Customer Reviews Reef Sandy Love

I ordered a size 10 and it was too short. My heels were hanging off. I've worn reefs for about 10 years and they've all worked well. These new ones run too short so had to return them. They didn't have a size 11 in the style I wanted. I'm pretty bumbed because my old ones are gone(had them for 6yrs) so I needed a new pair. Please go back to the old styles and sizes.

Sizing was too small, I had previously bought diff shoes from this website that's fit perfectly, but there was a substantial diff between the "same" size , very disappointing

I love Reef flip flops and I tried two different pairs of this model because I wanted something in brown. Both pairs had the same problem: the soles are so slippery on hard-wood floors that I am afraid to wear them inside. They are fine outdoors and on carpet but but I am hoping they wear down a bit so I can wear them indoors.

Straight out of the bag the cloth straps on this shoe we're very loose. My thought if the straps were this loose now what'll happen after a few wears? I should have returned them but I'm bad about not doing that. I would not recommend these unless you have a super wide foot then maybe they'd work for you.

Colors are great, fit is great, but the bottoms are too slick to feel safe.

I was so disappointed when I received the flip flops because they had not arch at all. I've had two pairs of Reef flip flops with great arch support and was excited to be replacing my current pair which is wearing out after a few years of much use. Sadly, I will be returning this pair.

These have been my favorite flip flops for forever. I ordered a new pair recently, and they don't stack up to previous pairs. Reef changed the sole. It is very rigid and doesn't contour to my foot. Even worse, it's very slippery and has no traction. I nearly wiped out several times. I tried washing the flip flops and waking on concrete to break them in, but it's not working.

I wrote a review 2 months ago. I am SO disappointed with my Sandys. I've faithfully purchased size 9 for years, so I had no hesitation purchasing that size again (I bought THREE pairs! ). Unfortunately, the sizes are completely off! At least a half size-if not a full size too small! If you're planning on purchasing, size up!!

I returned these sandals because they did not have enough cushion. The straps also rubbed the top of my feet. Overall they felt heavy and were uncomfortable.

I had a pair of black ones for years, size 10, the size I wear for everything including the Sandy. Ordered a new pair and they were TOO SMALL. So sad...sending back and they don't have 11s in the color I ordered. Disappointed. From other reviews, it appears as though they may be using a new manufacturing site and many others have complained that the flip flops are now running small.

Been wearing the sandy for years. I'm a 7 1/2 and have always gotten a size 8. Ordered a new pair and the 8 is too small. Very disappointing as the 9 is too big.

Not long or wide enough

I liked the shoes but no way were they a size 6. I had to send them back. If they had been sized correctly I would have liked them a lot

Loved my old Reefs. So comfortable. But these new ones are a size smaller in length and width. I returned them the week of January 15. Have not heard anything!

Will need to return for larger size. Ordered the same size I have worn in the past but these are measuring 1/2 inch shorter in length and width than previous ones purchased. These have been my favorite flip flops for years but they seem to have been reduced in length and width. I will return for a size up and try that.

I've been buying the Reef Sandy for years. It's my favorite flip flop. Last season I bought a new pair of black ones to replace my loved ones and I couldn't even get my foot in them. All of a sudden they seem to be too narrow, almost like the cut changed. Couldn't even get my foot in to see if they'd break in.

This is my FAVORITE reef flip flop I have 5 pairs from previous years and they are the best! This year's style is NOT the same! I ordered the exact same size and it is literally an inch shorter, which sucks because I wear an 11. I can't just go up a size. I'm very disappointed in reef's decision to make the sizes smaller. It doesn't make sense when people have larger and larger feet. Where's the size 12 if I can't wear an 11 now? All I can think is they changed manufacturers or something. Please make them bigger again these are my favorite flip flops!

I purchased these after borrowing my D-I-L's sandals. These had none of the arch support or "feel" that I wanted. They look cute but they don't feel like the older version. Considering returning.

I thought this was the same style I've bought twice before, but it just doesn't fit the same way. The flip flops I currently have are my favorite style and they fit perfectly. I wish I could find another pair. I thought I purchased the wrong size, so I bought these again in a larger size, but still wasn't right. I even had the associate recommend other options when I called for a return label.

not the same as I usually get not soft material they are stiff....hopefully they will soften up other wise I love Reefs

Seems like great quality and would be comfortable... if they fit. I've been a size 9 in Reef Sandy flip flops for the last decade at least (8.5 in regular shoes.) These are at least half an inch shorter than my old Sandy size 9s from 7 years ago or so. It's unfortunate because that extra 1/4 or 1/2 inch would make a big difference! Sadly will have to return, not sure if a size 10 will be huge for me.

So, I ordered a size 7 to replace the current ones of the same size and style, but the ones that got delivered are so much smaller. I'm going to have to return them and order new ones. It's just strange. And kind of a pain in the butt, but oh well I guess. The quality still seems great, and I look forward to getting a new pair that fit because I loved my first pair (that I've had for probably 5+ years) that just need to be replaced.

I ordered women's size 8 (which is my normal shoe size) and couldn't come close to squeezing my foot in it. They ended up fitting my mom who is wears a small women's size 5&1/2 - 6. Maybe there is something in the sizing chart saying you should order 2+ sizes larger than average. But obviously I missed that note. It was very disappointing. However, I love the brand and the quality.

I have worn Reef flip flops for years. I did not realize the pair I purchased online ran quite a bit smaller than the pairs I already have; beyond the time of returning. They are too small for me to wear. I am not sure if they were mismarked or the sizing has changed.