Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Really

Not the most comfortable flats (not a huge fan of the flat memory foam insole with no arch support), but I looked everywhere for neutral pointed-toe flats and ended up with these after trying many pairs from other brands. These definitely run narrow. I usually wear 8.5 M and I am going to keep the 8.5 W.

I ordered these in both a 7 and 6.5 W; I fell somewhere in between. The 7 was slightly longer but accommodated the width better; the 6.5 width was just a tad narrow but had a more secure fit. I am keeping the larger size, but these are not the most accommodative shoes for those with feet on the wider side. With some exceptions, pointed toe shoes tend to stray on the "narrower" side of what is deemed wide. These are definitely on the narrower side. That said, the insole is exceptionally comfortable and I hope it stays relatively cushion-y after extended use. The shoes are very attractive and the nude color is spot on for me. I wear these for my 10 or so minutes from the bus to work, and would keep them on all day in the office if they just fit me better. For the walk, I am ok with them. I switch these out with the Naturalizer Jayne (another pair I use for my walk to the office but I will keep these on occasionally all day). I thought I found the truly comfortable nude shoe, but not quite so. These will do for now but my search continues.

Love the animal prints, but they weren't comfortable at all. It is my size, but the bones on both sides of the toes on both feet hurt and they made my feet looked wide. As much as I would love to keep them I won't be able to wear them so I am returning them.

I am blessed with long, wide, flat feet. After four babies, I think my feet have settled into a size 11M, from a 10W. I needed some flats that were a little better than disposable, as I wear them walking around the city. However, my feet are of a length where flats rarely look good. Anyway, I found myself liking how these look, especially that they weren't too round or too pointy at the toe. I wore them around the house and was not pleased with the pinch in the front right where the material cuts across my toes. I was going to exchange them, but there were no 11.5 available and no wide width available for me to try. So I took to online videos to see how to stretch them. I went for the thick socks and blow dryer method. I only did it in the front where the shoes were tight, because I don't want my heels flopping around in them. It still feels tight when I get up and walk in them. Not cool, especially for flats. Not cool at all. I'm going to try and stretch them some more before giving up and returning them.

I tried 8. I tried 8.5. Both were really snug near the base of my toes and I have fairly narrow feet. And I did want a basic black flat, but these are too basic in person--not much of any style to them.

Oh man, so bummed to have to send these back. I've been looking for pointed-toe nude flats in wide sizes forever, then these came along for this low price. Plus they're Dr. Scholls?! I couldn't buy them fast enough, and had dreams of getting them in every color. Unfortunately the back of the shoe scrapes at my heel so badly that it's very painful, like I could barely walk across my living room in them. I was even a little worried that it would break the skin. And since they're plastic there's no hope of them stretching out over time. So sad. Otherwise, they are fantastic! Cute, very low-profile, pointy toe that's not too long, and the insole is absurdly comfortable. They really feel like sneakers inside, except for the heel problem. I am really sad to have to send them back. I recommend you try them to see if you're lucky enough to not have the heel issue that I have.

I bought these in Smoke Harmony Stripe and am very disappointed that they are unbelievably dirty after wearing them for one day shopping (not in mud, dirt, etc.). Spot treating with soap and warm water helped a little bit, but they look all scuffed up now. Get these in a dark color to avoid this issue.

These shoes are very comfortable and cute. I will say I loved them the first few weeks I had them (wore them quite a bit). My feet get hot in flats and these "absorbed" that problem. Then they seemed to stop doing that and the inner lining is starting to come up at the toe. I recommend these but consider the lining might start to come up - super glue?

The leather is nice and soft, and the sole is very comfortable. However, the heel rides up higher than other flats I've worn and was quite uncomfortable to me. I only wore them for a few minutes and my heels started to hurt. I'm so sad that I have to return these! They're very cute!

I liked the look of these shoes, though the leopard print is quite light. It is very soft and has a comfortable sole, both of which are great. But it stretches as soon as you put it on. And after an hour of wearing, it is around half to a whole size too large. Since I had already worn the shoes, I just sent them to Goodwill.

These look comfortable and are for a little while, but after a day of shopping in these I had blisters on the back of my heels and the tops of my feet where the edge of the shoes sits above my toes.

If you have to walk, forget these. They are slipping off your feet constantly, and because of that, they did not even last me once season. Scuff marks everywhere with the soft leather. I thought these might be supportive, but they are not even close.

Loved these so much for the first couple of months I had them. BUT the pony hair wears down VERY quickly - the heels and part of my toe box are bare now and look terrible. I wore them maybe 12 times before noticing it. Wish they were more durable. Won't re-order these.

I normally wear a size 11 M, and my foot is normal/skinny width. These were a 1/2 size too big in the M width. I tried a 10 M, which was 1/2 size too small. The sole was comfy, but the toe area was a little too deep (showing too much cleavage), and it was super wide exposing half of the big toe joint. Weird. If you are lucky to find the right size, I must say these are super cute in the leopard print.

I don't normally wear wides, but decided to order wide in these shoes because sometimes flats can be narrow. The wides fit perfectly (which is why i think they're narrower than marked). The soles are comfortable and more cushion than most flats. Unfortunately, I'm finding the interior of the shoe to be rubbing on several spots on my toes, where I've never encountered blisters before. Unusual places like the side of my big toe, or my fourth toe under the nail. I'm on day 5 of wearing these and they're still not broken in. i am hopeful that by the time they're broken in- they are still intact.

The shoes ran a little wide, it felt like they were already "stretched" to fit my feet, which is comfortable for right now but it seems like they would stretch too much after use.

The cushion of the shoe feels great but the top of the shoe digs into your foot! I think the only way to stop this from happening is to wear stocking with the shoe. I wore the shoes for a total of 2 hours and I already hate it. What a waste of money! Very displeased with the total lack of comfort.

The shoes feel comfortable, but they don't match. The color was off. One was more orange and solid black print...the other shoe was more tan and the print wasn't solid black.

I really like this style of flat. However when I tried it on, it was way to big for my foot and slipped out. So I am sad to return them.

I want to love these shoes. I really do. I've ordered them twice from Amazon and once from Zappos. But I've now got a size 9 (half up from my normal) and they are painfully tight. Please ignore the reviews that say this shoe runs large. Not true. I listened to those people and ordered an 8. Too tight. Ordered my regular 8.5. Too tight. 9, too tight. I think i'm giving up. The pointed toe is just clearly not going to work for me, no matter how cute they are.

Very cute, but hit my toes and big toe first joint. I could hardly walk ten steps before wanting to just take them off. Dr Scholl's "Really" - really Dr Scholl's can't you make them more comfortable?

When I bought these shoes I was looking for shoes to wear at work that could be comfortable and lots of cushioning. However, that is not the case. I would say they have a little bit more cushioning then a regular ballet flat but not to the level of the Dr. Scholl's brand. If there is supposed to be arch support, I am not feeling it. They run a little narrow around the balls of your feet so you will need to break them in, but hey it leather so it will stretch. If you are looking for a shoe that has a tad bit more cushioning then the regular ballet flat this is your shoe. About 98% of the time I am a regular size 8 for footwear.

These hit the knuckle right below my big toe and would definitely have caused blisters so I returned