Customer Reviews KEEN Sienna MJ Canvas

I ordered these to replace my third pair of Keen Mary Janes. These are a shoddy replacement. First the sizing was very different then the other two pairs of MJs I still have. This new one measured 10 L x 3 1/2 W; the traditional was 10 3/4 L x 4 W - that's a huge difference in a shoe. But I didn't even consider ordering in a bigger size as the quality was shameful. The soles were flimsy. The insole was flat vs. the traditional insole that adds so much arch support. I used to recommend Keens but not if the quality is this bad.

I love the look of these shoes- I wanted something sporty but without looking just like a gym shoe. This shoe is adorable with capri's, shorts, and skirts as well. I bought Keen because I wanted the extra support (I regularly wear Danskos, Softt, Merrell, and other super supportive brands). They were perhaps more supportive than the average flat but not by much. I had to purchase a separate supportive insole to supplement the lack of support and in particular arch support. Kind of a bummer considering the brand but not a deal breaker. I love the look and versatility of these shoes!

Made differently, vamp is too high! I love these shoes, and wore out a pair purchased in 2016. So I thought I could replace them, however Keene changed the design and now the vamp hits directly on top of the metatarsophalangeal joint (or the joint right in before your big toe. Due to the higher vamp they also look too old lady-ish, not cute. Surprising what an additional 3/8" of fabric does. The footbed is still awesome, and the sole is still grippy material. Keene: please, please change it back! Zappos service still awesome and dependable.

Pink! I viewed these on 2 different computers and, on each display, they looked like they were a light orange-red color. FYI, they are not. They are hot pink. Just so you know.

Love these shoes! I have very narrow feet, so finding flats that stay on my feet is impossible. The strap on these is cute and solves that problem. The toe room with these is great too. The only thing that was a bummer is that the "black" is really a navy blue. Overall this is an awesome shoe!

Love them. Fit great. May be wide for some women because I have a slightly wide foot and these are roomy for me. Length is true to size and colors are nice. These are my most comfortable Keens although all of them are.

The "throat" area is cut TOO HIGH for those of us with a High Instep. The Throat cut is very uncomfortable because of this. 2 years before Keen created a much more comfortable MJ - these were the most comfortable shoes I ever had. It's sad that Keen has not made them again.

Review is for my most recent purchase only - I have two pair of Siennas (linen canvas and gray leather) and absolutely love them, so I was looking forward to another pair. I got the denim look canvas, and am disappointed! The vamp is cut about 3/4" higher than my other two pair. It rubs on my foot and is very painful. The toe is also narrower and a bit . I wore them a couple of times thinking they'd stretch, so can't return them.

I absolutely love these shoes, my only complaint is...they are supposed to be black, but look navy. Navy is fine, but thought I was ordering black shoes!

I did not wear these and ended up donating them. The cut is much higher than it used to be, putting pressure on feet with a high arch. The soles are flat, with barely-there support. The rubber toe box is twice the size they used to have. They went from the sporty ballet flats I could take on any travel to weekenders best work for short periods of time. The colors are morose, and the soles rubbery -- the look is more old lady than athletic. I wish they will bring back the older versions, in colorful leather and mesh, the cute low cut and especially, the functional, supportive and stylish sole. Here is what they used to look like...

I love the look of this shoe. Looks great with jeans, capris and skirts. I find the strap across the top very uncomfortable. I bought them for that strap thinking it would provide better support but the strap is very tight and hits me in a spot that causes pain that lasts for a long time after wearing. Wish the strap was a 1/2 inch longer.

I love Keen but these shoes have thin, unconditioned sole, very unusual for keen. :( Otherwise, very cute.

I bought this shoe to replace a Teva favorite called Ochoa. apparently discontinued. These are comfortable, but not as comfortable for long wear. The strap is a little tight if your feet swell at all.

Love these! When I saw the Shaded Spruce color (a soft turquoise), I knew I had to buy these shoes, and I couldn't be happier! They are a nice, feminine alternative to a sneaker and are comfortable for all day walking. I find that they have moderate arch support (as do most Keens) and the sole is thick enough that I was comfortable walking on a gravel river trail without any kind of pain. I love the nice roomy toe box that Keens are known for, and the strap offers security and a cute factor to the shoes. I am a true size 8 and I have just a little extra length in these, not so much that I need a 7.5 though. Great for throwing on to go grocery shopping, trail walking, or picking my daughter up from preschool!

I bought these to replace a beloved pair of Keen flats that I bought in 2007. They are adorable shoes, even on my size 11 feet, but they are a little short in the toe box. I am normally an 11 on the nose, but I could have easily gone up half a size.

While this shoe doesn't have as much support as other Keen shoes I own, I think it will be a good shoe to slip on for casual use. Not sure I will use it if on my feet all day.

Absolutely love this shoe. They are cute, very light, and extremely versatile. I have them in the granite color that works with both black pants and even with brown since they aren't so pitch-black. I wear them to work with both pants and skirts, and they are so comfortable that I now use them as my go-to shoe around town as well. Oh, and wore them walking all day without socks and not a blister in sight. (For reference, I'm a size 9).

Love these shoes. They are comfortable and cute. I get compliments every time I wear them. The elastic band makes them easy to wear.

You can't go wrong with Keen. Their shoes deliver every time without fail! The Sienna is no exception. Right out of the box, it not only looked great but felt wonderful on my feet. The pinkish tone gives the shoe a nice pop of spring-like joy.

I had high hopes for these shoes because I love Keen's boots, but unfortunately they ran a little large. The elastic helped keep them on my feet, but the back of the shoe slid too much. I knew it would drive me nuts, so I had to return. Bummer!

I've had Keen Sienna's for many years. The new canvas Sienna's look extremely cute (I purchased the beige ones). They are very comfy, but I do wear them with nylon socks to prevent sore spots.

I absolutely love these shoes. This is my third pair (the first two being the previous leather style). The shoes are always comfortable and match a wide array of clothing. I chose the black canvas. I actually like them more than the leather because while they are black the canvas tones the black down. I highly recommend these shoes.

These shoes are very cute and perfect for spring! Love the signature keen toe cover. Color is just as pictured. Elastic band is slightly snug, but not uncomfortable in my opinion. Would definitely recommend these.

This shoe is as comfy as it is adorable. Absolutely true to size - not too tight or pinchy anywhere. Feels like a slipper. I got these in Sienna today, put them on and immediately ordered a black pair to wear this summer with my scrubs. I'm tempted to order the hibiscus ones too - maybe next paycheck! Highly recommend for comfy, cute footwear when you need something a little nicer than a sneaker.

These are okay, a little thin in the sole (lots of road feel) and less support than I like in the arch, but I will put my own superfeet insoles in these and take out the Keen cork insole which isn't very padded or thick. Overall the shoes fit a lot like my other Keen casual shoes in terms of length and width, though thinner material in the uppers makes the top of the shoe a bit floppy. They feel better with socks, better than barefoot, but that will look dorky with skirts and capris. I am still looking for the perfect summer Mary Jane to wear without socks, but these are okay and the best I've found so far. Brown color is not bad as a spring/ summer neutral. I'm not in love, but I think these will work.