Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Bethany

I hate to write a negative review for a shoe that is so nice-looking and obviously so popular, but I know I am helped by reading reviews, so I will leave one for others like me. I have bunions and the B width in this boot was uncomfortable for me. It was so uncomfortable, I couldn't even zip up the back of the shoe. The seam on the toe hits the bunion exactly where you don't want anything to hit, and it is tight. Loosening the laces doesn't affect the fit of the toe box. I even bought it a half-size bigger than my usual size. It's so cute and lightweight (and that zipper in the back is so handy) that if it came in a wide width, like the Cobb Hill Pandora bootie does, I'd buy it in every color! For now, I'll have to stick with getting the Pandora in multiple colors.

I thought these boots would offer good support for my problem feet. I was a loyal Merrelll customer but have been looking for alternatives since Merrell seems to have become more hit or miss in terms of consistency in sizing and support. These did not offer the support I was looking for. They are, however, very nice boots for the average person and I do wear them, switching off with my Dansko clogs because they are so stylish I get a lot of compliments on them from my 20 something co-workers. Love the red! But am still looking for the right boots for my problem feet.

I loved wearing these boots, and still do, but they have changed color drastically. When they arrived they were the deep olive color I ordered but after a few months of moderate wear they are now a full light brown. Since I already have a pair of brown ankle boots this is a bit disappointing. At least the green did not come off on my feet - it seems to have just faded away. They need to quality-control the leather dying process because these boots are too expensive to fail like this after such a short time. Really comfortable, though!

I've really liked these shoes and found them to be very comfortable. Unfortunately, in a little over a year, the sole has worn through leaving me with wet feet on rainy days! I took them to my shoe repair place but they sad they aren't able to replace the sole, which is too bad since the uppers of the shoe are fine. I expected more durability (or at least more potential for repair) given the cost.

These arebeautiful boots (that color!), but even the medium width is too narrow for me - and I have narrow feet. Low score for comfort so I hard to return them.

These boots are tighter in the toe box than other Cobb Hills that I have tried. They grip a bit too much right at the seam across my forefoot. I do not have wide feet.

It pains me to give this three stars because I love these boots. I've had them for a year, and I wear them on my commute to work (all walking) unless it's raining or snowing. They're warm, they're really comfortable, and very versatile. I love the zipper up the back for ease of getting in and out. Particularly helpful at airports or when I'm getting home from a long day of work. Unfortunately about a month ago I felt like one heel was slightly lower than the other. I didn't really think anything of it until my ankle really started hurting. When I looked at the boot I saw the reason - the entire heel of the left boot had collapsed and wasn't providing any support. There was also a giant hole in the rubber where water had gotten in and basically rotted underneath the footbed. I expect a little more from this price but what can you do. They were fantastic while they lasted. For reference, my favorite size is a 7.5W and the 8 fit perfectly. With the laces I could wear thick or thin socks. Very sorry to have to retire these.

So disappointed. I loved these online, but they are smaller, shorter, and less stunning in person. They are narrower than most mediums and just felt a little too small. But I'm not even going to exchange them for a larger size because I just don't love them. The dusty teal color was fun, but the style was just meh. Less combat and more of a comfort look. Without the benefit of being terribly comfortable.

These boots are kind of clunky. They tip up, so it looks like your foot is bent up. The laces will not stay tied, so I have to tie them everytime. They are quite wide at the toe, but that makes them comfortable. I don't think the price warrants the look, but I am keeping them because they are comfortable.

These were so narrow I really couldn't wear them. I was quite disappointed in the fit.

Nice kind of leather and sort of soft and suede-ish, but looks too much like Olive Oil shoes to me. These seem just a tad on the small size, but would work wearing a thinner sock.

I liked the style of these boots but when they arrived, they seemed really stiff. Maybe the leather would have broken in nicely eventually but I was unable to give them a chance because they were also too narrow in the part of the boot where the lacing begins. I have wide feet and got a size W so having a shoe that is still too narrow with that sizing is very rare. It's unfortunate. I was very excited to receive these and disappointed with the outcome. Overall, I have never been disappointed with this brand or its sizing before. I have other pairs of shoes by them that I love.

