Customer Reviews Frye Maggie Perf Wingtip

Swank - Gorgeous! I'm 47 years old. My 16 year old daughter really likes these (on me). Absolutely dream-perfect heel. They do fit snugly. Numerous other reviewers often suggest to order down from your regular size in Frye footwear. I find the opposite - I have to order slightly up. My normal size is 9W, but I need a size 10 in all Frye's. The color blush is a slightly warm beige, perfect neutral. Nothing pink about it, except that it's just a warm, neutral /natural go-with-everything color. A stunning, well crafted, work-of-art shoe. Enjoy! Frye is the only brand I can wear anymore (my feet are too wide for nearly all other brands, except Ugg's). I don't mind the price. I'd rather have only 5 pair of well-fitting, gorgeous, comfy shoes in my closet vs. a closet full of hurt-my-feet shoes. Buy these while you can get them!

Swank - gorgeous! I'm 47 years old. My 16 year old daughter really likes these (on me). Absolutely dream-perfect heel. They do fit snugly. Numerous other reviewers often suggest to order down from your regular size in Frye footwear. I find the opposite - I have to order slightly up. My normal size is 9W, but I need a size 10 in all Frye's. The color blush is a slightly warm beige, perfect neutral. Nothing pink about it, except that it's just a warm, neutral /natural go-with-everything color. A stunning, well crafted, work-of-art shoe. Enjoy! Frye is the only brand I can wear anymore (my feet are too wide for nearly all other brands, except Ugg's). I don't mind the price. I'd rather have only 5 pair of well-fitting, gorgeous, comfy shoes in my closet vs. a closet full of hurt-my-feet shoes. Buy these while you can get them!

These are my new favorite shoes - Love them! The workmanship, quality of materials, overall styling are all excellent. I've received compliments, and many inquiries as to where I got them. Excellent for hoofing around town - soft footbed, and very ' finished' on the inside. Really great style!

These are the coolest & most badass shoes ever. The quality of the leather and the workmanship is superior, and they look fabulous. I've needed to break them in slowly, but I expect these will become the most comfortable of shoes, like the Frye Carson Oxfords I've been wearing for the last 6 months.

Love these shoes. They look great with jeans, dress slacks & will be great to wear with bare feet & roll up jeans & cargos. I am a true 8.5 & these fit true to size. Leather is great quality & I really like the vintage look to the shoe. They did not take any time to break in -- as always Frye quality is the best. You won't be sorry you ordered. You may even want more than 1 color like I did!

Beautiful, well made, delish leather shoe! Distressed look is great. I found them to be true to size. Straight up/normal foot size 10 always. Ordered 10-fit like a glove. Buy these or you will be sorry come fall when this style is all the rage! Zappos was outstanding as always.

I love this shoe! Based on the reviews I was anxious about size and width as I have wide feet and often need either a wide shoe or a size up to fit. Since most folks say these run large I thought maybe I should go a size down, too, but decided 'cause my feet are wide to go ahead with my usual 8.5. They are perfect. I will keep my 8.5. Gorgeous shoes. Frye shoes are always great.

I had been looking for a woman's wingtip shoe for months and finally Frye came out with Maggie. I totally love this shoe! The heel is a little higher than the Frye mules I own, but I like the extra height (I'm not one that wears heels often). I got the stone vachetta color, which arrives looking a bit worn in intentionally. I love that, this way I won't worry so much when I scuff them. Sizing was right on, I wear a 9.5 and that's what I ordered. It was slightly tight width-size, I solved that by wearing really thick socks with the shoes around the house for a couple of hours. I love Frye, and I love to buy shoes made in the USA, it's a rarity these days.

In love with these Fryes. Understand why others went a half-size down, but I kept my usual 9.5. Maybe too narrow in the toe box for some, but for me these are perfect and exactly what I wanted. The leather is beautiful, a good price for this kind of quality.

These Frye oxfords are awesome! They run a little large,so I ordered 1/2 size smaller. They also run a little narrow. They are comfortable and full of style. I had to order a second pair, cute with jeans or beat-up khakis!

Just received this incredible shoe today; awesome with skinny leg jeans. Sort of old-world style; the leather is amazing! I've already ordered one in each color - the pictures simply don't do them justice. I would order a half size down.

Beautiful shoes. I'm a 10 1/2 but the 10 fit perfectly. But they are not very practical. Can not be worn on rainy days because of the little holes. I did not realize they were really open when I ordered. Also they are very noisy on the floor and too sporty for work. For the price I would like to get more for my buck. Sorry Zappos, I will have to return them.

These shoes will kill you in the rain/snow! They are beautiful, but the leather sole has no traction, and is extremely slippery in wet conditions. I took the worst fall on an almost bare sidewalk and seriously hurt myself. I've had two pairs of these shoes for three months now, and the soles have simply not worn in - they are as dangerous in wet conditions as when I bought them. I just don't wear them on rainy days any more, because I always slip around. That, said, they are very well made and handsome. They're stiff, and still haven't broken in after four months of moderate wear, but I think once they break in, they'll feel custom-made.

