Customer Reviews Bandolino Mylah 5

I am a huge Bandolino fan! I have bought several shoes in the brand over the years. I love all their shoes - they fit just right and don't need to try on. When these arrived, I was disappointed. They are huge on me! I am always a size 7 in this brand, they are easily a whole size too large. This is my 5th pair of Bandolino's and they are way too big. Very odd. Not sure why they are so big, but I have to return them. I may go to Macys and try on the 6 to compare before repurchasing. Super comfy though!

I ordered a 10.5, my normal size in shoes, however I have wide feet so these were too narrow in the toe area for me. The heel was a slightly big compared to the width of the rest of the shoe. this shoe is very stiff. Would not recommend because of the stiffness.

I forgot to mention in my last review of this product that the glue is visible where the shoe is connected to the sole/heel. Shoddy workmanship, if you ask me. I looked at some in the store today and saw the same thing! There are better quality shoes out there, same price range, so I suggest you keep looking!

I was very excited for these shoes to arrive just a few days before I was traveling to Seattle for a wedding. They are cute and the perfect height (I can't wear super high heels), but unfortunately, they are also extremely uncomfortable! I couldn't even walk around my house to try to break them in -- they felt tight around my toes, and I knew that they would rub and create a blister. So, back to Zappos they go!

Read the reviews and was excited to get a nice pair of comfortable peep toe pumps. However, I am disappointed and they are being return. The material is very stiff & digs right into my achilles. They also put a lot of pressure on the sides of my big toes because the "peep hole" is on the large side. The design of the shoe is not very flattering either, they make the top of your foot look very wide, even a little fat, which I definitely have never had an issue with before. I will say the heel is the perfect height and they seem to have good arch support, so they should technically be very comfortable if you aren't bothered by the 2 issues I had with them. Good luck!

Beware of buying these shoes in the white patent. The footbed has an awful, skunky/petroleum smell. I love these shoes and have them in 3 colors. The white patent is the only one with the problem. Zappos customer service was great when I told them, and they immediately shipped out another pair to me in the white patent. Unfortunately, they smelled as bad as the first. I had left the box open in my closet for a couple of weeks hoping they would "air out." Unfortunately, all they did was smell up my closet. I wore them once, and the warmth of my feet seemed to made it even worse. But again, Zappos customer service was great and told me to return them even though I had worn them once. Again, this only seems to be a problem in the white.

I have a similar Bandolino shoe, which I love, so I thought this shoe would be equally comfortable. Unfortunately, it was not the case. The peep hole squeezed my toes and I have no choice but to return these shoes.