Customer Reviews UGG Hartley

Love these! Super comfortable. The rubber sole is so cushiony. The heels provide just the slightest bit of height so that you aren't flat-footed. I adore them! And very warm too. I wear 8.5 shoes, 9 in these for me.

The boot looks great but the fit on the top of the arch is tight so you need to wear thin socks. The big thing that I dont' like abotu the boot is that if you step in snow or a puddle, snow or water gets in through the seam on the toe and your toes are soaked immediately! that doesn't really make sense for a winter boot. So, I can only wear the boots on cold dry days.

I love these super warm boots. They are a bit tight around the calf for me, I wish the zipper went all the way to the top. I still, decided to keep them. I really like them and see that they are stretching out already. These were great to find this on sale!

The size 10 was too snug ordered the 11 which would have worked in the foot but the shaft is too big and no ankle support whatsoever. Returning sadly! 1/2 size up may be the safest - the bigger the boot the bigger the shaft!

Well made boot. Not the comfortable "Ugg" experience but I knew that before making the purchase. I purchased for the lining in the shaft and the wedge. However, just like a similar purchase in the past, they keep the bottom of my feet very cold! I wish they could figure a way to make these wedge boots with the infamous fuzzies on the bottom of the shoe!

Very cute boots and comfy but I ordered a 9 being an 8 and my toe touches the front of the boot. I will have to find 10. Too bad they don't come in half sizes.

Great looking boots. Warm, stylish, and unlike other typical UGG boots. However, the shaft area is tight and it's difficult to fit in with jeans. Another downside is that they are made in China! This ruins my impression with UGG, what I expected to be of high quality. UGG should significantly reduce the price because labor in China is extremely cheap (which also reflects on the overall quality of the boots). I feel fine with the boots with the huge discount that Zappos provides. Otherwise, I would not want to pay the full price for the OK quality even it's UGG.

Love the style! Been looking for a boot like this forever. Just trying it on, it feels very warm but the whole foot part is extremely tight. I do have narrow thin feet so that surprised me. I'm normally a 8.5 but ordered a 9 to be "safe" but even that was super tight. My roommate who wears a size 6.5, tried them on for fun, and even she said they fit her tight but she could deal with it. Being from Chicago with the crazy winters and not being able to even wear one sock comfortably concerns me. I'm hoping trying a larger size helps and if not that they do stretch over time as some have stated because they're too cute. Beware, they may steal your socks on removal.

So ready to spend a lot on these boots but the calf is so tight! I didn't think I had big calves (14") but according to UGG I do! Very disappointed. Going back!

How I want to be able to love these boots! Tried a 7...too tight across the toes. Maybe they'd stretch? Thought to next try the 8's. Loose and sloppy in the heel and still a little tight across the toes. So no Hartleys for me. But I love the look. Maybe Ugg could try to create true half sizes? The heels seem loose in comparison to the toebox. Even in the size 7 the heels felt loose. Maybe they would've stretched in the toes but the heel would still have been unstable and wedges are sort of wiggly anyway. Since I really wanted black and they were unavailable I wasn't going to settle at all!

This is an update review. I have owned these boots for little over a year, and I have loved them in all this time. Super comfortable, warm, and most importantly for winter, waterproof. All last winter they kept my feet warm and dry. This morning, as I walked in to work, I noticed that one of my toes felt wet - there is definitely a leak in the boot. What I don't understand is where it's coming from, because I've taken such good care of the leather (polishing, waterproofing with mink oil) and the leather itself isn't even wet. I'm not jumping in puddles - I just walked across the parking lot on a rainy day! The front sewn-in seam appears to be the problem. I am absolutely heartbroken and really annoyed that my investment didn't even last 2 years, when I was expecting much much longer. The fact that I can no longer wear these when it's wet out makes them almost useless to me.