Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Really

At first I loved these shoes, they were comfy and cute so I bought not one but two pairs. But within less than two weeks of wear on BOTH pairs the covering on the inner-sole as started to lift so my toes can feel extra fabric. So annoying. Also, they hold on to smells FAST! I keep my feet clean, I shower at least once a day, I work in an office, and yet within less than one month of wear in both shoes they are stinky. Like so bad I stopped wearing them and have put them outside (why haven’t I trashed them? I don’t know). It’s funny because I have other Dr. Scholl’s shoes with what I can tell are the same insoles and they’re fine - no stench and no fabric separation. But both pairs of this shoe have done the same thing to me. And I wore one pair after “wearing-out” my second pair in less than a month. Pity because they are uber cute and when I wear them people always comment how cute my shoes are. If only they knew the smells and texture I am hiding.

These shoes are lovely at first. Comfortable and fashionable, but after 3 wears the front tip is already worn and white of the shoe is showing through. Will be sending them back to Zappos for a refund!

Worst shoes ever!! I was looking for a comfortable work flat and thought a Dr. Scholl would be comfortable and supportive. I was so far from the truth! I have high heals that are way more comfortable than these. The material is so firm that causes a lot of pressure points and blisters. I tried adding protective pads to the heal, top of my shoe where it meets my foot, but nothing helps. I even tried walking around the house in very thick socks to help stretch them out. After many days of trying to make them work I finally gave up, wayyyy to painful.

Terrible! I wore them for a 10 minute walk and was bleeding on my heels. Beyond awful

I thought Dr. Scholl's would be super comfortable and have some arch support, but noooo. W was wide enough but slighty short

I ordered these b/c I was told they were extremely comfortable, however, as soon as I tried on the shoe, I could immediately feel the rim of the shoe digging into my skin, so I'm returning them. I'm sure not all of there shoes are like this, but so far, I'm not a fan.

I tried these on in store and they felt great. I ordered them and got them on my feet and they felt great - for 10 minutes. But there's something about how they cut across my feet, and in particular how the shoes have no give in that area, that made them incredibly uncomfortable to walk in. I walked around in them for less than an hour and have three blisters on my toes. They're going to the resale shop. Really disappointed.

Super cute shoe but...the lip of the shoe dug into my foot and was too painful to wear. Had to return.

I thought these were great at first, but halfway through the first time wearing them out, the top of the back of the shoe started rubbing my ankle. I wound up with blisters on both sides. I tried to fix the problem with (ironically) Dr. Scholl's rub relief strips from CVS but they show from the sides and make the shoes look cheap. Sadly it is too late to return these.

These shoes were so very disappointing. I bought them because these shoes looked like a cute flat, and I assumed they would be comfortable because they are Dr. Scholl's and because other reviewers were so full of praise for them. Wrong. They were really awful. The shoe is cheap plastic, and the plastic digs in just underneath the toes. They weren't comfortable at all, and I didn't' bother walking around in them to find out if they would get better because I didn't want to scuff the bottom since I knew I would be sending them back. Additionally, the cordovan color in person is much browner than it looks on my monitor.

If you want the back of your ankle to get ripped apart, get these shoes. I thought Dr. Scholl's shoes were supposed to comfortable!

I walk to work and am pretty picky about my flats - I thought I'd take a shot on these as the reviews about the insole were so positive. They were a little bulky looking, but (as reviewed) the insoles were crazy comfortable. I was a little bit worried about the heel, but walked to work in them the next day. These shoes are torture. I walked a half of a mile in them and it was a bloodbath. If you are in to the socks + flats look or you dig standing in place, then go for it...otherwise, steer clear. Ouch.

This shoe is very wide. The width of my foot is somewhere between narrow and medium and a familiar complaint of mine is that flats tend to flay out along the outside edge when I take a step, but I keep trying and occasionally succeed in finding a cute pair that hug my feet just right. I've had good luck with Dr. Scholl's in the past and love the polka dot so decided to check these out. The width was disappointing but the pony hair (a new material option for me) was disappointing as well; I had slipped the shoes on my feet, walked across the room to check them out in the mirror and removed them - what I saw then was that the pony hair had literally begun to separate around the top edge of the shoe giving it the look of threadbare fabric...not pretty and not something I would consider wearing even if these had been a fabulous fit. Back to Zappos they go.