Customer Reviews KEEN Sienna MJ Canvas

I really wanted to like this shoe. I love the colors and the texture of the linen-y fabric. But that toe guard looked like a blob of something stuck to my foot! It needs to extend down the sides of the shoe a little more. As it is, that plus the strap visually cut the foot into distinct sections, making it look longer. Maybe this won't be the effect in the small sizes but my size 10s looked more like 11s or 12s, in my opinion. In a well-styled flat they can look two sizes smaller. Plus, no arch support. The elastic band seemed comfy and the fit was good otherwise but there are too many negatives. Sending them back.

These shoes are pretty comfortable for lounging around, but I was disappointed that they had very little arch support and as a result became super uncomfortable after walking less than half a mile on concrete. Still, if you don't plan on going on walks with them, they're a decent pair of shoes. They didn't rub against my heels or pinch my toes or anything like that.

I normally wear a 9 or 9.5. I ordered these in a 9.5 and a 10, and both were too small! I already have a complex about having large feet, so I'm not sure how I feel about going up in size any more. These are a cute summer shoe, I'm a sucker for a ballet flat. I work for a land trust, and these fit my need for a cute shoe that can easily go out for a spontaneous hike or outing at any moment.

Very cute and shipped super fast but not all that comfortable. I love Keens normally, but was disappointed in this shoe. I got blisters for about a week of wearing them (both with socks and without). The support isn't that great either, after standing on my feet for about 4 hours my arches ached. Still kept them because they're cute. ;)

I was disappointed in this shoe. These were kind of cute; however, the two shoes looked different enough from each other that it was weird. The main problem was the rubber toe. The size of the rubber to on each shoe was different, and on one of the shoes, there were tons of the little speckles on the rubber, and on the other there weren't really any, so the one shoe just looked like it was dirty. The comfort was so-so, but from all the great reviews I really expected them to be more comfortable. There was no cushion, and they felt stiff when I walked in them, which might have worked itself out in time, but I couldn't risk it. The heel on one shoe also slipped a little, so there would've been blisters involved in the break-in process. The shoe had potential to be cute with shorts, jeans, and even casual skirts, but unfortunately they didn't quite cut it.

Shoes fit well both in width and length (I ordered a 36). Insoles can be removed to accommodate orthotics. However, once I added orthotics, the back of the shoes hit the back of my foot at an uncomfortable spot and caused chafing. So I returned them.

I purchsaed these shoes hoping for a comfortable pair of walking shoes for an upcoming trip. I am disappointed by the lack of cushioning in the bottoms of theses shoes. They are light and comfortable otherwise but need more cushion.

After reading reviews on these, I was very hopeful when I ordered. I have multiple pairs of Keens because they are usually high quality, comfortable shoes. Keen did not deliver with these. There was no cushioning at all like the Harvest Mary Jane. These also ran a bit on the narrow side for someone with slightly wide feet. The sole was made of some strange, uncomfortable material. Will have to send back. Very disappointed all around.

I love these shoes and wish that they had worked for me but alas, though the right foot shoe is a perfect fit the left one seems to have a smaller toe box...don't see any way to stretch it out so sadly back they go.

I wanted to like these shoes but they have to go back. The style is cute but the arch support was not right for my feet and the fit was all wrong.

This shoe was just junk. I am very disappointed. Something was put in the heel. I guess for support. It was hard and did not conform to the shape of the shoe. Hurt and would rub a blister. It is not in my other Mary Janes by keen.

The biggest reason I'm returning these shoes is because the left shoe strap digs in the top of my foot. These are definitely NOT for people who pronate. And there is no room for orthotics. Also, the style is really odd. They are almost perfect rectangles. So disappointing Keen. What ever happened to the great arch support and roomy toe box?

True to size, but elastic over arch was very tight.

The stitching in the left shoe was messed up and did not match the right shoe, these shoes have zero arch support and feel extremely cheaply made. Not sure if they're a knockoff or Keen is really cutting some corners.

These shoes are very cute and had plenty of space in the toe box. The insoles were very comfortable, too. Unfortunately the top of the shoe was extremely tight. Returning the product to zappos.

The shoe length feels like a perfect 6. The toe-box seems wider than normal, which is perfect for me. The low rating is due to the height of the shoe (for lack of better words). Even though the toe-box is wider, it is shorter than normal, so it is very tight across the top of my foot at the toe-box. Also, the strap across the foot is tight. Perhaps that will loosen over time, but because of the overall tightness, the comfort overall was compromised.

I was hoping that these were similar to myKeen slip ons that were discontinued last year. But the band was too tight and the shoe felt clunky.

I am completely disappointed in Keen. They were my go-to shoe company. I could go walking straight outta the box, like they used my foot for the mold. Had all the right supports in all the right places. Now? Nope, what happened to the insole? Bring back the standard supportive insole not this flat crap!

narrow, short, no support

So very cute, as a quilter I was in love! I have worn the Keen Mary Jane style before, and enjoy the removable footbed for an orthodic. However, these were so very narrow, and they have a smaller toe box than my other Keen Mary Jane style. They had to be returned, and I am sad.

Cute shoes but I am returning these. They were the same size I've worn for years but my toe touched the tip of the shoe. Shoe was flimsy and gave absolutely no support whatsoever. I'm becoming more and more disappointed in this brand. I've worn nothing but Keens for the last 10 years at least, regular shoes, sandals and mary janes. I don't know what Keen's is doing to their shoes but this is the 4th or 5th pair of styles I have previously worn for years that I have to return. The toe box is not as roomy, the shoes seem less supportive and the materials flimsier. I guess I will have to find another shoe line as I am sick of sending these back. It's a shame because they were my favorites for many years.

What I really want for spring and summer is a pair of mary jane presidio's -- my favorite urban walking shoe. I looked at the Presideo MJ II but they all seem to have that funky coloring so I thought I would try these out. Maybe it was just the pair I got, but the toe box on these shoes stuck out kind of funny looking. The longer toe box is already less flattering on my huge feet but this sort of weird puffiness was really awful looking - I returned them. As far as size and fit they were fine.

Oh, Keen! I ordered your Sienna MJ canvas again this year, hoping that you had returned to the style you produced several years ago (several people reference it on this website). Then, the top of the shoe was lower cut. That version was one of my favorite pairs of shoes ever. I bought them in 2013 or 2014 and wore them out. I miss those shoes so very much. This version is not only less attractive but more importantly is less comfortable. Sadly, I'm returning these Keens just like I had to do last year. Please bring back the old MJ canvas. I miss it!

I had the previous version of this shoe for years and literally wore them every day. They were my absolute favorite. I ordered another pair to replace the originals and noticed that they changed the shape of the opening. The top part of the opening used to be rounded but the new version is straighter/square. This causes two problems: 1) It looks a lot less cute/refined and 2) The squaring-off makes the opening smaller so the top of the opening hits your feet at an awkward and uncomfortable place. Sadly I had to return them. Also, New Black looks like a medium gray in the photo but in reality it is more like actual black.

These shoes felt stiff to me and I just did not like the look of them on my feet (I ordered in black). I also found them to run small. However, I also ordered the wool version and they fit totally different than the canvas - softer, more comfortable, more stylish.