Customer Reviews Jack Rogers Jacks Flat Sandal

The classic Jack Rogers Navajo flat is the go to shoe for summer. Perfect with skirts, shorts or jeans, they somehow manage to be dressy and casual at the same time. I'm a little bit puzzled by some of the reviews that I see regarding the fit, so here's my take on it: these shoes are not intended for anyone with wide feet. Half sizes are marked with a dash on the inside of the strap. Half sizes are the same length as whole sizes, the strap is just slightly wider. I personally think they are sized lengthwise for the half size and are therefore, a little bit long if you truly take a whole size, however, my normal size is a 6 1/2 and the 6 is a perfect fit. The strap is supposed to be very snug at first because the leather is soft and will stretch to the shape of your instep after the first wearing. I suspect that those who return their shoes for a larger size will regret that decision once they are broken in. Also, these are not meant to be walked in for miles as there is zero cushioning or arch support. Save that task for your Tevas. They are, however, perfectly comfortable for the purpose for which they were intended--light shopping or sipping cocktails at the club, so pour yourself a G&T and enjoy!

Cute, timeless flat. The strap across the foot is smaller than on many slides. I found this a huge plus, as this style of shoe often flops around when I walk. However, if you have a very high arch or wide feet, you may find it too tight. The shoes do take a couple of wearings to break in, but are really comfortable once this is done. Do sand or scuff the bottoms before wearing. They are crazy slick right out of the box.

What has happened to Jack Rogers Palm Beach sandal over the years? They just don't feel or look to be the same quality. A lot of people question online merchants offering "fakes, " but I fully trust Zappos, and I believe it's Jack Rogers who is now out-sourcing these sandals all over the place, so the quality varies. Or, they have purposely lowered the quality to increase profits. Sad. My daughter has an older pair that clearly are made with a leather footbed (they are now a dark brown and nicely burnished) and the top leather strap is soft and supple. Another pair we bought a year or two later are stiff and the footbed is thinner and the top color has actually scratched off in spots--probably inferior leather or some other material. This pair feels the same way as her poorer-quality pair, so we are returning this black pair. They are uncomfortable (as many "Jacks" are, initially), anyway, and we don't feel they are worth the pricetag, despite our love of the look. Maybe I'll compare other pairs from a retail store to see if the quality is any better. Lastly, this pair's size was marked in a pen with "6 1/2." Typically,Jack Rogers' half sizes are marked "6-" to indicated the half-sized. I thought that was odd (although easier to understand for someone not familiar with Jack Rogers sizing). This pair was made in the Dominican Republic.

I really like the style of this shoe, and the colors are neutral enough to go with pretty much everything. The bone color is actually a bit lighter than it appears in the picture: it's more like a pale skin tone. I usually take either an 8.5 or a 9, so I initially ordered the 9 and they were definitely too big. The 8.5 seems on the smallish side but it's the better fit, so I'm keeping them. I've only worn these once so far and they did rub my feet a little uncomfortably on the sides and the heel, but I think they'll become more comfortable after I've worn them a few times and broken them in. I also did a fair amount of walking the first day I wore them, so I'm sure that was a factor. Overall, the quality is excellent (I love the real leather) and they're cute and versatile, so I'd recommend them.

These shoes are very classy looking. The white band seems tight at first, but leather stretches. This is my second pair of Jack Rogers and they are great summer shoes!

I usually wear 10 - 10.5. I ordered a size 10. The bottom is way longer than my foot. Looks weird. Also the strap across the instep is so loose, that it's difficult to walk in them. Disappointed.

Absolutely love these (as I wear them as I speak)! I am usually between an 8 1/2 and a 9 but when I tried the 9 it was much too big in the toe box. So I highly recommend staying true to size with Jack Rogers. Oh so comfortable and takes barely any time at all to break in (if any). I now have two pairs and cannot wait to grow my collection.

