Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Aubrey

Well made shoe. Felt snug in the toe area. The shoe felt somewhat off balance on my foot. Also, the shoe is more casual looking in person that what appears on the website. Returned it for a different style.

I know how good this could be, which makes me sadder. Pre-Rockport, Cobb Hill wide shoes fit me so well. I now find them terribly narrow as I do with Rockport shoes. These fit like any other brand's regular width would. I'm trying to replace my Cobb Hill with New Balance pair. They last a long time and are well made... now only if they would fit my wide foot.

Even though the width was okay for my toes, my arch is not very high so it seemed the arch area was too narrow for my foot.

Cute shoe but definitely wasn’t wide enough for my foot. Had to return.

These shoes accomplish the goal of having a summery shoe that covers your toes. I have bunions, and even the wide width isn’t quite wide enough. As a result, they hurt my feet. I am keeping them, as I’ve already worn them to work a few times. I was hoping they would stretch, but so far, I take them off every break I have. If you don’t have bunions, thay will probably be a good choice.

Super cute but very cheap shoe. I am now on a mission to find this in a similar style in a better class of shoe.

Squeaks when walking. Noisy in an office setting because of this. The comfort outweighs the embarrassment however.

Squeaks when walking. Otherwise excellent.

All of my 3 pairs of this Cobb Hill Aubrey shoe squeak! Kind of annoying because like Captain Bligh, you can always tell when I’m coming. The squeaking is the only deficit. They are very comfortable though and very pretty.

I like that these shoes are comfortable but somewhat dressy. The materials are soft and breathable. I don’t like the heel strap. It is too expansive. It sticks out past the back of the shoe and doesn’t keep my foot in place.

Ordered a 6W. The shoe length was fine and the toe box itself was fine (toes were not cramped), however, it was too tight at the widest point across my foot. In addition, the ankle strap was too short and I could not fasten it. Very odd fit, it's not as if I have fat feet or large ankles ;-). I have other Cobb Hill shoes that fit well, however this was the first sandal I tried from them.

I adore this shoe, but sadly the left strap cut into my foot badly. I really don't want to chance it for stretching out. Returning.

These have got to be one of the most narrow Cobb Hill shoes I've tried on! I ordered a wide size and it fit more like a narrow! I couldn't even walk in these. So disappointing considering there are so many good reviews - I really wanted to like them. There should be an Extra Wide option, but alas, there isn't.

I ordered this in navy blue to go with a number of outfits I have. It is a cute, comfortable shoe but it is NOT navy blue. Having paid a lot for shipping, I will keep it and find something to wear it with but I thought I should warn others. It is more of a medium-dark, grayish blue than the very dark blue that constitutes navy. I will admit that in the picture it does not look navy either. I would also say that the picture is a bit different from the actual color as well which is a bit duller but is generally representative. However, the description said navy and navy it is not.

So comfortable straight out of the box. The arch support and lining are perfect. I bought the blue multi color, and I scuffed the toe of one shoe slightly the first day I wore these shoes. Despite that light scuff, all of the color came off of the toe and I had to use a blue marker to color the scuff mark so that I could get through the day. So, I am taking a few stars off for durability.

The buckle strap on these shoes are to short. I have pretty normal feet and could only get to the first hole and it was very tight. These are going back!

Most comfort for a sturdy pump....good toe room, a pinch on the bunion toe, and hope that it gives better. The foot pad helps for all over comfort but beige color on the sides of the pad do not flatter the shoe. Buckle strap needs more elastic stretch to ease on and off. Otherwise after trying to get into a dress pump, this shoe is well designed. The non slip sole & heel are quiet & secure overall better than the other leather pumps which I had to return, Zappos return and tech help are superior, that is why I shop here.

I absolutely loved the design and quality, however the color once I saw it in person and tried it on was not stylish and made me feel like I was wearing granny shoes. I asked my boyfriend and he said “uhhh no”, and I agree. It’s a bit of a bland geriatric hue of tan for such a well designed shoe. I will be returning and considering an alternative color if I decide to reorder.

Oh, I wanted these darling shoes to work on my feet!! Unfortunately, across the width of my toes & joints, even after wearing them around my carpeted living room for a while, they still hurt my feet. So disappointed!!! I'm returning now and looking for a snazzy dance shoe with a small heel that I can wear all night!!!

These shoes run extremely small! I could barely get my foot in the shoe.

Cute shoe, but color is not Navy. It is a medium slate blue. Does not go with the navy clothes it was intended for. Also is narrow. I am almost always a medium, especially in Cobb Hill brand. These will be going back. Otherwise, good quality.

I have bunions and hammer toes, so I can't wear open-toed sandals. I ordered these in a black and a white 8.5 W because I knew the closed toe would suit me. But although the size was just right and I love the shoe and the style--it's versatile and could be worn nearly all year round--the toebox isn't actually "wide," but more like a "narrow wide" (which is actually how it looks in the product page shot of the sole). I also found it very hard to fasten the buckle without going through contortions. I didn't want to try stretching the toe box with a shoe stretcher, so I'm returning it (sadly). May eventually order it in a 9 W, but I doubt that the half-size will make much difference in the width.

Not real leather over whole top as advertised, just the toe & the little tab at the top of the T-strap, balance is fake leather. Very comfortable over all, but disappointed, because I wanted 100% leather top as advertised.

The toe was too narrow but the heel was too wide.

I oder size 8.5, but this shoe is half size larger than marked