Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

In the description, the regular calf is 15 inches and the wide calf is 16 1/2 inches this is the second time I've tried and both times the boots have arrived with 16 1/2 inch calves, which are way too big. the boot itself is very nice and very comfortable and I would love to have them if they were as described.

Just fit but couldn't fit even jeans under it I wanted.

Very uncomfortable boots, I had to take them off at dinner. It's beautiful and looks great but not for walking more that 15 mins.

They do not fit very well and are just not a good design.

Runs very small - I'm usually a true wide 6 and this is tight.

The color doesn't look anything like the photo. I'm so disappointed.

Do not buy! Calf not wide enough. Zipper was defective when boots arrived.

Boots came scuffed up and the sole had pulled away on one of them. They also ran small, both in the foot and the calf. Disappointing, because one of my favorite things about this brand is the consistency of the fit.

I recently purchased these boots and I was super excited until they arrived. I allays buy medium calf boots since I do not have a wide calf. These boots does not even zip up my calf. I'm beyond disappointed because I was looking forward to wearing these boots this fall and now not I can't wear them nor can I return them.

My boots arrived with damages to the leather and black marks on them. Additionally the calf area was hugeseems almost like a wide boot was replaced. I wish they looked just as good as my older pair I was replacing. Will be returning.

I ordered both the regular calf width boot and the wide calf boot. They are very well made with all leather and a great heel and sole. However, the regular width boot is too snug and the wide calf boot is too wide.

I'm so sad to say that the quality of the boots has gone down. I bought this boot 6 years ago and loved them so much. I would wear them every day during the winter until they recently started ripping. I even raved about the quality of these boots to everyone and would express how they lasted for so long. Then, I decided to invest in another pair in the same size. I wanted to love them but am so disappointed in the quality. What happened???? They fit a bit more snug now and I even tried breaking them in by wearing them as much as I could but every time I put them on, I would have to take them back off in 10-15 minutes because the pain was unbearable. I'm almost about to get blisters. These went from my favorite pair of boots to my least favorite. What a disappointment.

While it was a nice boot, the sizing is way different from most boots I've purchased. I tried 3 different sizes, 6.5, 7 & 6.5 W and all sizes felt way too tight for my size 6.5 foot. I won't purchase this brand again. Sizing may not be USA sizing?? One review said size was perfect? Unless your feet are extremely narrow, with no arch whatsoever, it won't be perfect.