Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

I'm on a mission to review shoes for narrow footers. Most shoes that actually come in narrow sizes are usually too wide for me. This medium width boot hugs my foot with a thin sock. I'm so excited! The leather is beautiful-- soft, not too shiny but not dull either. The taller side of the asymmetrical cut hits the back outside of my knee when sitting (I'm 5''4"), but since the leather is soft it's not uncomfortable. I was a little worried about the hardware looking a little too gold and shiny in the pictures, but it's really more of a burnished gold. Finally, I've found a black boot that is not embellished with fringes, laces, buckles, extra straps...just simple and classic. Thank you to Zappos for getting these to me in time to wear for Christmas!

these look great and super high quality for the price, i've only had them a week or two, a little uncomfortable on the top of one of my feet, but probably just due to breaking them in still or thick socks? true to size!

These boots are amazing!! I am very particular when it comes to boots. My calves are fairly big but I did not have to buy these in the wide calf version. I am a huge fan of Sam Edelman shoes and these boots did not disappoint. I bought them in gray and am seriously considering purchasing them in black and brown.

I own a pair of brown Frye button boots and wanted another pair in black. However, I was not wanting to spend the money but didn't want to sacrifice on quality. I tried these and they were perfect. Fit true to size and the calf width works well for me. I have large calves, but not large enough for wide calf boots. These are a great pair of boots for the money!

Love love love these boots!

These are amazing! If you would like a boot that is as beautiful as a Frye without the price tag this is it!

These are cute boots but they are too slouchy in the ankle area for me so, unfortunately, I have to return them. They do run narrow - I ordered the wide and it fit perfectly. The regular width would have been too tight. They are pretty and I like the lower heel - they would be comfy if they were a little more fitted.

I'm super happy with this purchase. The style, the color and the fit. I love the zipper which makes for easy on and off. The leather is soft and comfortable. I'm a teacher and have little feet always stepping on my shoes and they don't scuff easily. Very comfortable.

Love these boots, I wear them everywhere with everything.

I love these boots. Just enough accent to be fashionable. The only thing I don't like is that the zipper starts at the back of my heel, and I can feel it.

Love these!! Not quite as wide as I expect a wide size to be (wide foot, not wide calf). But, they do fit nice, look really sharp and stylish!

Love these boots! They are very comfortable and great overall boots.

The color is beautiful and the leather is really soft! Zippers work easily and I like the rubber sole on the very bottom.

The leather quality & color are great. Couldn't comfortably fit a thicker sock in these boots, which I tried because the back zipper is not comfortable on the heel. Going to return and try something else. Would also prefer a rounder toe for comfort.

Love this boots! I like that the leather is soft and requires no break in time. The shaft is a little tight, but I just had a baby and am sure that once I lose the weight they will felt perfect, but it's not too much of an issue since the boots can stretch some. They are so comfortable!

This is my second pair of Sam's-I love everything about them! So classy and just perfect for work and play!

Been in search of new boots and finally found the perfect pair! The material is so soft and nice! Love the minimalist design. Usually wear 6.5-7 and went with the 6.5!

I love these boots! I had purchased a pair of Frye boots of similar color and style but the toe bed was so narrow. I ordered the Sam Edelman Penny in a wide and it fits great! The color was little lighter then I had expected (whiskey) but still beautiful. I have received many complements on these boots. I wear them several times a week. They do stretch a little.

great fit, color did not work with outfit is only reason i returned

Very comfy right out of box. Been looking for a long time for gray boots, love the color!

These boots are very comfortable.they look great on. I usually wear between a 6-6.5. I ordered a 6.5 and they are slightly longer than I expected. They are fine with thicker socks.

I ordered this boot in the Whiskey color and love the rich color. I have narrow feet but slightly wider calves so have a hard time finding something that will fit me since wide calf boots are way too wide. The 7.5 (my normal size) fit in the foot area but were a little snug zipping up so I exchanged for an 8 and they fit much better. I ordered the M width and if you don't have narrow feet I'd recommend ordering the W width or going up at least a half size. I liked the narrowness of the foot was a plus for me, but could see it being a problem for others. Overall very lovely boot!

i have never been able to find a good tall boot in this color brown in a nice material at the store - but I finally have my perfect boot. The leather is soft, and the color is perfect. I'm 5'4" and 155 lbs, and fits nicely around my calf. The material is stiff enough to hold its shape even when not being worn. Am now hoping it lasts as long as other reviewers have said. Highly recommended.

These boots are stylish and felt comfortable as soon as I put them on. I liked the price and the color of the leather is great.