Customer Reviews Earth Bellwether

I haven't bought earth shoes in years, when they had the obvious negative heel and wide toe. I was excited to see an updated look, and ordered my usual size (8B). The shoe was huge, and my heel had no luck staying in the shoe. Adding heel grippers would not have helped at all. The support was amazing, and I would have loved for these to work out!

Pros: Shoe looks nice and is made from quality material. Brand was recommended by my podiatrist. Color is a nice, dark silver with black prominent in a lot of places. Have worn it multiple times in different settings and it has yet to rub or slice my feet. Cons: Had to reorder in a half size smaller. Shoe pulls on toes when walking and not great when standing for long times.

These are great all around shoes. They look great with pants, jeans or a skirt. They initially felt a little tight across base of toes but they are fine now after wearing them a few times.

The only flat I have found that has decent support. I ended up ordering a half size smaller than usual. The toe box was tight at first but it stretched. The shoe is now a bit wide in the heel.

I love the look and feel of these shoes but I could not quite find a size to fit my very wide feet. I tried the wide and half a size up from my regular size. That was just a little too long and still a pinched across the front. I really wanted to keep these, but I had to return them.

I was lucky with the pewter color so I reordered in black but the right side only is so loose it slips off my foot when I walk .have to return this pair.

These shoes are very comfy. Nice padded insole and soft leather. The stitching in the insole is a little irritating for my hypersensitive feet, especially at the heel area, but nothing I can't live with.

I love the quality of this shoe, very simple, nice leather, perfect amount of shine, not too much. And they would be very comfortable, but the heel slips off. I ordered a pair in a size down, and they fit, but can't walk in them because of this. So sad, but must return. Maybe would work on someone else's foot?

Happy with my purchase. The shoe is cute, and most importantly, very comfy! Highly recommend if you are looking for something with good support that is fashionable as well. I have a wide foot and I was happy that the shoe came in different widths as well. I normally wear a 5.5 and this shoe fit just great.

This is the second time I ordered shoes by Earth and the sizing seems to be way off: it is a full size smaller than marked. Also, the color is disappointing. It is much greener than in the picture, I would probably call it "pistachio." Beautiful shoe but it doesn't work for me.

Ordered the distressed pewter color in sizes 9.5 and 10. I am right between a 9.5 and 10 in most shoes in general, and the 9.5s fit just slightly snug, so I'm going with those. They are leather, so I think they will stretch out. Plenty of room in the toe (I hate scrunched toes). However, I am not keeping the pewter color because it looks like it is going to scuff up incredibly easily and just look dirty. Even taking the two pairs out of the box, one pair was a little scuffed up already around the toe and sides, and that's just how it came in the box, so I don't think they are going to look good for long. For the price, I don't think they will be worth it in that color. I'm returning them to try for the admiral blue color instead. I'm hoping the non-distressed leather will look nicer longer. Overall, very cute shoes, and comfy. I am excited to try the blue.

I ordered 11W. The wide part in the toe box fit great, but the shoe is too long and slipped entirely off my heel. I am going to try a 10W to see what that does to the length.

I ordered my usual size and I walk right out of these. I thought they would break in and fit okay but they will need some heel grips. Really cute shoes and well made, though. I may try them in another size.

Nice looking but seems to run large. Went from a 9 1/2W to a 9W but it still is too big. Footbed seems quite comfortable.

Runs small. Ordered 9, and is too small. Width is true to size. Will exchange because are really cute!

Nice looking shoe but as with the Bellflower, the vamp is cut a little too low for people with bunion issues. Luckily, the Vanya style worked.

Comfortable...slightly tight in the toes for me on one foot, larger size I walk out of the back, but I have frog feet and these are much better than most.

These shoes were cute, but pinched my toes and was too short. I ordered my regular size 9M. I going to look for a different style, I think my feet need a more substantial shoe.

One shoe in the first pair that arrived squeaked but they were so comfortable that I ordered a replacement. They will be my work shoe and I bought a different pair (that is a little cuter) as my regular day pair. I'm a true 5 and they fit perfect--no breaking in needed.

Love the shoe, but reg size 8.5 was too squeezed in front toes. Also got a 9 which was too big. Great support. Just wish they made an 8 3/4 size.

I'm not really a ballet flat person, but I needed a good shoe for transitional weather. These are at least moderately supportive, and I like the style and that they're not black. They have broken in reasonably well, though they still rub a bit when I first put them on. I initially ordered an 8, but ended up going down to the 7 1/2.

I love the style of these shoes! Classy without being snobby. They would have been a great addition but they run too wide! To keep them on my feet I would have to wear hiking socks.

These are very cute shoes. To me, seems like they run at least half a size too small. Maybe more. Another pair of flats in the same size felt a full size too large. I think flats are trickier than other shoes, size-wise.

Wasn't as comfortable as I expected. Had to order 3 sizes before I got the right one.

Very cute, however it's tricky to maintain the cute appearance of the leather, as it gets roughed up & scratched easily.