Customer Reviews Yellow Box Custard

I wanted to get new flip-flops for my trip to Hawaii and I was looking for the right ones for such a long time. Based on many positive reviews, I decided to get these ones and I am so glad that I did that. I wore these pretty much everywhere in Hawaii (except when I went hiking on the hill) and I was so comfortable in it. I have to say these flip-flops are very versatile, you can dress them up (I wore flowy dresses, and skirts) and just dress casually with shorts and tank top. Both look good! I am pretty short (5'3'') so I always look for flip-flops that are not totally flat. But it is so hard to look for a pair that are not so obvious/ugly/uncomfortable. But I am absolutely in love with these! I feel like I am going to wear these all summer long this year!

I ordered these for my outdoor July wedding. I usually wear a 7.5 but ordered a size 8. They were just a tad big but were still super comfortable and were just what I was looking for to change into to dance the night away. Looked great on my foot and loved the sparkle. Would definitely recommend to other summer brides.

These pair may look similar to cheaper ones on the market but the foot bed is clearly different. I have joint issues and feel clear difference. Foot bed is flexible and cushy, very comfortable.

Very comfortable flip flop with a perfect small wedge to give you more comfort and style, without looking like a "wedge." I love these. So versatile and can be worn casual or with somewhat dress outfits. Got these delivered in less than 1 business day (about 18 hours after I ordered). My love affair with Zappos continues.

Really loved these. So disappointed that I had to send back. They run wide so that my foot flopped around.

Cute and comfortable. Unfortunately, I can't recommend them because several of the little gems fell off after very little wear. Zappos was fabulous (as always) and sent me a new pair at no charge, but they've started falling off the 2nd pair now also. So I figure I'll keep the first pair and take the rhinestones off them to glue to the 2nd pair when they fall off. Too bad, because they're cute, hard to find a nice flip flop with a heel, and I can walk around in them all day and my feet feel great.

Looks great no matter where I wear them. Still amazed at your service...ordered these last night and voila, they were on my front porch today. Impressive! You guys put all the other companies to shame.

Love this version of the "Jello" style shoe. Same comfort and quality - yet a bit higher.

This was my second pair of yellow box, the first pair are kinda plain. These are perfect! Comfortable as always! Definitely your go to shoe!

These shoes run about .5 a size small in my experience. I ordered the blue ones about a month ago and have worn them a number of times and have two comments: 1. The construction is good quality, the rhinestones appear to be either sewn on or strongly affixed. 2. The blue color rubs off on the bottom of my feet. I have to wash my feet after wearing them. It's been one month and this is still happening. I don't think I walk more than the average person during a normal work/weekend day. The sandals are so cute I really don't care.

I've bought many pairs of Yellow Box "Custard". This one was disappointing. They have changed the rhinestones. The newer version has no sparkle compared with previous versions. So what you see in the photo is NOT what you get!

These flip flops have the great sparkle, with a heel and comfort. The toe piece is comfortable, and the strap over the feet is soft, not stiff. I can walk in these for a long time, which is great.

Zappos is awesome! I placed an order last night around 8:30PM and I got my sandals today. I ordered the charcoal color and they are beautiful! They are the right height and the straps are so soft and comfortable. It's a little pricey for sandals.

Hi, I bought these in White, Navy, Brown, and Black. I love them. They fit great and wear beautifully. I would advise buying 1/2 size bigger. I would also add that doing business with Zappos is beyond a pleasure. Cheers, one happy customer.

Love these! The sparkle is subtle enough that they're not over the top for a summer shoe. Extremely comfortable, and the quality is good.

As classy as you can get for a comfy flip flop. Like jewelry for your feet, such sparkle!

These are my favorite sandals! They are light weight, but comfortable and substantial enough to wear all day. They are very pretty, feminine and look equally nice with casual wear or something a bit dressier. I definitely need to find the time to order at least another pair in a second color.

Awesome shoes! They are so comfortable. Well worth the money. They are definitely my "go to" shoes. Friends told me Yellow Box shoes were great but I was never willing to pay. Would buy another pair without hesitating. Love them!

I love these shoes. They are so comfortable and pretty. I get so many compliments on them. Thank you Zappos!

I absolutely love Yellow Box sandals. These are very comfortable and I've never had an issue with the rhinestones coming off. I have 10 pairs of Yellow Box Sandals and get compliments on them every time I wear them. This color goes great with just about everything.

Loves these shoes. Great quality and very comfortable! Sizing is correct.

These sandals are a great mix of comfort and style! I also love that they are more wedge than platform. Being tall, I don't need extra height, but I want the look of a wedge. The Yellow Box brand of shoes are very durable too. This is my 4th pair and it won't be my last!

Cute shoe and true to size, comfortable, casual shoe with a little bling! The slightly higher heel adds comfort if you have higher arches.

Yes I have always loved this style shoe, however, the photo is a little deceiving as I thought the sole was thicker like the others I have purchased in the past. Also only one style like this in white? Did not have any other choices. But all in all its a great shoe and a wonderful company. Eleanor Moscatel