Customer Reviews Reef Creamy Leather

This is the only flip-flop you will need for the entire summer. The leather is super soft, the construction is high quality, the color is completely neutral, and the comfort is there right out of the box. They even have some arch support, which is hard to find in this type of shoe. They are perfect with shorts/beachwear for day as well as a cute sundress for evening. Can see these being excellent with a pair of flowy linen pants and white button-down, too. Hmm, might have to order that outfit too now. Enjoy these - you won't be disappointed.

I saw the reviews stating the flip flops ran a 1/2 size small, so I ordered a 9 when I normally wear an 8. That was the right choice. There is a little extra space at the toes and heels for me, but it's fine. I have a slightly wide foot. I am definitely a medium width, not a true wide. But I am on the wide side of medium, and I sometimes have trouble with shoes being too narrow. These have a very standard-width cut. Personally I wish they were a wee bit wider, but they are wide enough to accommodate my foot. If you have a true wide foot, these will be too narrow, in my opinion. I also have a high arch, and the straps on the left foot were very uncomfortable for me when I first tried on the flip flops. I kept them because I hoped the leather would stretch with wear, and it did. After a couple of days, the shoes fit me perfectly, and I wear them to the beach everyday now. I got the dark brown because I'm not a fan of the wear print that feet leave on shoes after a whle, and I thought the dark leather would hide that better. However, the constant exposure to the sand is muting the leather. It's fine, but they always look a little bit dirty, even after I brush the sand off them. They look better when rinsed with water. If you're going to wear these as true beach flip flops, I may recommend the tobacco color instead.

Just what I was looking for- versatile, comfortable, every-day flip flops! I've been stashing these in my bag and wearing them for the commute to and from work, as well as all day on the weekends. I'm usually a 9.5 (10 in sneakers) and, based on reviews saying the straps loosened up, went with the 9. I wanted to have decent support for doing a lot of fast city walking. They fit perfectly. If you're a half-size, I'd go with the size down, not up!

I love my new flips flops! I live in south Florida and flip flops are to us as Uggs are to Yankees. Thanks Zappos.

Love, love, love these! I've been a loyal Reef flip flop wearer for many years, primarily because of the quality, looks, and moderate arch support (I have high arches and flat sandals hurt my feet if I have to walk a lot in them). For years, I've been hoping they'd come out with a dressier looking flip flop with all the qualities of their other leather flip flops - and these are it! I ordered these and Zappos (love them, too) upgraded my shipping to 2 day so I got them just before I left for a Caribbean vacation... As soon as I put these on, I could tell the arch support was even better than my other Reefs - and they felt squishier on the bottoms of my feet, but still supportive. I wore them the next day for our long 12-hour travel day, and was SO impressed that only at the very end of the day did I feel any discomfort (between my toes). In the week since I've gotten them (I live in Houston, we wear flip flops year-round), the toe piece is sufficiently broken in and they are my new favorite pair of flip flops! Comfortable and stylish, LOVE THEM! I just got on Zappos to order them in the other color. :)

These flip flops are fantastic, minus a flaw or two. I wore them when visiting Boston for a Red Sox game. They were on my feet all day and I loved the basic feel. There are 2 flaws with these flip flops though. One is that there is a difference in strap length between the two shoes. I decided to overlook it at first. The second is that after walking about 4 city blocks in the sun, they seemed to loosen a bit, and the shoe with the larger strap flew off my foot three times. Annoying! My advice is to make sure these are snug on your foot at first! I have skinny feet, so hopefully most people won't have this issue.

These are my go to flip flops. I am size 8 1/2 and I ordered the size 9. Fits perfect and I didn't need any break in time. The arch support makes them super comfy. Super soft.

Takes about a day to break them in, but they are like pillows once you do! It seemed like one was a bit tighter than the other, but it broke in easily. I usually wear a 6 1/2 and ordered a 6, but I had to return for a 7.

Good arch support and some padding on the bottom. The thong is a bit wider than I would like, which is sometimes uncomfortable, but nothing major and I have gotten used to it.

