Customer Reviews SOREL Winter Carnival™

I really like these boots. I was looking for warm pack boots and these qualify nicely. I have rather square shaped feet and these are roomy enough for me. I ordered a half size up because I wear them with heavy socks. The bottoms are flat without a raised heal.

Awesome versatile boot! So cute too!

Love!! I was skeptical about everyone saying to size down since I have wide feet, so I didn’t at first but I ended up having to exchange for a smaller size. They are so cute and comfortable in the snow! Definitely worth it.

Very cute. Especially with leggings!

I recently moved to Maine and realized I needed a good pair of boots for the snow and ice. I have narrow feet and was hesitant to order the Snow Carnival as some people thought they ran wide. However, with Zappos excellent return policy I felt I had nothing to lose. I ordered my regular size 7.5 hoping I would have room for Smart Wool socks. I am so glad I took the chance on these boots. They fit well with wool socks and are warm and comfortable with enough room to wiggle my toes (which is essential in cold weather boots). They arrived several days ago just before the last snow storm. I found they break in quickly and look stylish with leggings or jeans. Also, there is room to tuck in pants. Easy on and easy off. Thanks Zappos for a great service and a great price.

I’ve had my eye on these boots since last year. With the mixed reviews on sizing I was hesitant to order them. I ordered a half size up to accommodate thick socks and I have plenty of room without feeling squished. I could’ve probably gone with my true size but I wear thicker socks in the winter and wanted the extra room. I didn’t find these to be too narrow as some people did. I like the overall look and feel of the fabric upper. It’s not stiff and you can comfortably tuck your pants into your boots. We get a lot of snow here so dry pant legs are a must. These are warm but not too warm that your feet get hot. I can comfortably wear these all day without issue.

I normally wear a 7.5, so I ordered 7.5 in these boots, and I had plenty of room even with my thick wool socks, which I always wear with winter boots. They are still roomy, I might have even been able to pull of a 7 but I am happy with the fit. They are a bit clunky to walk in, and I did worry my feet looked a bit large in them, but who cares? I adore these boots. I had my eye on several different kinds of Sorel boots, and finally decided to take the plunge after some other boots did not work out. I am so happy I did. These are great quality, waterproof, warm, and in my opinion they look great. Sorel you did not disappoint! I look forward to having these for many winters to come.

I originally ordered my usual size and when I got them they were huge on me. I went down a half size and they fit really well in the toes but the heel space is fairly wide still for my feet but comfortable. I can feel my heel slide up and down (even with thick socks) when I walk but they are super warm and comfortable. And the exchange procedure was super quick and simple.

What a great boot! They were just too heavy to walk around in. I feel I would only wear them to shovel snow and I have a Sorel that's light weight that I will just wear.

Great boot, way too big in my normal size.

Since I can't edit my previous review, I will just add that these boots are warm even without socks. It's very cold here in NY right now, and I've been using these for several days without socks (because they were tight). Now that I've worn them, the lining has tamped down a bit and I am able to wear regular (not thick) socks, but good to know I can get by without them and still be toasty warm.

Great, warm. I’m 5’4” 120lbs with skinny ankles and order 1/2 down from my normal size. I found these to be comfortable and slightly clunky, but I wanted substantial snow boots and these fit the bill. Compared to the sorel Caribou these are a bit slimmer, lighter, and come to a more natural height on my calf which since I’m petite the proportions matter. I found the caribou to be huge inside (even after sizing down 1/2 size) and they just made my foot look huge. I wear my carnivals for playing in the snow with kiddo, running errands, and general out and about in the yucky cold months of Chicagoland. Love Zappos, they make it so easy to get a couple pairs and return the ones I don’t want. Easier than shelping to a department store for me.

Love these boots. True to size warm, beautiful color. I keep laced loosely for easy on and off.

Love these boot....Very comfy and warm. As stated in other reviews, they do run big. I normally wear a size 10 but ordered a 9.5. Fits perfect. Style is cute and feminine with the Sherpa cuff. Highly recommend.

These boots are very stylish and definitely water proof. I also like that the liner comes out so that you can wash them if need be. I can wear these daily. I did find my toes feeling a little cold when I wore them in the snow, but may just have needed thicker socks.

i love them!

Boots are great however I should have listened to the other reviews on size. These run huge!! I’m a 7.5 and I ordered a 7. Still too big so a 6.5 is on its way. Hope that’s the right fit.

Bought these for my 13 year old daughter - she loves them. We're the same size so I tried them on - extremely comfortable and very warm. They run large - ordered a 9, her usual size, and they were too big. Ordered the 8.5 and they're perfect.

I love these boots. They are super cute and comfy. I think they will keep my feet warm and dry for our snow trip. I ordered my normal size, 7-1/2, and they fit well but will have plenty of room for thick warm socks. As always.....STELLAR SERVICE with Zappos!! You guys ROCK!!

Got these in today and they are precious! The purple is a great/rich color and so pretty! They do feel about a half size too big, I’m an 8.5 and ordered an 8.5, and I’m going to keep them because I think they will be perfect with thicker socks. They were easy to get on and off and felt comfortable walking in them. They are stiff around the back of the foot/ankle, so I don’t know how they will feel after several hours. I bought these with the intent of having them for several years, since I don’t live where we get a lot of snow. They are going to the Smokies with me for NYE! Hoping for some snow!

Got these for the cold weather in Colorado! Love them!