Customer Reviews KEEN Siskiyou WP

Unfortunately, this will be the 3rd pair of Keen hikers I'm returning. Their casual/leather shoes are unbeatable in comfort and durability, but the hiker styles I've tried have all come up short in comfort. The footbed lacks the design and support I've come to expect after owning three pairs of casual designs. Styling is great and colors are good so it's a shame they're going back.

These are tough but comfortable. Great for around wear to do anything.

My husband liked the look of these shoes but they are just not wide enough for him. He has another pair of Keen shoes that are wide enough. He usually has to buy wide so I guess it is not the fault of the shoes.

Great working shoe, I work full time at a Golf Course and as a part time Landscaper. This is my 3rd of Keens, best waterproof shoe.

First of all, thanks Zappos for free shipping policy. Am now a loyal customer because of it. Keen Siskiyou is a great shoe. Gets hard work done farming in VT.

Bought as gift for husband who is a pretty consistent size 12. These shoes ran small, were rather heavy and inflexible for what they are (low hikers) and were generally uncomfortable. They look nice, but plan on ordering a size up and having them be heavier and less comfortable than you expect.

If you want a slippers, then buy some. I read the reviews before purchasing, but I did not believe the ones who were not satisfied because the pictures said otherwise as I have been ordering my shoes for 20 years. When I first tried them on they were comfortable with stability and that is what I need for my large frame, stability shoes. I am sure that they will break in more and more, but these shoes are great around the city and at work. My feet are starting to feel better because these do not have pinch points around the tendon areas. They are stiff, but the stiffness keeps the tension of my feet. I just wish they would have a better color selection like the Targhee and Finlays.

I bought this as a birthday gift for my husband. He loves it so much. This shoes is very comfortable inside. The style looks so cool. He loves the "caution symbol" at the back of the shoes. This is a very heavy duty shoe.

I love the Siskiyou Keen's. This is my second pair. They are the most comfortable shoes I have ever worn!

These are tanks, they feel tough but at the same time are easy to use. And again the super fast and free shipping from Zappos. Highly recommended!

Comfy shoes, they look very good, waterproof, good grip in water and ice. Very happy to have them.

This shoe is one of the best I've ever owned. Did take about a week to break in, but felt great after that. They are everything as advertised. The rubber toe is great at protecting and does not cut easily. The laces stay tied which is a big plus. This is not a sandal so don't expect it to be and you will get a great shoe.

Great shoe, great price (more for waterproof) breathes well and great for hiking. First time trying Keen but I am impressed with the overall shoe. Most other waterproof outdoor shoes are so much more! I mostly use them for commuting on campus (campus is open with lots of outdoor walking during winter season).

I have four other pairs of Keen shoes or sandals, and all fit great and are true to marked size. The Siskiyou’s, however were not. I had to return my regular size (great return policy BTW) and get a half size larger. The comfort is good, not great. Maybe it will get better with use.

At first I thought of returning there shoes but now I am glad I didn't. They were a little stiff and the tongue of the shoe would dig into the top of my foot. But as I wore them they softened up and they are much more comfortable. I think this was due to them having leather. Also I really like that they are waterproof. I helped move some friends during a hurricane and my feet stayed dry!

The Keen Siskiyou shoes are definitely worth the money. They are completely waterproof as advertised and the durability of the sole is better than any low cut shoe I have ever owned. I definitely recommend these to anyone doing any activities that require a durable shoe.

Really good shoes! I was surprised to find how much support they have and how cool they are.

Love Keen sandals, so thought the shoe version would be a perfect fit as well. Unfortunately seem to feel 1/2 size smaller than marked. Definitely go up 1/2 size when ordering these shoes.

I'm in between a normal width (D) and a wide (E). This definitely have a narrow fit and would not be comfortable over the long run. Nonetheless, it's a good looking shoe.

A nice shoe, but not a good fit for me. It felt uncomfortably tight and constrained around the whole top of my foot. (I don't usually have a hard time finding a shoe that fits well.)

I bought these as I've been looking for something sneakerish that is warm and dry for the fall/winter/spring months. They do just that. However, they have zero cushion whatsoever. After 3-5 hours of wear time the heels and balls of my feet are killing me. Just no shock absorption at all. I also have a fairly high arch and found these to have a good amount of support. I will have to try some different insoles before I would trust these to a day of hiking or something similar.

The shoes are very comfortable, but after two days and the latter being in the rain, my feet are soaked!

Having worn these for about just shy of two months, here are my 2 cents. Pretty comfy out of the box. Heavier and more rugged than I expected, but I'm happy about that. The footbeds are not very soft/squishy but they are surprisingly comfortable regardless. All of this being said, I noticed yesterday that the midsole is separating from the leather along the toe bend. I would have rated them 4, 4 and 5, for Overall, Comfort and Style respectively, if it were not for the failing construction. I do wear these shoes 5 days a week (to work) but have a job where I spend 75% of my time sitting at a desk. I did wear these on 1 hike (about 2 hours). I plan to return these to Keen, and will leave a review of the return process here, when completed.

Stay away from this shoe. Owned a previous pair of Keens that I absolutely loved. I thought the Sikiyou was that shoe, as I now need replacements. Boy was I wrong. These are not comfortable shoes. Almost no arch support. Length is definitely smaller than real-life. Very disappointing. Keen manufacturer and why go to the trouble to make a great shoe, then put in a cheap, thin insert with no arch support? Makes me start to rethink buying Keens. This seems to be a trend in companies, I've noticed. They never stick with something that people love. Always changing for whatever reason, messing up a great product.

Very uncomfortable. If I tied the laces tight enough to keep the shoe it felt like they were digging into my foot. Very disappointing.