Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Really

I think the most disappointing part of this purchase is that they are advertised to be leather. Inside the shoe it says, "All Man Made." I should probably return them for the price they were. They won't stretch the way I need them to. I do like Zappos, but this just surprised me.

The shoe is adorable. I thought it was not going to be a toe cleavage shoe. After trying the shoe on and walking around the house, it bothered me having toe cleavage, so I will return them due to that issue.

Oh my goodness these shoes are almost upsettingly comfortable. It's like walking on clouds. And they're hella cute too, so these are a total win-win; I got them in the leopard print, but I'm probably going to get them in other colors too. These shoes might ruin me.

I had high hopes for these shoes. Really disappointed! The material has almost no give so it hurt to have them on, giving me painful red marks on my feet. To add to it, the inside of the shoes kept rubbing off a black ink on the inside. It won’t stop doing this! For being Dr Scholl’s they should feel like you’re walking on air, especially at the expensive price of $60!!! These are going back unfortunately.

These are great shoes that are comfortable right out of the box. I wear a 9½/10 in flats, and the 10 is great and I might add in those back of the heel cushions for extra grip. The Leopard print is dyed calf fur - real fur. So much is synthetic these days I did not realize that is what that was. I felt bad when I realized it was real animal products so if you are sensitive to buying animal products, I would want you to know that. These are beautiful and comfortable shoe,s and I will keep them and say a prayer of thanks for the animal.

It’s so hard to find good black flats that don’t look cheap or matronly. They aren’t those garbage elastic flats with a bendy sole. They’re very sturdy. The sole doesn’t look orthopedic from the outside (meaning half an inch tall outside the shoe), but the insole is definitely cushy. They are quite stiff upon arrival, and because the back of the shoe is slightly high on the ankle (but not unattractively so) and the width is definitely a standard wide (meaning not for someone who needs an E width or bigger), I will be wearing them around the house to break them in and avoid developing blisters on the ankle and where the toe box hits the first time I wear them out. I am on the wider side of a standard wide, but these are definitely wearable for me. It’s so nice to finally have a plain and simple, pointed toe black flat! Why is it so hard to find a good basic?

These are pretty comfortable, very standard black flats. I like the almond shape of the toe- more pointed than a ballet flat, but not super pointy. Very comfortable, though as some other reviews mentioned, if you're between sizes, you may have some issues with them slipping off the back- I notice them trying to do that, but it hasn't bothered me.

I just bought my second pair of 'Really's. I love them! They are cute and office appropriate while also being super comfy.

Why can't I find the right size in this shoe? The 7 is way too small and the 7.5 was way too big!!!

Fantastic shoes and perfect right out of the box. Slipped them on and trekked 10 miles in a single day of the high point furniture market with no blisters.

I bought these in black. I normally wear an 8.5 and I bought these in an 8, and they fit perfectly. Definitely get a half size down. These are extremely comfortable! I was surprised at just how comfortable they were for the price. I mostly wear them to work with my cropped black pants but t they also look good with jeans. I'm a 43 year old woman, style is just right for me, trendy enough without being age inappropriate.

With all the great reviews, I was excited to find these! I love the style and they are very cute on. Unfortunately, these are not comfortable for me at all. They pinch across the top of my foot and pinch in the heel. It's almost as though the patent is way too stiff. I haven't decided if they will soften and stretch enough to keep them.

Overall, it's a comfortable/decent shoe if you're looking for a nude flat. Support isn't bad and the color and shape are nice. My main complaint is that the lining of the shoe seems to soak in everything during the day and stays kind of damp. Gross. I don't have particularly sweaty feet, but it's summer and these shoes have gotten mushy and icky inside after just a few weeks of occasional wear. I actually bought some Odor Eaters inserts and that seems to be helping. It's just that the lining of the shoe is soft cloth and keeps moisture in. Also, the top edge of the shoe eats into my heel (although maybe this is unavoidable in some flats that hit higher in the back).

I go through about three pairs of these per year.... for 5 years now lol. First off, it was NEVER called the "Really" so that's new. I actually still have one of my old pairs to compare it against. Just like everyone else has said, the front now pinches. It actually gives my front toes blisters until I break them in... And by the time I do break them in it's time for a new pair. You can "Really" tell you're cheaping out for whatever reason and, Dr Scholl's, you owe us hardworking gals more :) And if you can't, please retire. I also think its funny that you've renamed this particular shoe to the "Really" as if you knew creating it was a bad idea. Has your team ever seen those SNL skits with Amy Poehler and Seth Myers? I could go on but "Really" what's the point? Sorry to sound like a brat but "Really" give us a better shoe than this.

Seems to run small. Uncomfortable in width

I had high hopes for this shoe, while the footbed is comfortable the toe box is small. I usually wear a 6m, however I could barely cram my my toes in to check out the comfort of the foot bed.

Didn't love the style when I received this shoe. Runs a size large. My heel was coming out if the back when I tried to walk.

In less than 30 seconds of taking these shoes out of the box and putting them on my feet I took them off. I am a size 7-7 1/2. I ordered these in a 7 1/2 and they were right up against my heel with no wiggle room. I know that if I wore them for a few hours I would have blisters not only on the back of my heel but also near the inner portion of the shoes near my toes. The shoe was so stiff and therefore very painful. I really wanted to like these shoes since they were wide enough for my feet and the instep was comfortable. These shoes would have surely rubbed up against my bunions and caused major pain since there was no give and I do not feel they would have stretched much. Overall, the shoe was nice looking for everyday wear both with jeans and for work, and had a comfortable instep. The length of the shoe was too short, the material was very stiff, and thus made it very uncomfortable.

Horribly uncomfortable flats! The bottom of my foot felt great, but it pinched my feet around the side and at top. I wore them one day and regretted not wearing them around the house for awhile first to make sure I wanted to keep them. Won't wear them again and feels like a waste of money.

These are a closet staple, I reorder whenever I walk through the bottom of a pair.

I was looking for new animal print flats for work, I previosuly bought a pair of Dr. Scholl's booties for work and I feel like I am walking on clouds, so i figured I would stick with the brand. The shoes were incredibly comfortable and fit well, however I have very slender and long feet and the animal print along with the pointed toe just made my feet look comically large, so I had to return them. I have a pair of black flats with an even pointer toe that don't look so bad, but the print I think just accentuated my feet the wrong way. I would recommend them as they are true to size and comfy, but just maybe in a more muted print or color if your feet are large!