Customer Reviews Stuart Weitzman Corkswoon

I usually wear an 8.5 or 9, but had already tried the 8 in a Stuart Weitzman store (it was all they had) and I knew they were just slightly too small so I went with the 8.5. On me the 8.5 is a little too big so there's some heel slippage. There's also absolutely zero cushioning or arch support. I don't think I should have to go buy heel grips and gel forefoot cushions for a $400 shoe. I guess I got caught up in the "Kate effect" (seriously, shame on me!) because there is absolutely nothing special about these shoes and I'm considering returning them.

I have read all the reviews and have come to the conclusion that the sizing of this shoe must have changed from when it was first made available until today. Early on, reviewers recommended buying a half size smaller and often discussed the "difference" in interior/exterior appearance between the Zappos site and the Stuart Weitzman site. However, by the time I became aware of Zappos wonderful website, this shoe was sold out and I've had to wait for a new shipment, which finally arrived! After heeding the reviewers, I ordered a half size smaller than my usual size, but my foot is absolutely not comfortable in this size. For me, it isn't the overall length of the shoe that matters, but where the ball of my foot falls in the last that makes the difference between comfort and discomfort--and the ball of my foot is not seated correctly in this smaller size. The shoes I just recently received look as they should, with a pinkish interior and a heel medallion. They are beyond gorgeous, as has been roundly reported, so I fully understand why all of us want them so badly. And we, myself included, are willing to sacrifice comfort for looks. But these shoes do NOT fit well and for the $400 price tag, I feel that is inexcusable. I DO believe that I would have been more comfortable in them had I ordered my usual size, but even in this smaller size, the heel cannot be restrained on my foot. That problem would only worsen with another half size of length.

I was so delighted when I saw these shoes, that I did not hesitate to buy them. I had tried them in an 11 in Nordstrom Rack in patent leather (there were on sale, but they were just a bit too tight, but they were otherwise perfect, so finding the 11½ was just exciting! I was utterly disappointed when I tried them on. The 11½ was hanging off my feet, to the point my feet wobbled as I walked. The medium width was also wider than expected, to the point where it gaped. The material was hard and unyielding, which makes the shoe utterly uncomfortable. The shoes are beautiful, but I truly found nothing redeeming about their fit and comfort, and so I will return them without regret. Stuart Weitzman, you sorely disappointed me this time.

VERY DISAPPOINTED! What happen to these shoes? I own these Corkswoon's but in black patent. Been waiting for these blue suede for a long time. Just as previous reviewers mentioned...these shoes are not the same as in the photo: these shoes are missing the little silver grommet detail in the back of the shoe, and the interior sole is nude instead of black (note that it is also not leather but PU). There is also no detail stitching of the interior sole, either. Suede is stiff and does not look like it would ever break in. Sizing has changed from 1/2 size too large to 1/2 size too small. I exchanged these 3 times...no more...will do without. Have to mention, Zappos CS was excellent in trying to resolve these problems.

I love Stewart Weitzmans, but this is the single-most uncomfortable shoe I have ever worn in my life! They look great, but are literally unwearable. The heel height is fine, but the leather is stiff and cuts into the top of your foot. They have yet to break in. They run at least a half size large. The toe box is extra narrow, but the heel kept slipping off my foot. Between constantly coming off my feet, and leaving them bloodied and blistered, these have now found a permanent place in the back of my closet.