Customer Reviews VIONIC Arcadia Mary Jane

I was excited to give these a try for arch support based on the reviews. The fit was great but the style/material of the ones in black looked extremely cheap, along the lines of something that you would see at a discount off brand store. I returned them and may try another color & style. As always, Zappos was great to work with.

Nice shoe and I really wanted them to work but unfortunately I need a good arch support and these do not have much of an arch support. I was surprised but just how "normal" of a shoe they were rather then the brand catering to those people who need more out of a shoe. The cushion for the sole of the feet was nice, however.

I really wanted these shoes to work! They are cute enough to wear with a dress/skirt and have a nice wide toe-box. Unfortunately they slip so much at the heel, that I found myself walking funny to keep them on. I almost considered layering two back of heel cushions, but realized that was a sure sign they needed to go back. I also didn't like that the insole wasn't attached in anyway - it kept moving around and squeaked when I walked!

When I first bought this shoe, I left positive feedback saying I loved it. However, I had only worn it for short hops in and out of the car at that point. The first time I wore the shoe to work where I stand all day, I was in terrible distress. My bunions, arches, and ankles all ached! What was even worse is that the back of the heel not only comes up too high (which before I thought was only a minor annoyance) but also slants inwards slightly. After wearing them for half the morning, I had bloody spots on both ankles where the back of the shoe was digging in. I had to call my husband to bring me a change of shoes! Since then I've removed the insole and replaced it with my own orthotic, and had a cobbler cut 1/4" off the back of the shoe and restitch it. Now I don't mind them since I can wear my own orthotic and they are wide enough to fit my bunions. But I wouldn't recommend that anyone buy this shoe!

I love this shoe. The style and fit was great, but it made my feet really hot because of the material. Sorry to send it back.

This shoe is cute and it felt so good. I got them to wear on vacation where I knew that I would be doing a lot of walking. They felt great. I didn't have the slightest flare up of my plantar fasciitis but, and this is a big "but", they did not hold up. I have never had a pair of shoes fall apart like this and definitely in the short time that I had had them. They are going back today and I have had them less than a month. The leather like fabric on the toes and strap have completely disintegrated. I wish I could attach a photo. I am so disappointed in Orthaheel's quality.

I really like these shoes. I've worn them for a month already, almost every day. I need the extra support and happily it's there without looking like an orthopedic shoe. Because I'm actively training my dog and gardening occasionally in the shoes, they've gotten dirty and I haven't yet figured out the best way to clean them. I'm considering getting another pair for "good." I'm a 10 medium; the fit is right on.

I bought these in anticipation of walking around NYC all day for 5 days. They were perfect (albeit hot, only because temps reached 100). These shoes significantly helped with my PF. I was not in any pain any of the 5 days while in NYC. Highly recommend, assuming you don't mind the style.

I LOVE these shoes! I bought a pair to test out before a recent trip to Europe. The test run went so well that I bought two more pairs before the trip. I suffer from plantar fasciitis, but these shoes allowed me to walk as much as ten miles in a day with no pain! The only thing I will say is that the shoes can get hot because the canvas doesn't breathe well. Perfect for winter/fall/spring and chilly Europe, but I probably won't wear them in the summer time. I also recommend Orthaheel flip flops and sneakers.

Most comfortable shoes ever! And I have bad feet. Price was good too. I will be ordering more. Had to go a 1/2 size down though.

Great, comfortable shoes. A bit of a squeak in the insoles, which is unfortunate but bearable. So super supportive and comfortable that I wear them regularly. A must buy - not sexy, but super practical.

Love these shoes! I had severe back pain for several months and I work in retail wearing high-end ballerina flats on a hard wood floor for 9 hours. I wasn't sure what I was going to do. I researched online and came across this brand and these shoes have been perfect! The problem is, I've been wearing them 24/7 so I need to get another pair! I've been able to work my entire shift with no pain in my lower back and in addition, they are cute! They work well with both my uniform (a designer, black suit) as well as with workout pants or even shorts...so versatile!

This is an excellent shoe for anyone who needs arch support. Very good toe box. If the sole were thicker, this shoe would be near perfect.

I just don't care anymore about how I look in these shoes. They feel that good. I am 55 years old and how my feet feel are a great concern to me. I will no longer wear uncomfortable shoes and definitely will not wear spiked heels anymore. Even the squishy thong-type sandals are not this comfortable. This is my third pair of Orthaheels and my first Maryjane type style and they feel wonderful. I would rather wear these than go barefoot, that's how good the support feels. No leg pain. No knee pain. Thanks Orthaheel, but could you work on the styling a little bit. Maybe not so clunky would be nice...

These shoes are perfect for casual wear. The fit is good and they are very comfortable. Easy slip on and off.

I love these shoes in any color! Had back pain from being on feet 8-10 hours a day and now problem is resolved. Even improved my attitude. Great shoe and great brand.

Not a cure, but my feet and legs feel so much better when I wear my Arcadia Mary Janes! There is good toe space, too!

I wear a 40 Narrow in Birkenstocks and ordered a 40 in this shoe. The length is perfect. I really wish it came in narrow, though. While the Mary Jane strap helps to accommodate the extra width for me, it does cause the sides to gap a little. Regardless, I'm keeping the shoe. I have bone spurs on my big toe joint and am a candidate for joint fusion, so have problem feet. This shoe is supremely comfortable. By the end of the day I was happy I had them on, but definitely paying attention to the rubbing across the top of my toe joint. Someone with bunions might have a problem with where the top of this shoe falls. Like other posters have mentioned, it is a little hot. Funny thing is, though, I wore them without any foot covering and realized when I took them off after work that I hadn't taken out all the packing material from within the toe bed. I had to chuckle because I kept wondering why it felt like I had tissue between my toes. Maybe they'll be cooler without that extra lining. I think I'll get cotton footies for the future...that will help to absorb moisture, 'cause they're a manmade material. Overall, I do like the comfort of this shoe and will order in another color. Wish they had lighter, summer colors that didn't have the white accents that make them look too sporty for business casual. Oh, well. Finding a comfortable shoe overrides "pretty."

Love this shoe! I ordered it in tan and liked it so much, I had to have the red. Now, I believe I should treat myself to the black. Several years ago, I shattered my heel and have metal pins and plates in the heel. As a result, I think I'm a pretty good judge of comfort! Do yourself a favor and buy this shoe!

Love these Orthaheel Arcadia Mary Jane shoes. They are very comfortable with minimum break in. I would recommend them to anyone who have feet that require TLC.

Love, love, love these shoes! Perfect for running around with your jeans on. Feel so good on your feet. I wear size 11 1/2 - 11 fit fine.

I have plantar fasciitis, and of all the shoes I've tried, these are the only ones that let me walk comfortably while I try to to get better. They also are casual enough to wear all day, but also good-looking enough to wear when going out at night.

Love these shoes! I now own 3 pair, red, tan and black. Several people have ask who's they are and where I got them. They fit well, and have fabulous insoles - if I forget to put in my own orthotics.

Would like better heel and arch support from this shoe. The heel width was comfortable for me. I have a narrow heel. The front is deep enough for my arthritic old toes.

So comfortable and so stylish. Have tried many shoes over the years for my fallen arches and this one is amazing. I don't even know they're on my feet and I have no more pain. Sorry I didn't try them sooner.