This is my daughter's 6th pair of Jack Rogers! She loves them. Her favorite are the flats but we do have a couple heeled pairs. They go with everything - from a cute sundress to a pair of jeans. Jack Rogers are great but the best thing about Zappos is the service. I can't say enough about this company! It is a win win situation!

The fit and size are fine . over all I am pleased with the shoe, however, Jack Rogers are a pricey sandle. They arrived in a cellaphane bag, flattened like I just bought them at Walmart. No box, no supporting packaging. A little disappointing.

Love these. Pretty true to size, I wear a 6.5-7 and the 6.5 fits perfectly. Are a little slippery on the bottom when you first get them but they scuff up and are fine. My favorite shoes right now!

These are perfect. A flat shoe with enough heel to make your legs feel longer.

The JR Palm Beach is true to size (I wear a 12 and it had plenty of room), it was wide enough, only dis is heel pad a little tough, cute, but white just doesn't suit me after all, so back they go. Don't try white sandals unless your tan a warning to avoid disappointment. Thanks for having them.

The color combination of bone/white is fabulous. It matches with everything and goes especially great with white jeans. It is true to size, and not as uncomfortable as other reviews. I have worn them for long periods of time, and they are very comfortable and stylish! highly recommend

So cute and comfortable! I can wear these at work or at the movies! Eye-catching and flatters the foot!

Great, easy sandal to use. Nice enough to wear with skirts yet casual enough to wear with pants. I bought this is black and platinum. For some reason, the platinum pair is softer and more comfortable. These are fine, but not yet as comfy as the others.

This is my first pair and I saved up my pennies. I agree with what other reviewers wrote that these can be a bit tight upon the first wearing, but then they stretch out a bit and are fine. I love the color combination and wear them to dress up or dress down.

These are classy and comfortable. These flats look great with shorts, capris, or a skirt. The prong is comfortable and does not rub or irritate. There is a little cushioning in the sole. I would buy another pair.

Love them. Not the most comfy of sandals, but they are.. more than adequate in the comfort department. The color is not exactly as pictured, the bone color is lighter. I have had more compliments on them, everyone saying that they are going to get them. I just feel good when I wear them. I catch myself always looking down at my sandals. It was money well spent.

At first I believed they were too tight. Do not let this fool you. After one wearing they became a second skin and are perfect. I have two pair and am ordering a third. A tradition that will continue for many years!

Perfectly cute! I am a 9 and ordered a 9. They fit great and I don't have a skinny foot.

Zappos you are awesome! Thank you for getting these-last year when I mentioned that should look into carrying the line and am I so pleased you now offer it.

Loved the look of these shoes, but they ran a bit small. I am sending them back and ordering a half size up. Thanks Zappos!

This shoe makes your feet look beautiful. But it takes a while to wear in - persistence is key. The leather was very stiff out of the box. I have very high arches so the top of the shoe was quite tight. It prevented my feet from being far enough forward that the strap between my toes would feel comfortable. It's taken me about two weeks of wearing daily for 3 hours to get the leather softer. Now it is much better. The shoe looks elegant on and makes my wide feet look very beautiful. The shape of the sole is excellent. The perforated leather under your foot at the heel is extremely uncomfortable. Overall, for style, these can't be beat. But it would be very helpful if they'd make them more comfortable.

This is the second pair of Jack Rogers I have bought for my daughter and she loves them! After 3 years they get a bit dirty but the shoe seems to hold up just fine. I just bought a pair for myself. They aren't the most comfortable shoes for wearing if you are doing a lot of walking for hours - but not bad for regular use and they look great.

I have a narrow foot and normally wear 9.5. I read that the 9.5 has the size 9 footbed so I ordered a 10. Glad I did since it fits in length perfectly. The shoe is very narrow and is almost too narrow. These would not work at all if you have a wide foot. The shoes feel like there will be some break in time but they have the potential to be super comfy. Though not sure about the design under the heel, that may have to be covered or removed.