. They scuff easily and feel like man made leather of some kind. The quality doesn't seem as good as it used to be. The Naturalizer Brand just doesn't seem as good as it used to be.

I ordered an 8, my usual size but they were too big. I’m returning for a 71/2.

Love them when I first put these on and then waked right out of them! Much too long and 8 1/2 is my true size. Returned. Will not be buying another size.