Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Carlyle

Allen Edmonds are the only shoes my husband will wear. The color is perfect for brown, black or blue suits. Shipping was fast.

Bought for my nephew -- they were a big hit! Great quality.

Great dress shoe!! This was the first pair of Allen Edmonds that I purchased and I now have 9 pairs !! One word of advice, make sure you spend a little extra on leather lotion and polish. It will make a WORLD of a difference.

Really love the look of this shoe. One thing to note is the last on this shoe seems slightly wider than on my pair of Park Avenues.

Just purchased these shoes, they're very comfortable and aesthetically pleasing. I am size 11 in most all shoes, Nike/Vans/Hoka and size 43 in Birkenstocks. However, the 10.5D fit perfect for me, meaning these shoes run just a tad large. Great quality, great smell, very happy!

Great dress shoe, beautiful design if you're looking for plain-toe oxfords and excellent quality built.

Very nice shoe, first pair with you, still breaking them in. Maybe a 12 will fit better next time. Love'em!

The quality is exceptional! Shoes fit nice and snug; I've gotten tons of compliments and excited to take my business attire to the next level. Thanks!

I have several pairs of AE dress shoes and this one hit the same high mark I've come to expect. Comfortable, consistent size, nice modern color and durable.

My favorite shoe. Super comfy and the quality is inmatched. Ran a little narrow - I've always been on line between D and E - go with E if you have the same issue.

It's a beautifully made, great looking shoe, and it runs true to size. It also attracts compliments.

Great traditional shoe with totally dressed feel, I am pleased.

Bought them in December and am confident they are the most comfortable dress shoes I have owned. Love the quality and craftsmanship!

Purchased these for work very. Ice shoe and comfort

Took a leap of faith when purchasing my first pair of expensive dress shoesglad it was a pair of Allen Edmonds!

I needed new oxfords in black & brown. I ended up buying these and one in burgundy. I was looking at Ferragamo but decided that getting three very good shoes for the price of one made total sense. Also, I liked the idea of being manufactured in the U.S.

Fit a little tight, maybe due to not wearing dress shoes for a year. Great classic look/

Great shoe. Beautifully made. I expect the glove like fit to only improve with wear.

This is my second pair of Allen Edmunds dress shoes. They are phenomenally comfortable and durable. My first pair I purchased 8 years ago and i was able to have them re soled once as required since I used them daily both outside in the elements and in office. These shoes are amazing when new and can be converted into a casual wear shoe once distressed and weathered but, that will not happen unless you wear these through snow and rain for many years. Great investment!

These were a Christmas gift for my significant other and he LOVES them. Shoes: They look amazing and can be worn with the fanciest of suits or casual jeans. They molded to his (very difficult) feet with in 2 wears. In fact, he liked them so much, that we recently purchased them in black. Belt: Fits great and is an identical match to the shoes. This is hard to do with the chili color, too. But, it's perfect. The best part is that he's proud of how he looks. And, I love that!

I only wish AE provided two shoe covers instead of one. The website does not allow you to purchase additional ones. In my mind, this is value-add that separates AE from the competition.

The amazing thing about Allen Edmonds shoes is that after wearing them for a day out of the box, they feel as comfortable as shoes you've worn for years. The Carlyle is a classic oxford with clean lines. It pairs perfectly with a well tailored suit or slacks because the quality and craftsmanship complete a look without distracting from it. It will also "dress up" jeans for a smart casual look when needed. Pre-COVID, I traveled for business and counted on the comfort of my Allen Edmonds to survive long days navigating airports and business meetings. These are worth every penny.

Well constructed of excellent material. I plan on having this shoe for the next few decades. Thanks for making an incredible product at a fair price.

I like the product, this company makes a good pair of shoes.

I've enjoyed Allen Edmonds shoes for a long time. They ae expensive, but the quality makes them last. When this particular shoe came on sale, I just couldn't resist! In addition, because the quality is so good, the recrafting opportunity in the future is meaningful, allowing me to stretch the value even further. I've tried other brands thinking I might save a few dollars - never works out - go with the best!