Customer Reviews Sperry Saltwater Quilted Nylon

Really cute, but they were different sizes! The left boot was too small and the right boot was ... well, just right. And to double-check, I asked my husband if he noticed anything about them, and he said, “Sure, that one is smaller!” Pointing to the left boot. So if he could notice just at a glance, it wasn’t just my feet.

One boot was a half size smaller than the marked size! Right boot was a perfect fit, left boot was tight and uncomfortable. Holding the boots up side by side, it was obvious to the eye that the left boot was smaller. I even asked my husband to double check, and he also said of the left boot, "This one is smaller." I loved the look and feel of the right boot, wish they had made the left boot to match! Unwearable; extremely disappointed, reluctant to re-order if this is the kind of quality control they have now.

Two different sizes!! Obviously a manufacturing error. The left boot was right, and the right was a good fit. Both marked as 7.5 (38). Even holding the boots up and matching them, the left one was obviously a half size smaller, and when I showed them to my husband, he also picked out the left boot as a smaller size. Very disappointed - they are cute boots but unwearable.

I ordered a size 7, I am normally a 6.5 to 7 shoe size. The 7 was too small. I exchanged for a size 7.5 and they were massive, so I am returning them. I was shocked with the major sizing difference between a 7 and a 7.5, these boots look cute but do not fit well at all. This is with thin socks with the smaller pair, and thick socks with the larger pair, either way both pairs did not fit.

This negative review is coming from someone who has only written about 2 negative reviews on anything in her entire life. It also comes from someone who isn't particularly picky about footwear...if it fits okay and is moderately comfy, I'll wear it. So, you guessed it: these shoes have to be AWFUL for me to write this review. And they are. Hands down, these are the most uncomfortable, ill fitting shoes/boots I have ever had on my feet. They run about 1.5 sizes too small and are quite narrow. They are also difficult to get on and off because there is no pull tab on the back so one has to grab on to the quilted nylon, which is so slick your hands just slip right off. I wasn't expecting a pair of rubber boots to be as comfortable as tennis shoes so my expectations were fairly low on comfort but I literally could not walk 50 feet in these. There is a very pronounced and sharp edge where the rubber and the nylon meet at the back of the heel and it grinds into the foot when walking. Worst shoes/boots I've ever purchased. I'm happy that Zappos makes returns easy!