Customer Reviews Naturalizer Michelle

Dear Lord. These shoes tore my feet up. They were of course too big. Which is normal for me and high heels. The back of the shoes tore my heels up so badly I've been unable to wear normal shoes for a week now. The toes weren't as bad, but still caused some pain. I wanted to like these so bad. I thought once I break them in it would be alright. But I won't be breaking these in. They will be in the garbage. Don't buy unless you're able to fit in heels without having to modify.

In most shoes I wear a size 6, but I always buy a half size up for high heels. Usually after a few years of wear, they stretch out to the point where my heels constantly slip up and I practically lose my shoe when I walk. I am okay with that because I can't squish my foot in the toe area of a size 6 without a lot of discomfort. These shoes stretched out the first time I wore them so that I cannot walk a step without losing my shoe. I am SO disappointed because now that I have worn them outside I cannot return them. What a waste! I did wear them around the house a bit to make sure they fit and they are comfortable for a heel. But, now I am stuck with trying to figure out what kind of insert I can put in them to keep them on my feet.

Two problems. First, these shoes are a very pretty tan, however, they are supposed to taupe and they are not. Second, the extra cushioning under the heel is very nice and comfortable, however, it raises the foot enough that the back of the shoe is not high enough to stay on and the shoes slip with every step taken.

Epic mistake. I bought this shoe in navy because the platform profile was cute, the heel wasn't a tiny spike, and the color was true navy. After a few wearings, however, I found them to feel heavy, the leather to be poor quality, and the style to look "dumpy". Even I'm not THAT conservative. They went into the donations box. Yuck.

This shoe (for me) looks better in the pics than in reality. I thought this shoe was very matronly. It also had a very round toe. And, the 8.5 wide fell right off my feet. I bought the naturalizer indeed in same exact size and width and it fit perfect. Michelle is going back. Indeed is a keeper!

These run EXTREMELY narrow. I don't typically even need a wide width shoe, but the E width isn't even wide enough. I kept them and they are bearable if I'm not standing or walking much, but my toes go numb if I do. Also, after about a dozen times wearing them (without much walking), one of the heels began to break off. Very poor quality for such a well-renowned company. I've honestly had higher quality, more comfortable pumps from Payless (their Comfort Plus line by Predictions seriously blows these out of the water. Very sad!)