Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Really

I wanted to love these. However, they are way to narrow across my foot, even though I don't have wide feet. Sadly, returning.

Nice looking shoe. But definitely felt smaller than marked. Top of shoe cut into foot

These are adorable and were comfy, but I'm normally a size 6 and they were massive. Somewhere between a half and a full size too big. Bummed they don't come in a 5.5

So horrible. My sister and I both got this pair - so cute and a great price. We walk a lot living in two big cities so Dr. Scholls seemed like the perfect option. Sadly, we both ripped our feet apart in these. Cuts and blisters all over our feet, from multiple wears. It never got better so we have gotten rid of them. So painful to wear.

The color and material looked cheap, and the cut was low enough along the sides that it gaps when you take a step. Disappointed because Dr. Scholl's usually makes a really comfy shoe for me.

Cute shoes, I really wanted to love them but they gave me the WORST blisters, totally defeating the purpose of wearing flats.

Every girl needs a leopard print flat and I'm a big one (200+ lbs) so it's harder to find quality accommodating my heft. I purchased these shoes twice. Not b/c they were awesome but b/c they are cheaply made and look shabby after a few months wear. When new they cut into the top of my foot but I hesitated to go larger b/c they lose their shape really fast. Not worth the money.

Every girl needs a leopard print flat and I'm a big one (200+ lbs) so it's harder to find quality accommodating my heft. I purchased these shoes twice. Not b/c they were awesome but b/c they are cheaply made and look shabby after a few months wear. When new they cut into the top of my foot but I hesitated to go larger b/c they lose their shoe really fast. Not worth the money.

I have a pair of these in black with the black and white flowered insole, and they are amazing, really comfortable and have held up well for a few years. However, when I've tried the other colors, they are terribly uncomfortable - a different material that pinches and causes blisters. I tried to buy a second pair of my old favorites and discovered that the softer faux leather has been replaced by the same painful material as the others. I'm returning these.

I just printed the return label to send these back: a 9 1/2 wide was too small--it pinched quite a bit. I also didn't love the style, as the top of the shoe doesn't cover my toes at all, making it seem flimsy and more casual than I would need for work.

First bought these flats on size 9.5, they slipped off the back of my heel. Exchanged them for a size 9, a lil snug but thought they would break in and stretch a little bit. I have these in black, tan, and leopard. All of them in size 9. I have had these flats for over 6 months now and wear them frequently. Still haven't stretched out, and blisters on the back of my heels. Cute in style though, but not comfortable at all. They make my feet clammy and sweat a lot. The tan ones are wearing the color off around the back sides of the lower flat. Not the best quality.

Somehow this shoe felt too tight and too large at the same time. It cut into the upper part of my foot and the middle (arch of my foot) was too loose. I wore them around the house trying to break them in with no luck. I was sorely disappointed that I spent the money on what I thought was going to be a comfortable shoe. No arch support! Shame on you Dr. Scholl! Style was adorable and that is the only positive thing I could say about it.

I am on a quest for pointy black patent shoes. I also wear a 10 wide (in new balance and aerosoles). This felt about a half-size too small, which sucks because they don't come in a 10.5 and they're REALLY cute. I was impressed by the memory foam insole, but the back dug into my heel, and the top of the shoe dug in right beneath my big toe on both feet. Another reviewer said the toe box is shallow, and that sounds right to me. My fourth and fifth toes were also markedly cramped, and couldn't fit in the shoe without curling up. Back they go :(

I was thinking these were a pretty safe bet for your average run of the mill flats, but I had the worst blisters on my heels within the first couple of hours of wearing them. I definitely should have sent these back but I really needed some new shoes so I figured I would make them work. So far I have not dared to put them on again. I think the back of the shoe is too stiff and tall which causes the blisters. My last pair of Dr. Scholls were great, so this surprised me. I recommend if you are looking for flats spend a little more money and get something better.

I have really annoying feet: wide, high instep, bunions, thick ankles. I found these shoes to be wide enough, but as other reviewers mentioned, the toe was uncomfortable and led to toe cleavage. they also ran long and didn't stay on my ankles.

Cute shoes, but uncomfortable immediately. I ordered the black and white stripes, which are very good looking. However, the shoes felt narrow and tight as soon as I tried them on. I also have to say, I don't think the quality of the shoes merits the price. Glad they work for some people. Just not the shoes for me this time.

These flats had a couple of issues for me. The toe area is extremely tight and gives ugly toe cleavage. I tried the M width and the W width. Both have this issue. Plus, the wider shoe is too wide on the rest of the foot and does not get much wider for the toe. I returned these as soon as I received them.

These felt a tad short & rubbed painfully on the top/inner side of my foot behind my big toe. Returned....i purchased the black with dots - very cute just not comfortable.

I got these shoes in the beige and they are the cutest thing I've ever seen! When I first tried them on I was amazed at the sole, a when I first tried walking in them I was fine. For the next couple days I broke them in but I got a blister in the back and on the side of one of my toes. I also found these shoes quite expensive for how quickly they got smudges.

This is the first time I tried a Dr. Scholl's shoe. I expected the utmost in comfort, but instead I got an awkward fit. I am normally a 7.5 W. I ordered 3 different sizes: 7.5 W, 8 M and 8 W. None of them fit. 7.5 W was too tight in the toe, and 8 W was too long. When I realized that this shoe was not leather, but man made materials, I knew that they would not break in. I could feel the irritation of the heel rub almost immediately. Also, the toe box is really small. The low-profile peds I have were very visible.

These shoes took a verrryyy long time to break in, and when I finally did, the lining/insert part in the shoe started to come up by the toes. I end up having to stuff it back in now when I put them on, and honestly, on hot days, these shoes are still not very comfortable. But the outsides are actually holding up very well compared to other flats I've owned. I buy black flats every few months when the last ones inevitably die, and I've been curious about these for a while, but I do not plan on buying them again.

These flats felt wonderful but were very wide and bowed out when I walked so I tried a smaller size and then the toe box was too tight but they were still too wide and bowed out at the sides so I will exchange them.