Customer Reviews Kate Spade New York Small Square Studs

These earrings shipped very fast, but did not look at all like the picture advertised. They are a pale blue color and completely see through. I am very disappointed with these earrings.

I have these in so many colors and was excited when these arrived. Sadly, the color was not exactly as shown in the photo. They were more light blue in color. Still cute, but will be returning.

With my many Kate Spade product purchases, I have come to know and love their great design and great quality. Unfortunately, these earrings seem to be an exception. While they are just as beautiful in person as they are in the pictures and came in a cute little dust bag, the posts of the earrings were completely bent to a 90 degree angle. I had to bend the posts to the appropriate spot just to put the earrings on and even then I still haven't been able to get the posts completely straight on these earrings. I am afraid to mess with them too much for fear of breaking the post off the back of the earring. In addition, these earrings are pretty big (which I love!), but that means they are pretty heavy as well. I'm not sure the earring back supports the weight of the earring as well as it should. I am nervous the earring will come loose and droop or (worse) fall off altogether. To summarize: these earrings are just as gorgeous as I expected, but not the quality I paid for or expect of Kate Spade products.

They do not look anything like the picture, a very dull garnet color.

I absolutely love the multicolor glitter earrings. They are my favorite earrings ever. However, I am having to replace them because I've lost one due to it falling out while wearing. Normally, I would think this is just an unfortunate occurrence, but I have 4 different pairs of different Kate spade earrings, and 3 of them are missing one due to them falling out. I've been wearing a different back on the one pair I have left in the hopes that poor fitting backs are the issue, and will on my new pair too.

Sadly these are too big. With them titled "small square studs" I expected them to be the same size as Kate Spade's more popular "small Square Studs" that come in a multitude of colors. Sadly, they are quite a few millimeters bigger... Enough to make them go from chic to cheap. I would recommend one purchase Kate Spade's normal studs instead.

While these earrings are beautiful; they are super large. Do not be fooled by the description "Small Square Studs".

One stone had to be secured because it fell out a few times

These were purchased as a gift, when my sister put them on the stones in both came off almost immediately...which was incredibly disappointing. Purchasing from Kate Spade directly I expected a certain level of quality and frankly it was embarrassing watching these earrings that I gave as a gift literally fall apart.

Once these earrings arrived, I tried them on. Within one minute, the stone fell out of one stud. Also, the backs are not tight enough to keep the studs tilted upward. The studs end up facing the floor instead of facing forward.

I absolutely love these earrings in clear but the blue and light pink I got aren't up to standard for that price. Very disappointed that the blue don't have that color at all but look black and the light pink are dull and have no sparkle at all. Wish I hadn't spent that much on those earrings.

I love Kate Spade style and was so excited to buy some of the signature studs! I wore a pair today for the first time, and my ears are aching. I have sensitive ears, so I have to wear sterling or other high quality earrings, but these aren't them. Very disappointing, but I'll be returning all of the pairs I bought.

I ordered two pairs of these earrings, and both arrived in the mail with the stones detached from the stud. I had to put the stones back in and pinch them with pliers so they wouldn't fall out.

I had admired these for quite some time but the reality left me disappointed. The quality of these is not at all what I expected. The "gem" is badly cut plastic and uneven in places.

I ordered these and have used them as my almost everyday earrings for almost a year. I love the style. However now, the gold flaking off, and these are not great for sensitive skin. I would have thought a brand like Kate Spade would use better material. Pretty disappointed

I just received my order today and This was my first purchase from Kate Spade. I ordered the tortoise shell colored earring. When they arrived they were super cheap and just holding them, the "stone" fell out and the stud post bent immediately. I was expecting more from Kate Spade. Not worth 38$ at all.

I ordered two pairs...one you could barely see any tortoise, only appeared black. I understand that the cut of each stone varies, but more attention to detail is expected from Kate Spade. Also, very poor quality of the setting - plastic! No matter the price, Kate Spade should deliver a quality product reflective of their brand. Will be returning both immediately!

I love these earrings, I have them in three colors so I was excited to get the light pink. When they arrived I thought the wrong ones were sent. They are not pink at all, almost like a cloudy white. The color is much more translucent than shown. So I recommend the earrings but not this color.

Poor quality. I have to agree with the other reviewers. Both posts were bent upon arrival. Very disappointing since the price is not cheap. Don't bother with this product.

I agree with other reviewers - the posts bend very easily. Also these are way bigger than I expected, and heavy! It is really too bad; the colors are great and I had high hopes.

I received these earrings just a couple weeks ago. I got them for my new job. I had them on for my work day and when I got home one of the earrings was not on my ear. I realized the posts are really short and obviously do not keep the backs on well. I am so upset because I loved how big the stone was and so pretty. I spent a lot of $$ to only have worn them for not even 8 hours! Zappos or Kate Spade pls replace and send me new ones! I make a lot of purchases from Zappos! And am a loyal customer. They need to be replaced or I need to be refunded!

Very similar to another I bought and since I preferred the sparkler if the two I'm gifting this one on mother's day

I absolutely LOVE the look of these earrings, however I am not able to wear them because the backs keep falling off. I am hoping that a jeweler can get me the right ones.

1 Stars

These say small square studs but they are huge! Sending them back I did not like them at all had to give a comfort rating to submit this review but I did not try them on