Customer Reviews KEEN Sienna MJ Leather

I bought these shoes after wearing the canvas version all summer and loving how they feel. I work at farmers markets, which means being on my feet 5 or 6 hours at a time. I wear the keenes and have been amazed that my feet never hurt. The canvas ones quickly frayed at the right heel from driving, so I ordered a leather pair. I have not broken these in yet (got a blister on my toe the first wearing) but expect them to be great. I have borderline wide feet and they fit great without socks.

I love this shoe! So comfortable and pretty cute for a comfy shoe. I normally wear a 10 but had to return and get a 10.5.

Overall I like these shoes. They are slightly narrow compared to other Keen shoes and have less arch support. Still a nice shoe and not as bulky looking as other Keen shoes...more feminine.

These were the best shoe purchase I have ever made. I wore them on a trip overseas where I did a lot of walking and my feet still felt great by the end of the day. I also didn't have to break them in. I HIGHLY recommend these shoes.

Great little shoe. Comfy from the first time you put it on. You will need another insole after a few wearings though. More than enough room to accommodate one.

I ordered these in a 9½ and a 10 because typically the toe-box on keens can been too snug for my wide lady-feet. With the Sienna Mary Jane I was able to get away in a 9½ with no toe smushing. These are nice shoes, with comfortable soles, decent traction. I wore them 12 hours the first day and they were great from morning to night. No breaking-in was required.

Very comfy and cute shoes. I have had multiple orthopedic surgeries, and a good fit and support are foremost on my list of must have. And not look like gramma shoes! These are great! I purchased them to wear while traveling, and will be doing a lot of walking. I have already worn them around town and they are comfortable, stay on the foot without slipping around and are actually quite cute! I am very pleased...oh, did order a size down based on other reviews, both 8.5 and 9...kept the 9...felt true to size. Recommend.

Finally, another pair of these in straight black, this time in Leather! Five years back I purchased my first pair of these Mary Jane shoes and wore them constantly--eventually wearing a hole through the sole. Shortly before that happened, the shoe wore open at the outside ball of each foot (I wore them anyway). I wouldn't necessarily call it a defect due to how frequently I wore the shoes but I am hoping that this pair in leather will last a bit longer--I think I got a good year and a half out of the other pair. Very comfortable, slight rubbing at the top edge for the first few days out of the box, but nothing out of the ordinary. Very grippy/gummy sole, comfortable wide elastic band. The foot bed liner comes out of the shoe occasionally whilst doffing, which is a minor annoyance--this was also the case with my first pair and I suppose you could call it convenient if you like to use other liners (there is enough room for larger inserts like superfeet due to the stretch in the elastic band)--but I'll probably just glue it down this time. All this and they're super cute to boot! I love wearing them with capris or rolled up jeans.

These are extremely comfortable shoes. I can walk forever in them. they are light but the arch is good. In fact, I left one pair on a cruise ship and bought another from Zappos.

The most comfortable shoe I've ever owned! It fits snug, but true to size. I would compare the fit to a ballet slipper. The leather is butter-soft and required NO break-in time. I own many other Keen's, but nothing compares to this! I am buying a 2nd pair. The bonus is...the shoe makes your foot look tiny. These shoes are Over-The-Moon!

These shoes are fantastic. Wearable right out of the box. I also own 2 pairs of Keen sandals and a pair of Keen walking shoes. I wasn't sure if I was going to like the strap across my foot but no problem experienced. The color is great and I have had many compliments on these shoes. Very comfortable shoes that can be worn with socks or without. I've actually worn them around the house like slippers. Have bought another pair in black but I had to buy them off the Keen site because Zappos didn't have them in black in my size. Even my husband likes the look of these shoes and he thinks they look really nice on me. I am so happy to have found these shoes because I have a problem with my left foot because of nerve damage so it is difficult for me to find a comfortable shoe.

Love this shoe! Ordered it in black as well. It's not as clunky as many of the other Keen Mary Janes, but because it isn't, it's not as sturdy in the footbed. It looks good with clothes, but for me, not great for a walking shoe.

Not the most attractive shoe but sooo comfortable and perfect for running errands. Dressier than sneakers and easy on/off.

Love, love, love this shoe! Probably the most comfortable shoe I've ever worn. Would love to have several pair in different colors.

I love the looks of this shoe. I am a big fan of Keens and wanted this shoe to work. However, they will need to go back. They are much tighter across the big toe joint which is where my other Keens have not been. If not for the tighter toe box, the length was true to size with comfy arch support.

Comfy, true to fit. Less arch support than my previous pair of Keens (different style) but adequate. Less clunky than my last pair of Keens, too. Lots of room in the toe box for my wide feet. I like these shoes a lot!

These are really cute and so comfortable right out of the box! I wore them to a work conference for 3 days and walked all over town. They are great for narrow feet. The strap gives a nice secure fit. So happy with these shoes!

I LOVE these shoes! Since they've arrived, they have been my go-to shoe for every day. Super comfortable, no break-in period and neutral enough to go with most of my clothes. I've had other Keen shoes that I've loved and this is another winner!

Super comfort from the first time I tried them on. These are great shoes for everyday use, hiking, walking. Very cute with jeans, yoga pants and capris. Can easily be worn with or without socks. Rubber toe seems larger in picture than it really is.

I am always searching for comfortable shoes with decent arches for traveling and running errands. I have had 2 bouts with plantar fasciitis. I wear a size 10.5 or 11 depending on the shoe. These Keens were comfortable out of the box, with room for my toes. I just wore them walking around a large city for several days. No heel problems or sore feet and they looked good too. I even wore them into the office. When you first put them on, the arches do not feel high, but your feet settle in and the arches are enough. I bought a second pair in grey. It is nice to have shoes that are not clogs to walk in. I tried Naot and retuned them all as my toes hit the front of the shoe.

Love these shoes! The leather is very soft and conforms to the foot easily. This is a good shoe for everyday wear running errands. The soles are really flexible with just enough arch support to make them comfortable all day.

I bought these shoes for a trip to San Francisco that I knew would involve lots of walking. They were extremely comfortable and required no "breaking in" whatsoever. I like that they are lightweight but still offer a decent amount of support. I ordered my usual size, and they fit well both without socks and with a thin sock. I would recommend these to anyone looking for an urban walking shoe.

I work retail so I'm on my feet 10 hours a day. I usually get raw spots from new shoes, or at least my feet are sore. These are great! No blisters, no soreness, even on day one. Worth every penny!

These shoes are cute and I found them comfortable right out of the box. I bought all three colors. Especially like the gray with black jeans or pants.

Just got these cuties a couple of hours ago and have been wearing them around the house. Felt good the minute I slipped them on - a lot like a slipper, actually. The leather is super soft and flexible, and the elastic MJ strap hugs my foot nicely. They are not nearly as wide as most Keen's, which for my narrow foot is good. Also, be warned that they don't have the structure or support of most Keens. I have a pretty high arch, so I'm a little sensitive to this. They're quite flat and soft, and you can feel the ground through the sole. I don't think I mind this though, as I was looking for something a little 'softer' than the typical Keen. If I want a little more support and firmness in the sole, I might slip in a pair of Superfeet footbeds. For a soft, slipper-like shoe, this one is really nice. Just don't expect it to have the support or structure of a typical Keen shoe. Feels a teeny tiny bit smaller than most 8.5 Keens I've had, but not small enough to get a size up. Kind of feels like it's going to stretch a bit, considering how soft the leather is. Did I mention it is super-cute and looks great with jeans?