Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Georgina

Great shoes! Wore them all day straight out of the box. They're ugly/cute and very comfortable. I have a very wide foot (EE) and a high instep. These shoes work for me.

This shoe is perfect for casual business wear! I have a slightly wide foot and I tried both the medium and wide in a 6.5 and the wide fit like a glove. In addition I have flat feet and these provide moderate arch support. I would definitely recommend these shoes.

These shoes are almost too tight for me, but comfortable nonetheless. I usually wear a size 6 or 6.5, and the 6.5 for this fits me, but with a sock, after my feet swell at the end of the day, there can be a little bit of rubbing. I probably should have returned the medium width for a wide (I've never worn wide shoes before), but I didn't. On the other hand, I've never had a full blister with these shoes, so the fit might just be a little strange. That being said, I injured my calf this summer and was looking for a casual shoe that wouldn't exacerbate my leg and foot issues. I tried brands that specialize in shoes for sufferers of plantar fasciitis (Orthaheel, Alegria) but the arch support in those hurt my feet and legs more than they helped. After ordering 4 different pairs of shoes, the Cobb Hill Georgina is when I stopped looking. They're comfortable, made of a good material for the price, and the height of the heel is perfect for casual, everyday walking. The style is also nice. I can wear these all day with no problems.

Had to return as it was too wide in the heel. Otherwise perfect for my 11M foot. Rare to find a shoe in this brand that isn't perfect.

I've been looking for a cute shoe to take with me to Ireland that I can wear with dresses/skirts as well as pants. After sending back 5 other pairs from various stores, I've found a winner! Cute and comfy, and that is saying something, since I have plantar fasciitis. I am between a medium and a wide, and in these shoes, I needed a wide. Though the heel is a bit wide, the toe in the M was painful. For reference, something like Miz Mooz usually fits comfortably - they make a wider toe, but still M width. If you are borderline, do the W width.

These are very cute, super comfortable oxfords. I have been wearing these nearly every day. I have wide feet, narrow heels, and high arches. I also like the rubber treaded sole, which will come in very handy this winter.

These shoes rock! The stone color is really attractive and they are most comfortable shoes ever-No need to break in. The material is a little thick so may not be ideal to wear in summer time.

Wow, these are the most comfortable shoes I've had in a long time. No need to break in. They are a little thick so may not be ideal to wear in summer time.

Shoe was narrow in the heal and tight across the top on my medium-wide foot (I usually wear medium/normal width shoes no problem, but I'm on the wider end). Arch support was okay, but in the wrong spot for me. I think the synthetic lining would make my feet sweat (it does in my other pair of Cobb Hill) Style is a little sneaker-ish in person and the light tone leather stands out more than it does in the picture. If the style were cuter, I'd order a size up since that'd probably be comfy, but it's not quite worth it.

Love the shoe, the Cobb Hill line is one of the best. Unfortunately I had to return the shoes because they were too small. I have never bought larger than a size 7 and I have a slim foot but this style did not accommodate either. Also the back of the shoe at the heel is too short if you have a high arch which I do. Too bad.

Overall a great fit for me! I ordered these in an 8 Wide and they fit as well as most shoes that I keep do. My toes are wider than my heel area, so my heel always slips out a little. I added some foot pads to the inner heel part of the shoe and I'm good to go. The insoles are cushiony and soft feeling which is nice. Plus these are super cute!

Cute and comfortable! Make my 8.5 feet look small. Only down side is slight rub at back if I wear without socks or stockings. I have high arches and almost always add Pedag inserts to shoes. They work just fine in these.

I tried these on at a local store, and was surprised at how comfortable they were, so I went ahead and bought them from Zappos. They are awesome! Perfect fit right out of the box, and comfortable from the first step. I require good arch support and have a high instep, and these fit the bill; I don't even need to add special inserts. They're comfortable and perfect with slacks or skirts. Interesting side note: my friends under 40 years of age set see them as trendy, but over 40 as more old fashioned. I bought the brown and they do scuff easily, but that adds to their charm. I'll likely buy them in black, too.

Love these! I've been search for these shoes for a long time and so glad to have finally found them! Very comfortable (I got the wide) for walking, look great.

