Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Felicia

I ordered the champagne rose hoping for a rose gold ballet flat like what is pictured. Unfortunately, the box I received was marked champagne and the shoes inside were not a light metallic pink.

Love the shoe but the black rim around the entire shoe bleeds onto my feet. Not a sign of a quality shoe!!! Look very cute and are comfortable ??

This is my third pair of SE flats. I bought the other 2 at Nordstom. However this pair was so poorly made i had to send them back. The the lining of the left shoe was not trimmed and was sewn in with the extra lining bunched at the toe. Unwearable disappointment.

I also ordered these in the leopard calf hair. Fabulous looking shoe but omg when I put them on I felt like I was wearing Cinderella’s glass slipper. Ouch! These run even smaller than the orange snake print pair despite also be a size 10. I think I’m going to have to try a 10.5 in these otherwise, they’re just a no go. :(

I must have odd feet b/c a lot of You Tubers love these shoes. I ordered these in 8 and in 8W, but the toe box was still too short. Beautiful shoes and I have given up on Sam Edelman shoes. These are even suede, but they would still be uncomfortable to me.

I really want to love these shoes, but they are killing my feet. I purchased a wide, but unfortunately, these are just not wide enough and they are causing my feet to ache.

I was disappointed in these shoes. The W was not wide enough and they felt very skimpy. I returned them.

I ordered the size I usually wear for Sam Edelman heels and they were WAY too small on me...like, I could barely get them on. Not sure if it is this shoe model or just this particular color (the yellow snake) that I got on sale. Might try them in a bigger size or different color because the style is super cute.

I wear a 7W in almost every shoe I've ever bought, including sneakers, dress shoes, heals, boots, etc. I ordered these in a 7W and they were so small and tight, I had to send them back. I don't think a 7 1/2 would've worked, they were that tight.

The back of the shoe cut my skin. I couldn’t wear them anymore.

I purchased the Felicia's in gold two years ago and loved them! I even bought three other colors at the time. They were starting to show considerable wear so I re-purchased the gold recently to replace and they are too large and feel pretty stiff. The fit has changed considerably. These have been my favorite flats and I'll try again by going down by .5 size and if I they still don't fit, I'll be saddened to say, I won't repurchase.

These shoes fit me and I have several pairs of the Felecia Sam Edelman ballet flat, but when I opened the box of this shoe, there was already a significant scuff on the leather on the front of one of the shoes. So, I am returning them.

For such an expensive sticker price, this shoe felt super low quality. The fabric and soles are flimsy, the sides gap when you walk, and the toe style makes them look like matronly house slippers. I ordered the yellow gingham pattern which turned out to be a really awful, soaked in a flood, stored in the sun for years, musty yellow color, not sunshiney and cheerful like the pictures online. Returning.

I ordered a 6.5 W, and the shoe felt true to its width and size. The leather seems to be of moderate quality. However, the inside of the shoe is flat, with no arch support. Also, the sole is very thin, and I felt like i was waking on a bare floor. I don’t think that these shoes can hold up for an 8 hour work day, which includes walking around the office. I wanted to like these shoes, but I will be returning them.

I agree with other reviewers that this is an all-around comfy flat with soft, supple leather, perhaps a little overpriced. However, I ordered the silver and it is way too shiny and bright! I stupidly wore it outside and can’t return but be warned - unless you want to look like a disco ball, avoid the silver! I wish I had ordered in a different color or that the silver was more matte and sophisticated. It looks better on screen.

Runs too small, is very narrow, and not true to description. I wear a 6.5 in every other shoe out there, and this fits more like a narrow 6. The shoe isn't even of great enough quality to warrant the price, so I will be returning it.

I have at least 21 pairs of Felicia flats, but for some reason the newer ones don't have as much elastic around the heel, and my foot is too narrow to hold the shoe on without the elastic. I love the shoes, but without that elastic they are just too wide. PLEASE bring back the good elastic at the heel!!

Cute Sam Edelman shoes, however several scratches have occurred from the metal tassels and little SE tag. Happened after just a couple of wears; unfortunate as I can't return them.

Ordered the "golden caramel" color because it was on sale but did not like the color in person â?? too dark, to brown. I prefer the "bare new leather" color

I was sent the suede instead of the leather. The color was so beautiful that I kept it instead. Unfortunately the first time I wore the shoes I was caught in an unexpected rainstorm and they were completely ruined. It was not a small investment to see them ruined that quickly and easily.

Oh, how I had wished these shoes were better made! SO cute, BUT there is absolutely ZERO arch support and the construction of these are NOT very well made, especially with the price you are paying! It is very hard to find pretty ballet flats in fushia and royal blue, two of my favorite colors. ALAS, what a disappointment! These are going back!

very cute...but too flimsy for the price!

These have not held up well. The entire inside of the shoe fell apart. I am a huge Edelman fan but these did not hold up.