Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

It's rare to see an item have a unanimous 5 star rating. These boots truly are super comfortable and work well for wide calves. Unfortunately one of the boots came with a manufacturers defect but Zappos quickly remedied that and are sending me out a new pair. I got the Elk color and they are really nice.

I can’t wait to wear them. Beyond being warm their very stylish.

Love love love these in red. Even cuter than expected. I wear 9.5 or 10 and went for 10 in these, no problems at all. Soft on inside and waterproof indeed! Good for mushy muddy late fall walks and I am guessing there is a good winter ahead. Columbia is hitting it out of the park for my particular foot/calves: thick calves, weak ankle from injury, previous torn Achilles, slightly narrow foot. Third pair of Columbia shoes in three years and they all hold up fabulously.

So comfy, big enough to wear with woolly socks. Feels like sneakers!

I read reviews and ordered a 1/2 size larger to accommodate wearing a liner and wool sock together for my trip to Iceland. My feet and toes had all the room they needed to be comfortable wearing these boots all day. This was the best purchase I made. The boots look exactly like pictured, they are super cute and super functional. They are also waterproof just like they say. I hiked in wind, rain, sleet and snow plus walked up creeks to waterfalls. My feet were never cold and they were never wet. Awesome, awesome boots! Will definitely purchase again when this pair wears out.

Wanted some boots that were reasonably serious winter footwear without looking clunky. These look quite nice for insulated winter boots. They also have soles that seem fairly sticky and good for icy conditions. I wore them around the house for a while and forgot I had them on which is a good sign. The insoles are comfortable if not super cushy. A good choice for a winter boot that looks okay as street wear too. There are more expensive brands in this category but it's a type of boot at which Columbia excels.

I really like these! They are sturdy and comfortable at the same time! They did great in the snow!

Super comfortable and as described, looking forward to wearing them in the snow!

This fit pretty well but I also got tried the next size and prefer it because I'll be able to wear thick socks.

Excellent fit, especially in such a small size-5. Cushy, and my wife loves them! Waterproof will be tested soon in Ireland....

Love these boots - but had to return them because they are "too warm" for me. I live in Georgia and wanted these for a trip to Alaska, plus be able to wear at home too. They are very cute and comfortable, but just a little too much for a Georgia girl. If you live in very cold weather - I highly recommend!

I love them!

Extremely comfortable and very warm. I worm them out of the box to as all day ski competition. It was very cold and my feet stayed warm. Love these boots!

Love these winter booths. best I've ever owned. they kept my feet warm during the winter months. Bought another pair as a gift

I bought these boots for a vacation to the east coast in case it rained or snowed there, and it served the purpose very well!

These boots are very comfortable, warm, waterproof and attractive. I wore them in deep snow in the country, and tramping city sidewalks. A great solution for snowy slushy winter weather. They are fairly light, and the quality is quite decent for the moderate price range. They were a little on the small side - I exchanged my usual size foe 1/2 size larger to accommodate winter socks. The boots are well lined and warm, but I wanted room for socks. The laces are a bit annoying - they slow down taking on and off, but on the up side they do allow custom adjustment of the ankle and calf fit.

I wore these in Iceland in April and my feet were toasty and comfortable. I took out the insoles and replaced with my orthotics to provide arch support. Great boots.

These boots are comfortable and kept my feet warm in the snow!

Loved them!!! Wore them in the cold snowy Alps and they were great