I absolutely love these shoes! I do not write reviews normally. These shoes are the most comfortable shoes that I own. I am not sure how good they will be when I have to sprint through the airport for a flight, but for all the walking and standing that I do before and after the airport sprint, these rock. I ordered half a size larger than I normally do because I was desperate but they fit perfectly (by comparison, the Deidre, ordered in exactly my size was too big and walked like a flip-flop).

These shies run only very slightly smaller (narrower) than the stated size, and I would say it is the width that is the clincher in that. I go between a 6½M and a 7M in my shoes, and I went up to 7 but moved to the Wide instead of the Medium and now my feet are very happy. As other reviewers have stated the heel slips up and down a bit, but I do not find that annoying at all, it does not rub, but it is noticeable. Before you decide not to buy these based on this alone, I would suggest trying them out - if they do not work Zappos will take them back. I almost did not get these because of how many reviews that said this but after wearing them all day the first few days I am so glad that I decided to give them a try. They feel almost like slippers. The best thing about these shoes for me is the footbed support. The 7W suited my arch exactly, and the arch is nicely padded. The shoes are extremely flexible in movement and they look lovely with dress pants or jeans. I have been strictly a Clarks shoe gal for years, but the arch support and heel height have been a problem for me in recent years, and there is not a lot of softness in business shoes, so I thought I would try these. I want dress shoes that I can wear through the airport, running down a taxi, hauling luggage up and down stairs and all the while feel stable in my feet. There is nothing worse than your feet throbbing while doing all that - these shoes have made working on my feet as a business woman very pleasant. The sole, sides and heel are cushiony, so my feet feel a lot less fatigued after long days of trotting and travel. I am going to try one of the boot styles from Cobb Hill next - they offer a lot more options in lower heel height that my previous brands, with far more style. That is a nice plus.

This shoe was an incredibly comfortable shoe right out of the box, though it didn't feel like a true wide width. It's a great "wear to work" shoe, and I can run errands at lunch without having to change shoes.

Quality shoes! These shoes were exactly what I was hoping for. I have a very difficult foot to fit- wide with bunions and a skinny heal. The lacing on these allows me to adjust the fit so they stay on my foot when I walk. They also have great treads (important in winter). They are not the sexiest of shoes, but they are cute enough if you can work with the vintage vibe. Seriously considering getting another pair as backup!

Wow, finally. Cobb Hill is New Balance's gift to women. It actually is like walking in a gym shoe. I love the styling of this shoe, looks like a wing tip with a heel. I have a 7.5 in another Cobb Hill shoe and an 8 in this one.

First I ordered my usual size, (7.5, W), but they were a bit snug. Immediately returned them for size 8,W. Now I love them and want to wear them everywhere. They look great with dress pants or jeans.

At last, at long, long last, I have found a shoe that is cute, comfortable, and practical for fall in New England. I have a bunion that makes it difficult to find shoes that don't make me want to cry, either from pain in my foot or pain in my eyes from how ugly they are. I tried, literally, 6 pairs of oxford shoes before I found these. Thank you Cobb Hill! You are awesome!! Thank you ZAPPOS!!

I thought this would be a cute and comfy shoe for fall. Unfortunately, it is extremely tight! I believe this would only work for someone with a very narrow foot and low instep. I'd go up another size, but then heel would be too loose. Unfortunately I will be returning them. I recently bought 2 pairs of Clarks Hamble Oak - muuuch more reasonably sized.

This shoe is great! Super comfortable -- holds my foot snug without being too tight, has arch support, the right amount of heel (small, and looks nice. Thrilled.

This was my first time to buy Cobb Hill brand shoes and they were very comfortable right out of the box. The heel is just right and the padding inside is wonderful. I wear them with slacks but also with a skirt and tights and they look good on my feet. The rounded toe is very comfortable and the style, while not super dressy still looks good.

LOVE these shoes! Cute enough to wear with a skirt or pants and very comfortable. I have a need for very strong arch sorry and these could have been a little better on that front, but everything else is perfect. Going to get a pair in black as well... Thanks to Cobb Hill for carrying at least some of their shoes in a 12!