Customer Reviews Massimo Matteo 5-Eye Cap Toe

I HAD TO GET THIS ONE SIZE SMALLER THAN WHAT I ORDERED.THEY COME BIG.

The leather has not really lived it to my expectation for the cost. A shoe that scuffs and marks up. So if you like to polish your shoe regulary this is for you. Otherwise pass it up.

Shoe has incredibly long and pointy toe. Makes the shoe feel cheap and very Aladdin like.

The Brown color shown is darker than what actually arrives. These are cheaply made, you are getting what you pay for.

Very comfortable (soft insoles) but leather looks cheap (may be because of the color) and stitching not neat - does not look as if its a high quality shoe, and color differs from the picture. True color is closer to yellowish/sand like shade. Returned the shoes.

When on the foot, this shoe was at least one size too long and so narrow that it cramped my foot

I have another 5-eye shoe from Massimo Mateo and I found it to be easily scuffed. Trying this one in black I noticed both shoes had something in common in how they're made-- it is as if they take a thin layer of leather and bond it to a thicker layer. The creasing over the toe box that ensues is like a fine spider web, which doesn't look good. I think it might explain why the first shoe I got was so easily scuffed/scraped. Soles are leather and very slippery. These are also very loud when you walk on a tiled/concrete surface. I think I'm done with this brand. Magnanni and Mezlan are superior.

Really, the shoe was great except for the fact how fast it fell apart. I bought these in June 2016. As of December 2016 when I am writing this the heel cap fell off on both shoes 2 months in. I glued them back. On one of the shoes the sole is so worn down I can feel the ground on my big toe. The look is good, the style is great, very comfortable. Just bummed I am buying another dress shoe in 6 months.

These are really nice-looking shoes but the sole started leaking after six months of moderate wear. I expect a little more endurance from nice dress shoes.

I wear a size 10½ medium but because the reviews said these shoes ran large, I ordered a size 10 medium; the reviews also said that the shoes ran a little narrow and the fitting at the heel was loose. I found all of these things to be true. But all was good with the size 10 except the fitting at the heel was in fact too loose so I had to return them; the shoe was beautiful but there must be a flaw on the part of the manufacturer to make them like this; I cannot wear a shoe where the heels slip as you walk. Too bad. Please pass these comments on to the manufacturer.

Absolutely loved the look of this shoe. It just didn't fit right. I usually wear a 12-13 sized shoe. I ordered a 12 and it slid off my back heel when I walked. I even ordered an 11.5 and it was too tight.

Really nice shoes, for great but you sent me used shoes. I don’t appreciate scratches used good for full price. I’ll go to a thrift store if I wanted used shoes.