This boot is very cute and comfortable. However, for some reason, it just felt a little cheaply made - maybe i was just wanting a heavier, sturdier boot. I returned it but it seems like it'd be a nice choice for someone looking for a lightweight boot.

I bought these in OCt. 2017, I flat out loved them. Super comfortable, stylish versatile. 2 weeks into January and the right heel is breaking down, with a hole opening up in the tread and now it makes a little popping sound with every step. I wore them probably 2-3 times a week, for ordinary walking about. For the price they should last longer.

Sizing off. I normally wear 8 - with everything. 8 too long. Ordered 7.5 and still too long. This isn't a sock thickness issue. Shoes run huge with length and width. Laced tight, but too much room in toes. Odd that sizing is off so much.

Unfortunately, it seems like I'm the odd one out on these boots. I found them extremely uncomfortable. I have a low volume, narrow foot, and I felt that they were definitely on the narrow side. The sole is made of a suede-y fabric, so it often felt like my foot was sliding around on it. I experienced ankle pain while wearing these--which I've never had with other shoes! I live in the city and can't wear them unless I won't be walking much that day. Very disappointed for the price point and because these are cute.

I was disappointed in the red color. In the photo the color looks great, very distressed and worn but in reality it just looks like a flat dull bleached out red. Sent them back.

These boots are not pretty, but I was searching for a perfectly comfortable walking boot, so aesthetics were secondary. When I tried them on, I thought I had finally found true comfort. Um, no. After wearing them all day, my toes hurt and my ankles throb. The search continues.

I found these boots to be very cheap looking in person. The leather was thin and seemed quite flexible. They were very comfortable, however.

I have these in the blue/green color and ordered a pair of gray to replace my now worn-out black. While both black and blue were comfortable in size 9 (I'm usually a size 8 to 8.5) the gray are much narrower, shorter and all-around smaller. I'm not sure if I'll return for a size up and wider, try a different color, or just return altogether but I'm very disappointed.

I don't know about anyone else, but I buy leather shoes when I want a pair that's in it for the long haul. So why on earth would a shoe company put a cheap plastic zipper in leather boots? And up the back, of all places, where it's most likely to break? And then they get off charging the same for a pair of boots that will actually stand the test of time? Yeah, nope, sorry. These were cute, comfy, and the colors are great, but that plastic zipper is a deal breaker, not to mention a waste of a cow and some hard earned cash.

I really wanted to like and keep these boots, however the leather quality was very thin and cheap, and would not keep me warm enough in Michigan. Probably would be okay as a fashion boot in California. I really needed something more rugged for Michigan. In addition the stitching across the toe was tight and I was not confident that they would stretch out enough for my wider foot, to be fully comfortable in thick socks. So I am on the hunt for the perfect boots yet again.

I loved these boots. They looked amazing and they felt amazing, which is a nice combination when you have problem feet like mine (wide feet, falling arches, bunions). But they apparently weren't built to last. I'm an over-pronator and tend to walk on the outsides of my feet, so I do sometimes wear the soles of my shoes unevenly. But I only had these boots for a few months before the soles were so worn on one side that I couldn't even stand comfortably in them, let alone walk. And I only ever wore these to the office and on short errands - nothing too rough. For the money, I would have hoped these would have lasted a little longer.

I loved these boots. I work an office job and I wore these in the low-impact setting regularly and expected they would last many years. With minimal wear to the tread at about 6 months old, the sole of the right boot split under the ball of the foot width-wise allowing outside elements to seep in. Perhaps the mold for my right boot was faulty, which is my hope, and I'll be taking it up with the manufacturer to try and get things sorted.

This is a very comfortable boot right out of the box. I actually have purchased 4 pairs. My daughter and granddaughter both work in a restaurant and have loved working in these boots. Only problem is out of 3 pairs all of them have worn out , cracked soles before a 6 month period. Because they are so comfortable, I have bought one more pair knowing it will be a 6 month boot!