Customer Reviews Reef Sandy Love

Please know this flip flop runs small. Go up a full size from what you typically wear.

Arrived at Reef due to Teva's unfortunate discontinuation of the original Mush flip flop. I like a moderately thick sole with alot of cushion and the cloth strap is a must have for me. I've been happily married to the Teva Mush for over 10 yrs so I was hesitant about this purchase. I was pleasantly surprised! These flips required no breaking in, the upper is comfortable from the start and not too tight. High quality construction, should last a long time. The only criticism I have is I would prefer more cushion in the sole. This pair is cushy but only mildly so while I'm used to walking around on pillows :) Overall highly recommend these flips.

I've worn these flip flops for years, buying a pair every 6 months, but the sizing has changed, they run small now.

Order a size up! They do not exchange you have to return

If you are a 7 always please be aware of they run small so order a 8 so they fit perfectly..

I wear them 10 months a year. But I can no longer find the colorful ones that were always my favorites, and the black ones don't fit the same. I'm giving the old ones 5 stars--the new ones are more like a 3. Since I can't put that on my review, I'm giving 4 stars as an average. Sizing has always been a little erratic, which makes it hard to order them through the website.

While I have had no issues with my reef flipflops, I can honestly say that they are not the same as when I had purchased the first pair. I hope these will last just as long as the other pair. If the company chose to outsource for the manufacturing of this product, that might the cause of the change.

Always bought a black pair and a brown pair each time. Recently can not find my brown pair anywhere. So havent bought anymore. What is the deal? Why cant we get brown ones anymore? This was the only style I really like. Would recommend to everyone. We just need the brown back. Thank you!

I have always loved REEF and buy a new pair every year! (I'm really hard on my flops) This year they seem a bit tighter. I've already started wearing them so I really hope they stretch out a bit.

I have always loved Reef Sandy's but have recently switched to Teva Mush 2 because you no longer have any color selection for this shoe! Very unfortunate because I love them but want something besides black. They used to come in all kinds of great colors

I normally love these flip flops but the last pair I ordered, the straps are for a wider foot for some reason. The shoe fits very loosely :(

I HAVE A PAIR IN BLACK AND BROWN. WOULD LOVE A PAIR IN WHITE, NAVY AND PICK THAT WERE AVAILABLE IN THE PAST. WHAT HAPPENED TO ALL THE COLORS. SO SAD.

I used to buy a couple of new pairs of these every year but your lack of color variety has made me switch to Teva Mush ll. I like Reef Sandy's better but want more than just black.

I use my flip-flops as daily wear. These are wide, stable, and good looking, BUT, the left one is defective between the toes. It folds the wrong way and cuts into my flesh. The right one is perfect and oh-so-comfortable. I didn't want to return them because it took me a long time to find the right flip flop. I just wish the left one were sewn correctly. I sure would love it if you could send me a left one in size 10 that is inspected to have the right inverted fold (size 10). They run small, so one MUST order a whole size up. They could afford a bit more arch support, but I love them either way.

Couldn't wait to have a new pair of Reef Sandy, they are comfortable and can be worn all day without causing tired feet. I have a neuroma on the right ball of my foot and this is the only sandal i can wear that will not cause it to flare up. Reef is making fewer colors and unfortunately this pair does cause the bottom of my feet to turn black due to them being new, hoping this will clear up soon.

Great quality. Bought this pair to replace a pair I bought about 15 years ago

I am a size 7 in every make and model of shoe, both in the US and internationally. I ordered a size 7 and had to return for a size 8.

Great shoe for casual wear.

Cute flip flops! I have wide feet and they stretch a little over a few wears, to make a perfect fit. My first pair lasted a few years so I am hoping these will do the same. And I love the variety of color choices! I bought black and the printed strap with pink and white.

I am a devoted reefs gal! I have worn reefs for 10 years since I picked them up in SoCal. Sandy's are great! They are comfortable and casual for walking around, hanging out with family or going to the store. I wear them with jeans or capris for everyday use. The shoe seems to mold to my feet. The strap is thick and comfortable. There is very little breaking in. The soles are a medium thickness and comfortable. The shoe is not too wide or too narrow. I have a average foot and its perfect. Very nice. My only complaint is that the shoe size is 1/2 a size too small. I wear and 8.5 to a 9; mostly a 9. I picked a size 9 since that is what I have always worn in reefs. My heel is about 1/8 an inch from falling off. I push my foot in most than I would with a true to fit shoe to make sure I have enough room in the heel. I would buy this pair again just in a bigger size. I would tell a friend about the above before they bought a pair. I bought another pair in brown at the same time and they are the same!

Great product!!! Have been wearing these for 15 years and love them!!!! Sizes do run small though. I normally take a 7 1/2 and got an 8 and I am just barely staying in it.

Comfy flip flops but they definitely run small.