Customer Reviews Reef Creamy Leather

I love Reef flip flops! These are a whole new level of amazing. So comfortable...I wish they had more colors! It's worth the price!

These flip flops are extremely comfortable! I wear a size 7, ordered a 6 and 7, and decided the 6 was a better fit. These flip flops are great for long beach walks, look great with maxi dresses, jeans or shorts and are cute!

I have been wearing Reef sandals since middle school and yet again, they do not disappoint. These are comfortable, simple, and feel just as durable as the black pair that has lasted more than 10 years. Excellent casual, neutral brown for summer.

Normally I take a size 8 1/2, but I definitely needed the size 9 for this sandal. And even now, it fits just right. I wish it had a bit more arch support, but it's a solid choice for a classed-up version of a flip-flop.

Love these sandals! The thong part could be slightly more comfortable but these are wearable all day and the tiny arch support is great. They seem to be great quaility as well.

Living in Florida, I wear flip-flops year 'round. I ordered these because I wanted a good, utilitarian, go to pair of flip-flops to wear daily. These fit the bill. The arch support was the surprise for me. Now I'll probably never go back to wearing flip-flops without it.

Simple flip-flops. They fit a bit better than other reef flip=flops I had. Straps are wider - it is good. I don't like the sole. It is all bumpy. I think the sole material need to be a bit stronger. The leather quality is cheap. I wouldn't call it creamy. It is sort of rough, not treated leather.

Hadn't worn flip flops in 50 years, since I thought my feet were ugly! Now that I'm older...I just don't care. Very pleased with the Reef flip flops. Excellent quality. Beautiful leather color. I always wear a size 9 and these fit perfectly. Adequate arch support. The straps have stretched a bit more than I expected, making them a bit more "flip-floppier" than I would have liked. Still, I love the shoes and would repurchase.

These flip flops are the perfect color brown. They are really comfortable too. Due to these only coming in whole sizes, I ordered a size larger than I normally wear, only because they are narrow and I found I needed the width from the larger size. If your foot is already narrow, stick with your original size.

Very comfy. Super soft leather straps. Love Reef. True to size. Great looking. Everyday go to stylish sandal.

I wanted some "dressy" flip flops, if there is such a thing. I do like the color and these are a little more comfortable than your average flip flop. They do have arch support which feels odd at first. These are extremely narrow, which I really didn't appreciate. I find it hard to believe that this is the average width but just a way to cut corners. It would be a good idea to size up. I wish I had gotten a bigger size. Will be interesting to see if they last through the summer.

I did not want to return these, but I had to. The thing is that the fit is not the same from left to right. Both straps were shorter on one shoe, so it was tighter around the foot and the knot between the toes hit just in the wrong spot. I guess this is because the shoes are handmade, but one shoe was comfy and cute, and the other was painful. P.S. my feet are very similar.

The leather is butter soft and the color in the picture is true. I wear a size 10 but these sandals felt more like a 9.5.

Cute flip flop with really lovely soft leather, but unfortunately very uncomfortable for me. I wear flip flops all the time so my toes are used to having something between them, but these are thicker and really hurt. Sounds like you just have to try them, some reviewers report comfort right out of the box, and some report the opposite.

I have always loved Reefs! But as cute as these are, they are not as comfortable as the old traditional Reefs. I cannot wear these for nearly as long as my black pair.

It's not very clear from the photos but the piece between the toe is a very thin strip and cuts into ones flesh. Unfortunate because they're otherwise nice for the price.

These are a bit small and narrow for my wide feet. Normally Reef's work well but I miss the Butter 2. And, it looks like they aren't making those any more.

If you have very flat, unfleshy instep like mine, you'll probably find these flip flops too loose. I got them because other customers said they fit narrow feet, and the shape and width of the sole does fit. I added a ball of foot cushion so they're tolerable and I'm keeping them but would not order again. The leather is soft and the shoe is well made, but note that the sole is very thin and flexible. Not really much help on city streets. Nice for light casual wear.

The shoe looked really when I opened them. I wore them for a few hours (never got them wet) and the leather is already rubbing on the soles. Very disappointed, especially paying this much and them not holding up one day. They are very cute and dainty, just wish the leather would hold up.

I love these shoes in theory and generally find Reefs great, but the soles of these are just really thin and low quality. Not worth the price to wear through in only a couple months of moderate wear. I need to throw mine away or pay more to get them resoled soon.

These are so cute right out of the box, however if you have normal to wide feet they look and feel very silly on. I am so disappointed that I wasted so much money on these. I will not be buying anymore Reef sandals.