I've only been wearing these for a few hours but so far I love them! I've been wearing the thicker, cloth strap Reefs for years...but it's been impossible to find something slimmer & more stylish that won't slide around my extremely narrow feet. So far these fit really well. They're snug enough and in just a few hours have already softened up and formed more to my foot. I'm sure someone with a wider foot could get away with them also as the leather would stretch. Definitely worth the money.

I ordered this in a size 8. I don't have a wide foot, but it was a bit narrow. The real issue was the "knot" just above the thong part of the flip flops. It was too low and pushed between my toes and hurt. Cute shoes but they are going back.

I have a latex allergy so am limited to leather footwear. After much research, these are the flip flops I went with. No regrets! True to size and very comfortable. Have them in both brown and black. Wish they were offered in a wider variety of fun colors!

I've had these about a month now, these are the perfect flip-flops. I'm usually between an 8.5 or 9 but I like my flip-flops to be closer to the size of my foot so I ordered the 8 and they fit perfect. At first the straps were a little snug, and I made the mistake of breaking them in on a busy day of walking around campus and got a blister on the bottom of my foot. But after a few days (maybe up to a week) the straps had loosened up perfectly and I haven't gotten a blister since. They've gotten soaking wet walking around in puddles and wet grass and still hold up great when they dry out, not slippery or hard as I've had other sandals in the past do. Overall I'm super happy.

This slipper is wonderful! It's soft, and a nice balance between casual and stylish (to me, anyway). Like some other reviews said, it takes time to break it in to fit the width/shape of your feet, but for me it only took 2-3 days. I previously had the Reef leather uptowns, but found that the thinner strap easily came apart at the seam after being worn for a few months. This slipper is a better quality alternative, in my opinion. I love it tons.

Super comfy, casual but decent looking flip flops. Run maybe a touch wide, but not sloppy looking on a average foot. More arch support than most flip flops, but that's still not saying much. However, I run around in these in two different colors pretty much all the time.

I bought these creamy leather sandals in both colors, one for myself and one for my daughter. They go great with jeans, shorts or a sundress. LOVE them. My biggest complaint---they don't come in black. Come on Reef--we need more leather choices (soft creamy leather at that) in black, that have a thinner strap like these do. Other colors would be nice too, perhaps red or tangerine. Other than the lack of color options, these are wonderful sandals and comfortable right of the box. Would not hesitate to purchase more in a variety of colors.

Love these sandals! They felt a bit stiff when I first wore them but quickly formed to my foot. Look great with dresses and are a much better option than rubber flip flops. Keep in mind though, that they aren't really an "arch support" kind of sandal. They definitely are comfortable but won't offer you anything extra if you need greater support.

These are my absolute favorite flip-flops. We live in Austin, so I wear mine practically every day. The leather is super soft, the color is perfect and they go with everything. I'm reordering another pair soon just to have as a spare. They feel like slippers!

Absolutely no break in time needed. I get blisters easily and I walked 3 hours around town up and down hills with no problem. Also attractive enough to go to a casual restaurant.

These are exactly what I have been looking for. Beautiful and soft leather. Very comfortable. I've been wearing them every day with no problem.

These are so cute and super comfortable right out of the box, absolutely no break-in time required. I always wear an 8 in Reefs and these fit just perfectly. The leather is soft and not at all confining on the top of your foot like some leather sandals can be before it stretches out. I am addicted to Reefs, I love their flip flops because they always offer arch support which is SO hard to find in that style of shoe. I have high arches and love it when I can find a shoe that has great arch support. These do not offer as much arch support as some of my other Reef styles do but it is definitely there. You can't go wrong with these, very nice quality leather and super comfortable from the get go.

Very cute, great color, but I am reluctantly returning because the arch falls in the wrong place - too far back. What a bummer! These would otherwise be the perfect flip-flops!

Very comfortable! I bought these for a recent cruise as I didn't want to be walking around in plastic flip flops. These were good for a moderate amount of walking and the straps are very comfortable and no digging in at all. The arch support is nice as well, but probably not enough for a full day of walking. I typically wear a 7.5, ordered both the 7 and the 8, and the 8 felt about right, so they may run just a bit small.

When I first got this shoe, the strap on the right foot was tighter and hurt me. Over time, it loosened up. I also sized up and the size is perfect. They're comfy and cute. I wear them all the time.