Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I have wide feet and am regularly an 8.5. After reading reviews that said it was true to size, I ordered an 8.5. I was concerned that it might be too narrow as most shoes/boots are that aren't sized for wide feet. I've worn them for a few weeks now and they are very comfortable, but they fit width wise which means if you have normal/narrow feet, these might be a bit wide for you. They also seem to be a tiny bit larger than an 8.5. I've worn them with and without socks to test the warmth of them (I live in New England) and they definitely keep my feet warm even when standing outside for hours. Overall, great boot. I would have ordered an 8 had I known they would be this roomy, but it's not that big of a deal. Satisfied and would definitely purchase again.

I usually wear a size 8 but I ordered size 8.5 because I have a lot of foot problems like plantar fasciitis. When I first wore this it felt so stiff but after wearing it a couple of times for a few minutes, it became so soft and comfortable for me. It was indeed bigger for my feet but when I inserted my orthotic it was perfect. I love the style too. I just haven't tried it on a wet snowy day yet because it hasn't snowed that much here in Philadelphia. But overall I love it and I would recommend it to anyone.

I absolutely love these boots I had bought a different style Of Columbia’s in size 8 and they were so tight I couldn’t wear socks. I exchanged them for these In size 8.5 and they are way too big, especially in the ankles. I think they’re a slightly wider boot then just medium with. So if your foot runs a little wide or you have big calves and ankles I think it will be very happy with these boots. I’m going to return for an eight and try that hopefully they’ll be a little more fitted; but not too small.

The boots fit nicely comfortable and warm

Love the boot. I wear a size 7 in a shoe but always order a half size bigger in a boot to accommodate a heavier sock. The Columbia Ice Maiden is a perfect fit. Not only is the boot stylish, it is comfortable and my feet were warm on a chilly winter day.

Usually wear a 7, ordered 7.5, Was too small. Returned for a 8, fits perfect.

Best boot for price

I am very happy with these boots. Very comfortable. Great service from Zappos!

Love these boots! Stylish and cute while warm and functional. Living in a ski resort in Idaho and walking to and from work in the snow, I needed something to replace my old Sorels and these were it. I am a Columbia fan now.

I usually wear a size 8-1/2 to 9. Recommendations were to size up so I first purchased these boots in size 9-1/2. They seemed a bit wide even with thick socks...so returned and re-purchased in size 9. They are warm and stay dry. I pre-treated fabric with silicone waterproof protection spray prior to use.

Comfortable enough for long walks, and nice and warm for the winter!

I love the fit of these!!

Fit: Flawless I wear 41 Birkenstock or Chaco Zx2 ladies' 10W sandals and the Columbia Ice Maiden IIs in 10.5 were perfect. Easy to wear with thin socks or thick socks with plenty of room for my toes to spread out. Comfort: Major! I work outside standing on concrete in a windy ventilated glass studio in North Carolina and need more warmth for my feet. I also have plantars fasciitis, bad ankles, and questionable knees; these are the most comfortable, supportive shoes I've had many years (including all my sneakers). Flexible yet substantial support in ankle area makes them my most comfortable pair of shoes for driving. Style: VERY CUTE They pair beautifully with all my casual winter wardrobe & have a surprisingly slimming effect on my huge feet! I love the understated interesting texture of the boots which they created by juxtaposing sections of velvety suede, quilting, dappled contrast leather, & faux fur. Smartly designed to facilitate ease of getting them on/off; I'm never annoyed by the laces like I have been with other laced boots I wore in the past.

I have the world's worst feet and normally I buy a wide shoe but I happened to try this one and it is incredibly comfortable and does not feel tight at all. I have neuropathy so my feet always feel cold, sort of a burning cold and the boots make them feel better because they truly do keep them warm. I live in Southern California, for me they are perfect for our chilly winters. I liked them so much I bought them in black and in gray as well.

Perfect boots for the Northeast.

The boots are very comfortable and keep my feet dry. I love the soft inside.

Well made, Comfortable, warm and provides excellent traction on snow and ice. These will be my go to winter boots for years to come!