Customer Reviews Bandolino Mylah 5

My overall star rating is really a "2", not what is displayed here...oops! I really wanted to love these shoes, but I could not. I ordered two pair, different colors. I had to send both back. One pair had a tiny little scuff in the patent along the vamp/top edge. I might overlook that if they were marked way down, but not for regular price or a small discount. That pair fit rather nicely. The second pair, same shoe, different color, was too big...gapping on the sides and on the heel. The side gapping is not flattering. It was almost as if someone with huge feet had worn them and stretched them?! So, overall, I am not impressed with these shoes. Too bad. They are cute and fairly comfortable, but I cannot keep them.

These shoes are super cute and seemed comfortable even though they were a half size too big. But the sole seemed slippery, I slipped around a bit on the hard wood floor in my kitchen. I also usually wear a 7 1/2 but these were at least a half size too big.

This beautiful shoe will match gold, bronze, and silver. Stunning with black. A man-made shoe - won't be the most comfortable, but is slightly wide which gives a lot of "breathing room." Suggest a foot "petal" for the ball of the foot or even a thin innersole to make it snugger.

Beautiful shoe and color especially for the price. Would probably have to be careful wearing it as fabric is on the heel too, but this looks pretty. Felt too small for my foot so returning. Macy's also carries this shoe if you want to go to a store and try it on first. Zappos great return policy also makes it easy just to order it from home.

I am used to buying size 9 shoes, but the last 3 pairs have flipped off at the heel. Not sure if it's me, or the the last pairs of shoes I've gotten. And these types of shoes will stretch out so I'd suggest a snug fit when first buying. These are great shoes to wear to dress up any outfit for a more conservative situation (work, work party, church, etc). Overall great buy!

These shoes look great. I don't find them particularly comfortable, but I don't find any heels all that comfortable. These are better than most.

I find that Bandolino shoes run small. I usually wear a 5.5 but need a 6 in Bandolino heels. I prefer leather shoes, but these are cute and will go with many outfits. Comfortable to wear.

I usual buy very expensive dress shoes due to having a pin in my foot and the need for a hard bottom. I tried these on in a store and fell in love! The fit well, are not too high and have a nice size toe box. The day I received these in the mail, we attended a party. I just needed to add a cushion on the back due to a slight amount of slipping and I was off! I wore these instead of my $365 dress shoes! They were great all night. My only problem was they are very slippery so I needed to add something on the bottom.

Wanted this pump to work. I've been searching high and low for this color with a platform and peep toe. I almost always am a 8.5 medium width. Went down to an 8 and still could not keep the shoe on my foot even with an insert. The shoes seem too wide in the heel for an average or slightly wider than average foot. Trotters has a similar shoe. Maybe I'll try that.

I never wear heels, so I definitely judge tough on comfort. I bought the nude color and they are so cute. I wore them for the first time (without breaking them in first) to a wedding and lasted almost the entire night in them before trading out for flats. The nude is very flattering and on-trend and is a great staple piece to add to your wardrobe.

I loved my shoes. I have wide feet and am hard to fit but these were so comfortable. The best part is of course not having to pay postage! I am a first time buyer from Zappos.

I love these shoes. The platform bottom helps ease the discomfort of high heels. The perp in the peep toe is just enough. I tend to have a tall instep and these shoes fit perfectly.

I was a little hesitant, because they were not leather, but they were so cute and I love Bandolino - I wore them the first day I got them. They are so comfortable and they look really good with dresses and pants. In addition to looking good, they are really comfortable. I wish they came in other colors.

Great fit and comfort out of the box. Good heel height and the platform gave extra cushion, but on 2nd wearing shoe was stretched out and wouldn't stay on my foot! Never had this problem with Bandolino before. Maybe it's just the patent leather. I am a standard size 7. Will try heel inserts. Loved the shoe initially but have to reduce star rating since it seemed to stretch out after one wearing.

I already own these shoes in black and I love them. I ordered the same size (6½) in navy and they felt a full size smaller. I am so disappointed to have to send them back.

Love these shoes; adorable, I danced in them and I'm giving them away. I just can't walk in them. So disappointing since they seemed just right.

I bought these shoes in silver. After wearing them a dozen times, I'm over them. It's a nice practical shoe, but nothing special. The color is odd, not exactly silver, in fact not exactly any identifiable color. They're pretty stiff too, definitely not the kind of shoe you'd walk 10 city blocks in.

Was tight around the toes. Left marks and I only wore them around the house for about 10 mins. They are cute shoes, love the style.

Loved how these looked but too long and too wide in 8.5M which is what I usually wear. Don't think a smaller size will help the width issue, they gap open on the sides, but I may try it in 8.

Tight in the toe area yet my first 3 toes fit in the hole which looked weird. I thought only your big toe and the toe next to it should fit in open toed shoes. Very disappointed.

I ordered these in a 7 which is the size I wear, they run big...order a half size down, they flipped off my feet at a 7. Pretty shoe just too big.

Gold Glamour color is covered in glitter! I was looking for a stylish gold shoe, but this is over the top gold glitter. The fit and heel height is good and comfortable, but they have to go back. Love Zappos return policy!

Zappos service is great. Got my shoes when they said. However, I'm not too happy with the shoes because they are buckling at the toe of the right shoe.

I got them for a wedding and they weren't as comfortable as I was expecting. They were the perfect size for me but they ended up rubbing my toes raw. They weren't the worst heels I've ever had but I don't know if I'd recommend them for comfort.

While the shoes were comfortable and I loved the color of the Pewter Croc (very true to the picture), the construction of the part over the foot was crooked? Where the toes peep out, the shoe material buckled up and wrinkled in a funny way over the top of my feet. This was true for both shoes, but more so for the right one.