Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Great boot, easy to put on, and excellent support. Saw all the great reviews, and they are true. Attractive enough for going into town, not just mud chores. Boot fits true to size. Glad they were on Cyber Monday sale!

I have the Ice Maiden slip on boot and love it so I thought I would try this style in a different color. I love this boot also. It looks cute, is pretty light for how rugged it is and is super comfortable. I only wish the soles had a little more grip like a hiking boot for slippery conditions. I ordered my regular size in a 9 and I thought it was a little tight with thick socks. So I exchanged them for half a size bigger and they fit perfect now. Great boots!

I love these boots! They are super cute. I wore them to work for about a week after I got them because it was cold and rainy. My feet stayed dry and warm but not too hot. They fit a little big. But I’m size 7-8 depending on the shoe. I got these in 7 1/2. I think the 7 would be too small. They’re a little stiff on the bottom. I kind of feel like I’m clomping a bit but they are comfortable for all day wear and don’t hurt my feet. I have plantar facititis and these boots don’t bother me which is really nice. I have been wearing them with regular crew socks so I think with thicker socks they would be more snug. I think they actually fit like they’re supposed to. From where my toe hits. They stay tied. These are great winter boots. I’m glad I bought them.

Ready for winter! These boots look great and feel comfortable.

Very comfortable boots! My daughter loves them and I got them for an excellent price.

These were at a good price on black friday and couldn't resist. They are comfortable and very warm in the Minnesota winter. I ordered a half size larger than my normal shoe size and they fit great.

Tested these out yesterday in a Buffalo snow storm. They were perfect! I went up a half size based on experience with other snow boots - I prefer to have them a little bigger so I can wear thick socks. They are a great fit! Not too big. They are really lightweight which is nice. You don’t feel too clunky walking around in the snow.

I love these boots. I took the advice of the other reviewers and ordered a half size up, and they fit perfectly. Very comfortable, no breaking in required. I got them for a trip to Michigan in winter, and they kept my feet warm (even with normal socks) and kept me from sliding around in icy, slushy conditions.

Love these -- I need to add an insole, as the support isn't quiiiiite there for me, but that's a small complaint. Great style, great comfort.

These boots are great. Comfortable, sturdy, and warm!

Love this shoe...one of the best shoe decisions I have ever made...they are warm, comfortable, easy to slip on or off overall a Great purchase.

I wear 8 or 8 1/2 and the 8 was a perfect fit. My feet are average width. I took these boots brand new to CO and walked about 10 miles in them, including 4 miles in the snow. They were comfortable, warm, and kept my feet dry. Definitely happy with my purchase.

I’m a true 6.5M shoe size and there is a real problem in the industry with sizing. For several years now I have repeatedly found that my size is either just too large or a bit to long. I have had to revert to buying a size six which are usually snug.

Very comfortable and warm but not too warm inside. I live in Northern MN and it's has not gotten to -40 F yet for me to try them in extreme cold but I wore them all day outside in 10 degree temps with snow 6in deep shoveled in spots and my feet stayed very warm and dry. I also wore them inside restaurants for 1 hour or so and they did not get unbearably warm. I walked miles in them and they were lightweight and comfortable. Very happy with my choice.

These are my first pair of winter boots & I LOVE them! They were super comfortable right from the start. I live in FL & was traveling to Germany!

I haven't actually worn the boots yet, as the weather hasn't required it, however, I am excited that I can pull out the insert and put in my pretty big orthotics into it. I am not used to wearing such tall boots in winter, so it feels a little more restrictive around the ankles, but I think I will like it when I have to walk from the car into work or shovel the driveway, or go for a walk in the snow...I live in Wisconsin.

Comfortable boot with adjustable laces. Roomy toe box for extra thick socks when needed. I did buy .5 size up and it was good.

These are so warm and comfy right out of the box! I took other people's suggestions from the reviews I read and ordered size 8, even though I'm normally a 7 for regular shoes and 8 in running shoes. They felt like they were slightly too big, so I expect them to be perfect when I wear thick socks and long johns.

I ordered them after losing 80 pounds thinking I didn’t need wide shoes, wrong!

These are honestly the best boots I have ever owned. They are so ridiculously comfortable it feels like you're wearing slippers. And they keep your feet very warm, we recently had a few inches of snow and I was able to play in the snow for a few hours in these. I highly recommend these!

I've been looking for a winter boot and I finally found one. I would have marked style all 5 stars, but it is a lace up boot. I would have preferred a zip up boot, but these were on sale AND they fit quite well with a pair of heavy socks. I did buy a size 10 boot, I usually wear a 9.5, but I am really glad I did! I have a jacket from Columbia bought over 10 years ago and I am still wearing it. I think Columbia makes quality products.

I went up 1/2 a size for thick socks and I really should have just stayed true to size because unless I wear thick socks they are too big, They are SUPER CUTE! Very comfortable and easy to put on and take off. I am very happy with my purchase and now I know dont size up at all with these!

Really nice boots. I tried them on and didn't want to take them off! Now I can't wait for it to snow!!!!