Customer Reviews KEEN Sienna MJ Canvas

I depend on Keen brand shoes to take care of my wide feet, but not wide enough for Wides sizes. I have been holding onto the last pair of adorable multi-colored mary-jane style canvas Keen shoes. Strings are hanging off of them. I excitedly ordered the Sienna MJ Canvas shoes in two sizes to find my best fit. I tried the larger one first and I couldn't take one comfortable step because they were so narrow. Also, the thickness of the sole was much thinner than my old Keens so they were not as supportive as the old ones. The fabric was a cute design. I'm so disappointed. Are all Keens now a narrow design? Both pairs are waiting for me to drop them off at UPS to return.

The front opening was too shallow, and dug into the top of my foot at the opening. Without that, they would have been pretty good.

Right foot great, Left foot OUCH. Extremely tight, pinch across the top of shoe at the edge. Painful. will have to go back. This was the new black.. The Lily pad pair fit beautifully, both feet . Very comfy. Love Keen sandals, first try at a closed shoe.

Bought these for work as keens are some of the most comfortable shoes I’ve owned and I’m on my feet for 8 hours. These have no arch support and were not particularly comfortable.

There is a difference in this shoe compared to previous Keen MJs, I was hoping to replace my current pair but these are not as comfortable and the top of the shoe come over the foot in a spot that is rubbing and uncomfortable. Sadly, I am not keeping these ones.

Fits much narrower than my other keens. Also, there is less arch support

I bought a pair of these in 2014 or so and love them. I have literally worn them out. I was happy to see that Keen still made the shoe and bought another pair. I could tell they were different as soon as I put them on. The shoe comes higher on the foot, which was uncomfortable to me. Also, the sizing was a little bit different. The shoe was snug and I even put my old size 8 next to this size 8 and could notice a slight but discernible difference that I don't think can be attributed to stretching, as I measured sole to sole. I am disappointed. I really loved this shoe and I hope they will go back to the old style for the next season. I am reaturning them for these reasons.

These shoes are great for casual outings and light hikes, but they're pretty expensive for a light weight simple shoe.

These were comfortable but I had to send them back. I ordered New Black and they looked like a gray/light olive green color to me. Definitely not black!

These shoes are super cute but I'm guessing they cost the manufacturer about $10 to make. They are very cheap feeling in terms of the material quality and the durability of the shoe. I am going to keep them for the cute factor but I'm disappointed that Keen is making such a cheap shoe and charging so much for them.

I've worn Keen shoes for many years. They never seem to wear out. They always run true to size, however these are shorter and more narrow. I also didn't feel that the canvas at the heel would hold up. The shoes are super cute, sure wanted to keep them, sadly I had to return them.

ordered 39, or 8 1/2...usually wear a 39 or 40 in European..Wide enough in the toe box for my bunions, but did not feel like the sole was wide enough for full comfort and stability. Strap accomodates my high arch very well and comfortably. Toe box was not quite deep enough on one shoe to be a good fit. At first I was going to order the next size up, a 40 to fix that, but decided this shoe did not have enough material on the soles to keep from feeling what is underfoot. So, it was returned. Think many people would be happy with it for less serious, shorter periods of walking.Style and materials were fine, cute shoe in the wool stripe. Colors true to what I saw on the screen. Wish it had worked for me.

Strange fit - really roomy in the toe, but the stitching above there is too tight. Not much support either. I've gone through two pairs of the leather version of these and they fit much better and are far more comfortable.

Had to go 1/2 size bigger but even after that they never felt right to the bottoms of my feet. I felt like I was walking on the outside edges.

It's really funny with this shoe in the camo print color--they run really short! I already own a pair of these shoes in the beet root in 8.5 and they are great. I ordered them in the camo print in 8.5 and my toes were bent so I ordered a 9. Today I received the 9 and I'm going to keep them but I honestly should be trading them in for a 9.5 because now my toes touch the end. I normally wear an 8.5 in Keen's so I don't know what went wrong with the camo print. I take it back, I'm not going to keep them. I'm wearing them as I'm sitting here at my computer writing this review and my toes are rubbing the ends of the shoes. Disappointing.

This shoe has very little arch support, and very little support overall, but it's cute. My kids have run all summer in Keen sandals, and I know many adults who love those sandals, too, boasting of how supportive they are. I loved this style, and found them on sale, but after wearing them all day had sore feet. The shoe is otherwise incredibly comfortable. I was disappointed.

These shoes were disappointingly uncomfortable! I thought I'd found my new "travel shoes," but no, these Keens are terrible uncomfortable, and boy, they smell horrid after only a few wears. I do not recommend!

I was impressed with how lightweight and flexible these shoes were when I pulled them out of the box. Unfortunately, I am not a fan of the elastic strap across the top of the foot...it was a bit tight on me (though the rest of the shoe fit well) and also not that visually appealing. I hope that Keen will keep the design of the shoe and add a narrower, more traditional style mary jane strap with adjustable buckle in the future.

Absolutely love the look of this shoe but it just doesn't provide any arch support, and the sole is very thin which also causes me problems with my morton's neuroma.

Comfortable but not a great color or style. The arch support isn't quite as good as other Keens I own and the strap was a little too tight (and not adjustable).

Too sparkly green for me and my wardrobe so I'm returning these. I have this style in a less flashy color though and highly recommend them. They are super comfortable.

They are comfy, easy to walk around in. But the picture doesn't demonstrate just how sparkly these shoes are. It's like they are covered in glitter. I was looking for something less conspicuous so back they go.

I've been looking for shoes to wear on an upcoming trip to NYC for awhile. I am really not a fan of sneakers, but I wanted something comfortable for all the walking I'll be doing, and thought these would be a good middle ground. They are DEFINITELY a lot more attractive than athletic shoes, even if they are a bit oddly wide and square in the toe and therefore somewhat clunky in appearance (definitely NOT a minimizing shoe if you have big feet!). The black color is really not a black, more of a grey, but I was fine with it. I have a high instep but the strap is stretchy enough where it didn't bother me. No rubbing at the heel, either, which is a major plus. Sizing was... odd. Luckily I tried these in a brick-and-mortar store so could fiddle with sizes. I'm usually an 8.5-9. 9 was gigantic, 8.5 was still a bit big, 8 was almost perfect except my toes JUST butted against the front. So, even though I marked them as half a size large, they aren't QUITE a half size large... but really not true to size, either! Anyway, went with the 8.5 because with the strap, my feet still stayed in. Started to attempt to break them in by wearing them around the house-- which was when I discovered the weirdest ever issue: the removable insole has exposed edges. Fine, right? Well, yes... except in only the right shoe, my foot hits at JUST the wrong place, and the edges of the insole chafe against the bottom of my foot! It's confounding and immensely uncomfortable, and I think it's partly because the curve of the insole doesn't quite follow my foot (probably because, as I noted, they are somewhat big). I like these so much in every other facet, but I'm afraid that if I try to break them in, I'm going to get blisters on the bottom of my right foot. Might the insole eventually soften up? I guess it's possible, though based on the construction (VERY firm insole, without any cushion or spring), it doesn't seem likely. So, I'm not going to risk it and with regrets, will be returning these. For reference on my foot shape, I have a very high arch, high instep, narrow heel with wider toes. IF your foot doesn't hit the insole wrong, these should be great shoes. But they just don't work for me, and based on the fact that I've NEVER had another shoe do this in my entire life... I can only give them 3 stars.

These are cute, but what happened to the Keen arch support? I have been buying keens for about 10 years now, but in the past few years, the arch support has disappeared, and that was the reason I started buying them in the first place. I am afraid that I am going to have to find another brand.