Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

These are so cute!!! I ordered a half size larger than I would normally wear and they are perfect to put heavier socks in. Wide enough for my bunion. Not much arch but comfy. Can’t speak to warmth or wear yet but exactly what I expected. They look tiny and on sale you can’t go wrong! Buy them! I have a pair of Sorel Joan of Arctic and these are more comfortable for a lot less $

I wear a 7, ordered a 7 and they fit with normal winter socks (Smart Wool, nothing extra thick). I live in the PNW and we don't get ALOT of snow so I am wearing these when walking into town in the rain. My feet stay warm and dry and heck, they look cool too.

I followed other's recommendations to order a half size up, as they run small. Sure enough the fit was very good with room for my thick socks. My size would have been too snug. They are really cute, comfy and warm.

I like these boots a lot. It was hard for me to find a pair of winter boots that could handle New York weather but these have done well so far. My feet are medium width but long and flat so I’m always challenged in finding a shoes that are comfortable, stylish and can handle harsh winters. They are well made too. Hopefully they will last a couple of seasons with proper care.

I bought these for my 24 year old daughter as a Christmas gift. She just moved to Wisconsin over the summer and is facing her first winter there. She needed warm and waterproof boots, but she is super picky with shoes and has a hard to fit narrow and slight little foot. After reading all the great reviews, I decided to take a chance on these. It seemed the only negative reviews were people who thought they ran too narrow for them, but since we needed a narrow boot, it might work out fine. My daughter put these on her feet, adjusted the laces to fit her narrow calves, then has worn them every day since. No issue. Her feet are finally warm, and will stay dry during her treks to and from the bus stop. One happy mama here!

These boots are great! I have plantar fasciitis and at the end of the day my feet are killing me. I can wear these all day with no pain!! They are warm and have great traction outdoors! Easy on and off and look great too!!!

Great boot glad I bought it. Easy on and off, I’ve worn them with and without socks. I like that they tie up and adjust around the leg. Great buy!

I usually get a 9.5 or 10 narrow and got these in a 10 so an insole could be added if necessary. I did find them very roomy without the insole but after the insole was added they fit perfect. I love the style and would recommend them.

I sized up half a size based on other reviews, but I kind of wish I hadn't. They are a little big, but not so much that they aren't comfortable. They are very warm.

I love these boots. So many winter boots I have purchased in the past leave my toes feeling cold - not these boots! Not only are my toes toasty warm, but it offers great ankle support - great when you nearly slide down the entire driveway because it is coated in ice. The best part is that they are SO CUTE.

I read a lot of reviews on these boots. Most said they were true to size but I I normally wear an 8-8.5 and I ordered a 9. I'm glad I did. They fit just right with a normal sock. I might be able to wear a thicker sock for more warmth but I haven't tried that yet. They are comfortable and I have been testing them out by wearing them on polished concrete floors at my office. I'm not on my feet all day but do normal walking to and from my office all day long. I have RA and my feet hurt all day long and I have to say that when I wear these boots my feet don't hurt as much as when I wear my expensive Abeo's(orthotic shoes). That being said, the right boot is doing this weird thing where it creases right above my big toe and so there is some rubbing. This doesn't happen on my left foot and I don't have any bunions or hammer toe so I'm not sure what is happening. I'm hoping this won't affect my being able to wear the shoes. I plan to wear them in some wet snowy conditions and I do hope the waterproof part holds up as advertised.

Really cute, warm boots. Unfortunately, they hit me at exactly the wrong spot on the ankle bone. They bothered me just standing there, let alone walking. Sadly returned. I'd still recommend these boots to others if you don't have bony ankles! Don't forget to order a half size up.

I read the reviews and ordered one size up which let me insert my orthotic and the boots were perfect size and width ( I have a narrow foot). I wore a medium weight sock and my feet had plenty of room, support and warmth. Boots are cute, durable, warm, and waterproof too.

These fit well, provided great warmth, and are comfortable for all day walking through New York.

Great value for a cute, waterproof boot. Wore in New York in the rain, walked for miles in comfort.

Just got the Ice Maiden ll yesterday so I haven't really been out running around in them yet. I have a pair of tan Sorel Angels that are okay for warmth but I wanted a black pair of boots that are waterproof for when we go UTV riding this winter; as well as for everyday running around in the snow and cold of Wisconsin. I typically wear a 5 - 5.5 and ordered these in a black 5.5. I tried them on with a medium thickness sock and they fit perfectly. Upon walking around the house they felt very comfortable and light weight. My Sorels are heavier and compared to these new Ice Maidens ll were never this comfortable either. These Ice Maidens are really cute looking on and if they keep my feet toasty warm I'd say they will be a grand slam. Will update my review after I have had a chance to wear them in the snow and cold.

I walk...a lot... several miles everyday with our dog. Hence comfort is paramount. These fit the bill with the first time out. I live where it can be snowy and icy ...and these shoes worked well.

I ordered a half size larger due to other reviews, but it wouldn’t have been necessary. I think they’re true to size.

I have owned these boots for almost a year now and they are fantastic! They are super comfortable and warm. They are pretty stylish, maybe not quite as much as some boot that cost 2-3 times as much, but that trade-off is a no brainer for me. At this price point, some of the best winter boots I've ever bought, and I live in Minnesota!

I needed my first winter boots for my first real winter in Canada. I bought these a year ago and they've held up well. These are great for everyday use, maybe not the best for hiking or for work. They keep my feet warm and dry. I have annoyingly wide feet and these fit me well, no sliding or cramming my toes. Loved these so much I'm probably going to buy more from Columbia again.

I love these boots! Bought them for our upcoming trip to Iceland and can’t wait to wear them all over the place!

Great boots! By far exceeded my expectations!

I purchased these boots for a trip to Lapland, Finland and Sweden in the beginning of February, so it was quite cold with lots of snow. They were WONDERFUL! My feet were never cold and we did a lot of activities such as dog sledding and reindeer sledding. Everything was covered in snow and the boots were great. I wore heavy wool socks with them which is a must. The boots are Very supportive of your ankles and arch. I'd still be wearing them daily if I didn't live in a sub tropical climate!

Warm, cute, quick to tie. I like that they're tall'ish. Very little arch support, but I added my own inserts and I can walk for miles in these boots.

Love this boot. Unfortunately I read reviews to size up... do NOT size up unless you typically struggle with needing to do so. I sized up 1/2 a size and will need to return for my regular 9.5