Customer Reviews Alegria Paloma

These shoes are wonderful for walking. They are too wide for me though I wear a B width. Have to wear very thick socks.

These shoes are so cute! I love the way they look and I get loads of compliments about them. Plus they are still comfy after 8 hours on my feet. I originally ordered a size 10 from the company and they were huge and then I ordered a 9 from Zappos which are slightly small. I wear a 9.5 usually so I can't wear socks with the size 9 but I still love them.

I wanted these to fit so bad. I had been admiring them for the longest time online and finally purchased. They are beautiful but the top digs into foot and super tight. No love for them.

I hope this review helps anyone who is considering using their own orthotics in these. When I tried they made the shoes rub me and cause much pain. I took out the footbed it comes with and yes, it is thick so it causes an issue trying to get my orthotics to work because then the shoe is too baggy. What I do it order a thick insole and put that in in place of the one the shoe comes with. Then I can put my orthotic on top of that and it won't be too tight. Also, I am not able to wear these without socks because the edges of the stiff leather rub against the foot up near the big toe and across the top where the strap goes across. Socks help greatly, even thin ones. Also, to make the strap more comfortable I bought strap cushioning stickers and it makes a great difference. Why go to all this trouble? Well, it's because rocker bottom shoes are very hard to find in a decent look that aren't a sport shoe. Once I finessed them to work for me I can walk miles in them. IF they start to squeek just rub paraffin wax around the inside edges where you insole rubs the leather. Baby powder also works and so does silicone spray inside. You can also cover the bottom of your orthotic with medical taple. Phew! Having bad feet is a real challenge. I don't wear Dansko anymore because even though their clogs have a sort of rocker bottom on them, they are ankle twisters if you step on something!

The Alegria Paloma styles are wide enough, but the toes are too shallow with not enough depth. My toes would have rubbed against the top of the shoe. The heels are too deep for my ankles and I would need a riser pad in the heel if I had kept them. They are rather stiff feeling and would need 'breaking in' which I refuse to do. Returning them.

I was so disappointed that the toe box wasn’t deep enough. My big toe pressed against the top of the shoe. Other than that, the styling was cute and the support and stiff sole that I need were there. The quality seems excellent and I think they would hold up well. Lengthwise and width wise they seem true to size.

This shoe is super comfy and looks cute, albeit wider soles than anticipated. They have a bit of a Frankenstein look, but It's so hard to find cute, good orthopedic shoes I don't even mind that aspect. However, sadly I must return these. I have a bone spur on top of a big toe and the mary jane edge of the toe covering digs in to it, making it miserable. So, if your toe is jacked up like mine, beware. I'm so bummed to return these shoes...

These are incredibly comfortable and the top half are pretty cute, but the soles make these look wide and rectangular. If I were taller, this might work, but as a very short person, these shoes make me look like I'm all feet.

This is the most beautiful shoe I have ever owned! I wanted it to work so bad! But it didn’t. The length was too short for me. On my left foot, the toe next to the big toe got really bruised. Just not enough length in this shoe:(

The leather uppers were quite stiff and hurt. I was surprised though I never bought this brand before. Back they go!

The shoe is very cute, but the toe box doesn't work for someone with hammer toes, like me. It feels a half to a full size small to me even setting the toe box issue aside.

I wear an 8½. I ordered the 8-8½ and they were too small. The toe was crunched and no way could I wear them with socks. So I ordered the 9-9½, and they were huge. I walked out of them. I have 8-8½ sandals and they are great, but with closed toe shoes there is no Allegria that I can wear. Also the material was so so stiff. I am very disappointed.

These shoes feel great in the toe box and the arch, but I have extra room at the heel, so they slip when I walk. Will have to return them. I'm afraid that a smaller size will be too small in the toe box and my big toe will hit the end. I really wanted them to work but can't figure a way to make them snug at the heel.

Although these shoes are comfortable, I have only owned these shoes 4 months and the left shoe squeaks loud enough for others around me to comment. It is hard to be quiet around patients with these shoes. The velcro straps seem to loosen as I wear them and need re-tightened during the day. Not worth the price in my opinion.

If you are between sizes, size up. Haven't been able to wear it as it pinched my pinkie toe and slight bunion, hence, the mediocre review. I will return for a larger size which I hope will be it!

I tried these on inside my house and they felt fine. I wore them outside a couple more times and they began to hurt kind of like when you have to flex your foot to keep a flip-flop on. Also, the depth of the footbed was too shallow for me and this made me very uncomfortable. I had expensive, uncomfortable shoes. Zappos was so awesome when I contacted them regarding my situation. The rep was friendly and professional. She let me know that I should always try shoes on indoors and that items had to be in original condition to be returned. She also let me know that Zappos would accept the return of my used shoes even in not new condition! Of course, she also let me know that this was a one-time courtesy to show their appreciation of my patronage. I will be careful to stay indoors with my shoes until I have worn them many times now. I will also shop Zappos any time I can. That is what customer service should be! Satisfied customer!

I love these shoes in the midnight garden. Very comfortable. Lots of compliments when I wear them. However, the patent leather in this pattern seems very susceptible to cracking at the stress points. My first two replacement pairs were not manufactured well and there were gaps between the leather and the edge of the sole. The third replacement pair was fine but started cracking at the stress points again after wearing them twice. The shoes are great in terms of comfort but the manufacturer needs to do some more quality and wear testing. I have seen this complaint in other reviews but don't know if it's only the midnight garden pattern or not. As always, Zappos customer service was fabulous in helping me with the exchanges and I did not incur any shipping charges for any of the shoes.

I wish these worked for me. They are comfortable and lightweight but I have big ankles and when I walk the shoe rubs against it. Blisters.

The Paloma's are very cute. However, if you have wide feet or a bunion these shoes are not for you. I wore them to work and by the end of the day my feet were throbbing. If you have a normal width they would probably be quite comfortable.

Cute shoes, wanted to love them but they hurt me feet while wearing at a wedding and I couldn’t wait to get them off.

These shoes felt a half size smaller, but the width was fine. I liked them in the picture, but I thought they were ugly when I got them out of the box. I couldn't see myself wearing them anywhere. Thank you, Zappos, for the free shipping and returns. I buy almost all my shoes from Zappos, and their service is outstanding.

I wear a size 13. Chart said EU size 43 would fit.. It does not. The leather is very stiff and uncomfortable. I need to return.

I own several pairs of Alegria, as it seems to be one of very few brands that I can actually wear for more than 5-10 minutes without incurring pain with my problematic feet. However, these shoes - as beautiful as they were - caused an instant agony!!! Though I ordered them in "WIDE" and half-a-size bigger, the toe box felt so tight across and on top of my toes, they had to be removed within first 5 minutes of wearing them. Also, this particular style did not possess the lightweight feel on your feet - very heavy, which also added to the great discomfort. Great looking shoe, fantastic, signature Alegria wedge sole, but none of the comfort we have grown accustomed to expect.