Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Really

I usually wear a 9 or 91/2. The 9 was perfect. I have pretty narrow feet so these were a little wide but not as mush as some others. Love! I’m ordering in more colors.

These are SO CUTE! However they're too big on me. I ordered my normal size (8.5) and have to return them for a half size smaller because they're falling off of my feet. I don't have particularly narrow feet but have found this to be the case with many Dr. Scholl's shoes. They feel SUPER comfy though and I love how they look. Looking forward to getting a pair that will stay put :)

Although these shoes are exactly what I was hoping for and have, what seem to be, a very comfy foot bed - I will be returning them because the opening sits terribly against my bunions :( One of the other reviewers said they had toe cleavage with these shoes which worried me, however I didn't seem to have that problem. For anyone else that has bunions I would recommend looking for a different shoe.

These are really nice looking--I ordered the Merlot to wear with a navy dress and burgundy earrings. They're cute and have a nice shine with a sleek shape and style. As noted in other reviews, they are not particularly comfortable and I'm worried about wearing them all day. They also pinch below the little toe and then are unexpectedly a bit too wide toward the arch and heel...just a bit shy of the Minnie Mouse look. I was surprised because they're Dr Scholl's, so I expected a better fit, but then again the reviews indicate that the fit is uncomfortable. But they are so cute and perfect for fall, so I'll keep them.

Returning because I didn't like how my toes showed at the top-it's pretty pointy. Also, there is no arch support which is important as I stand most of the day. The memory foam was comfortable and it is super cute.

Overall, good comfortable shoe, but too narrow so it rubs near the side of the toes. I bought these almost 2 years ago and they've held up nicely and are wearable but run narrow on someone that usually can wear regular width fine.

I'm a solid 8, can usually order shoes blindly in an 8 and they work out. I was nervous after reading reviews, but ordered an 8 and they fit great. I do have a tiny peak of toe cleavage, but not enough to bother me, less than 1/4 of an inch. Nice and supportive, I walk 15 minutes to my office each day, and am looking forward to wearing these during my walk, much more support than regular flats. So far no pinching in my heel either. Very happy with this purchase! I got the leopard and may consider other colors.

I bought the Merlot Patent in two sizes. I typically wear a 6, but find that on occasion, a 6.5 fits better ( like w/ my Taos sneakers).The 6 was painful at the "corners" of the top of the shoe- moreso on the pinkie toe edge than the big toe. And, if I bent my foot, simulating if you stood on tip-toe or crouched down, the shoe felt short, pulling against my heel. So I tried the 6.5, but it was too loose and slipped when I walked. I didn't experience the same pinching/binding on the sides at the front, but they clearly weren't going to work for me.I would note that the color was less purple or burgundy than I expected. Instead, there was a great deal more brown or grey to it. Not necessarily a bad thing, but perhaps not what some purchasers would expect. It gave a more muddied, muted effect, but that probably makes it work even better as a neutral shoe that can be worn with many outfits.I wanted to like the shoe. But, it just didn't feel comfortable standing in it and doing a small amount of walking around the house. These days, with how much I'm on my feet for work, I'm not interested in breaking on shoes or tolerating painful feet. While I typically wear medium width shoes, I do have a foot that leans toward the wide end of the spectrum rather than the narrow end. So for those whose balls of the feet aren't much wider than their heels, this shoe just might for the bill. The insole certainly felt comfy (another reason I wished the shoe worked for me!)

These are cute and fit well with enough support to get me through a whole day at work. I bought these to match an outfit but wanted something comfy enough to live in. Color is perfect!

I really love the comfort, print, and the overall shape of the shoe but they are too "low cut" on the toes... I can't decide if the toe cleavage is going to make me return them or not, because otherwise I love um!

These are cute and very comfortable, especially compared to most flats that I usually find. A lot of cushion. Cuter than I expected from Dr. Scholl's. Love the real fur. Makes them look much more expensive than they actually were.

I needed professional looking black flats for work that wouldn't destroy my feet after a long day. These fit the bill. I am typically a 6.5 in flats but based on previous reviews I ordered the 6. It was the right call. They don't have a ton of support (these aren't running shoes people) but they certainly have more than any other pair of flats I've ever owned. I've worn them at least three full days now and have no complaints. They are definitely the best flat for your buck.

These are exactly what I wanted- plain black flats that look good. My mistake was wearing these without socks right away- and the back of them cut up my ankles. I've learned from my mistake and yesterday I walked more than a mile in them with no problems. I am not easy on shoes, and I wear flats so that I can do any kind of walking I want in them- these are very comfortable in general, and seem to be avoiding scuffs nicely

I'm now on my fourth pair of these shoes. They are SOOOOOOOOO comfortable, I walk ~8-10 miles a day but I still have to look cute and sophisticated (so no sneakers), and these shoes save my feet. The leather is normally soft (depends on the batch you get, sometimes it's stiff at first but you can condition it to soften it up) so there's no blisters. This is only true for the natural leather - the patent and vegan leathers are super stiff and do cause blisters. The downside is that they don't last a super long time - the area where the upper connects to the sole wears out relatively fast (for me) and leaves me with a flopping heel. The insole padding also flattens out after awhile, making them a bit less comfy. I buy a new pair every 4-6 months or so (but again, keep in mind I wear these almost every day, including in the rain, for 8-10 miles a day, so that's a lot more use than the normal person). They are cheap enough that I don't mind replacing them regularly, it's still a good value for the price. I HIGHLY recommend these for people who like to look cute while traveling or people who have to do a lot of standing or walking for work but can't wear sneakers. These will be a godsend!

So, I really like the style and look of these shoes. However, I definitely ended up with my skin rubbed raw on the back of my heels after wearing them one day. I really like the look however and want them to work so I'm going to put a adhesive cushion on the heel and see if it helps.

These shoes were comfortable and felt true to size except maybe a little wide. I ended up receiving a similar pair as a gift (ivanka trump brand) right when I bought these. These were more comfortable but looked cheaper, so I ended up returning these.

I really like the feel of these shoes but the leather, especially the toe, has just gotten chewed up from typical parking lot, car to office, walking. I've been wearing them less, despite the comfort, because I think they are starting to look sloppy from that toe wear.

This is a step up from the basic pointed toe flats you would find at Target or Payless. More comfortable but not the most comfortable of flats. No crowding or pinching, decent support.

I needed a basic flat and I am pleased with these. They are comfortable right out of the box. I ordered a wide width shoe and was pleased that the shoes fit comfortably.