Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I'm in love with this boot! I was skeptical when the only size left on sale was a full size larger than my regular size but after reading the reviews I decided to try them. I was so surprised, they are a perfect fit! They are a very warm boot and really cute! They actually make my feet look smaller! They are the perfect winter boot without all the bulk!

These were an excellent deal. They're comfortable and fit perfectly. Love them. Maybe (maybe!) I'll actually look forward to the next winter. :)

Well, well! I had ordered these to try based on previous 5-star reviews, and the price (!). I've been looking for a pair of black, insulated, waterproof boots. I was hoping to find something a bit dressier, but after putting these on out of the box, I didn't want to take them off! These boots are amazingly comfortable. They fit my orthodic and an extra insole just fine, with room for toe-warmers, if I end up needing them. I usually wear a 7.5-8, but between the 8 and the 8.5 that I tried, I'm keeping the 8.5. I like having a bit of extra toe-room, and my ankles are secure in the boot even with the extra room. The size 8's toe-room was a bit tight with my orthodic in the boot. So, depending on the socks/insoles/warmers/orthodics that you plan to wear with your boots, you may want to try up a 1/2 size. Can't beat Zappos' shipping and return policies, and for the price, these boots are a great deal.

I typically wear an 8 or 8.5 in flats and sandals but always size up to a 9 in boots and sneakers---I ordered the 9 in these and they fit well. These boots are warm, comfortable, and nice looking. They seem to be legitimately waterproof. For my job it is sometimes useful to wear these in semi-professional / business casual settings and I've been able to get away with that in the all black version because it is sleek enough if I'm careful to tuck the ends of the laces in. I'd been waiting to upgrade my boots for a few years and I'm very happy with these.

The boot is extremely comfortable and very warm. They are also very stylish and I have gotten many compliments.

Overall, the price of this boot for the style and it being waterproof was great! I bought more comfy inserts and that made them perfect for me!

Great fit and price. Bought second pair for mom.

Perfect fit and so comfy and warm. I walked a long distance in them and they feel great. Cant believe I paid a quarter of the price of some other brands. Love these boots! And my husband thinks they are super stylish - bonus!

Loved the boots. Great for the snow!

Love my new boots. They look beautiful and fit like a glove, lol. Immediately went for a walk, and they are perfect. Looking forward to my Alaskan cruise next month to see how dry and warm they'll keep my feet.

Great boot. Keeps feet warm and dry.

Warm and comfortable, just what I was looking for.

Look good and feel warm.

Adore these. My go-to winter boot now in northern WI! Cute, comfy, dry and warm. Easy on and off. A winner.

Love it. I needed some snow boots for a trip at the last minute, and these were perfect. They fit really well and still leave enough room for thick socks. Plus, they’re lightweight.