I really, really liked these and really wanted to keep them. The sole is beautifully made, the shoe itself is gorgeous. But I ordered two sizes, one was big and my heel was loose, and the smaller size was just far too small. Sigh. Back they went.

A buy big and mannish for my stele and needs, but nice shoe overall.

A buy big and mannish for my stele and needs, but nice shoe overall.

Cute shoes! No blisters, even first time I wore them. I would say that they are not quite as exciting as I was hoping they would be... but they are easy to wear and great quality!

I'm a big fan of Frye. These shoes are very nice. The footbed is nice and soft. I love the heel height. They are a have size small for sure and they will take a while to soften up, they're pretty stiff.

These shoes are cute. Even my seven year old daughter approves of the style. I have planter fascia and need sturdy shoes that will take an orthotic insert. These just about do. The heel depth is slightly shallow with the inserts. They are well made, attractive shoes. The leather is very thick and hard. I can't see them stretching much at all when you go to wear them in. This is my second pair of Frye shoes and I have the same fit problem with both of them: the toe box is too narrow and my little toe is squeezed. This is not a problem I have had with other brands. I am not aware of the front of my foot being particularly wide. To solve the problem, I took the shoes to our local cobbler and had the toe box stretched. We'll see if this works. They found it hard to stretch because the leather is so thick and hard. I will resist buying Frye shoes in the future however cute, they may be. They are just too expensive not to be comfortable enough to wear! I think the last they use just doesn't suit my foot.

I love these oxfords, have been looking for a long time for a pair that was masculine yet feminine at the same time. When they came out in cognac I knew I had to have them. Frye boots ages really well, especially in brown and these were no exception. Though the sizing I found to be very odd on this one. I typically wear a 7 for shoes and sometimes 6.5 for boots and sneakers. I ordered the 7, they were too big. I returned them and got the 6.5, they were also too loose. I got the 6, they were just right. Though after walking in them for a bit, and my feet were starting to ache due to the stiff leather. The length was right and I was no longer slipping out of them but the front was a bit narrow (I have wide feet) and it was causing issues. It also rubbed my heels a lot when I am not wearing socks with them. I've broken them in a lot since getting them but I have to admit this was the most challenging pair I've had with Frye.

I got the burgundy ones, but they are more two-toned, like the turquoise ones, with the toe a purplish pink, and the body pinkish. Absolutely georgeous, high quality, and very classy looking. I love Fryes!

This is my 3rd pair of Maggie's. Thank goodness they finally did it in black. The heel and sole are solid black (yay!). The heel seems harder than my other Maggie's and I am wondering if it is a wooden heel. Others are stacked leather. The fit is the same. Runs 1/2 size large. Needs a break in. They are always stiff at first but soon become comfortable. I'm not a fan of the white antique stuff they spray on the leather, but luckily, it rubs right off with a soft towel. Frye really should consider doing some Maggie's in a fine leather finish without the distressing. This is what we want most. Otherwise, the Maggie is a sensational style. It's modern, a little funky, and not too serious. Easy to dress up or down. Very versatile style and well worth the price. I wear mine all the time.

I was one of the original reviewers of the Maggie perfs when they first came out. I couldn't figure out the right size, and at the time I sent back both the 9.5 and 10. Several years later with this latest set of more refined heels and colors, I ordered the Tan Antique Pull Up, wanting to try them again. I don't know what's different, maybe that I wear socks with them in the fall, but I had no trouble choosing the size 10, which is my usual Frye size. I wore them the first day for ten hours as a teacher, and never felt any discomfort. I've continued to wear them without any issues whatsoever. I love the look of this batch of colors and styles and find them incredibly comfortable and stylish. I wore them today with a pencil skirt and cute pointelle/metallic thread anklets, but also wear them with trousers and skinny and bootcut jeans. I'm always on the fence about size when half the reviewers size down and the other half stay with their usual size. But I agree with at least one other size 10 reviewer who prefers not sizing down. My moderate-to-slightly wide foot really enjoys a non-tight shoe, and the 10 is just right.

These are so like the carson oxford, except they have a higher heel. It's about 1/2" higher than the oxford. Anyway they are also very comfortable, more like a cowgirl boot, with great support.

The most comfortable shoes ever, and absolutely adorable on the foot. I hesitated because of the higher heel, but they are unbelievably comfortable and easy to walk in. I have a wider forefoot, a high arch, and a narrower heel. I usually wear a 9 in Frye, and the 9 fit perfectly: room in the toe, good arch support, and no slippage in the heel. I now have a pair in "Dusty Rose" and a pair in "Mustard." Highly recommend.