Customer Reviews Circa Joan & David Callalily

I have these shoes in black, red, neutral, butter and brown. They are the most comfortable pumps I have ever owned. I live in Manhattan and my pumps must be walkable, these definitely are!

As I'm getting older, I am trading out my higher heels for lower ones, but don't want to give up "sexy." This shoe fits the bill...very attractive, comfortable, and stylish. Footbed is very padded.

The buckles on these shoes do NOT adjust! I bought them because of the buckle adjustment. I am returning them.

Love Circa Joan & David shoes - they are very stylish and comfortable. I love these shoes, too. However, I am disappointed because the one time that I wore them, the hem of my dress pants kept getting caught in the buckle. The buckle has absolutely no sharp edges so I cannot figure it out. Not ready to return these yet though - really hoping they will work with another pair of pants or some other miracle because I really like the style and comfort.

I had great hopes for this shoe--bought my normal size (9.5) and it fit like a dream and the foot bed padding was exceptional. After a few wearings, however, the leather seemed to stretch quite a bit, and my heel started coming out when I walked. I then ordered the 9, but it feels a tad short. Perhaps someone with a slightly wider foot might like this shoe better than I did!

I bought the natural/brown patent pair. They are my most reliable, go-to shoes for work - can go with almost any item, any color, are neither too low nor too high, and are comfortable! I have received tons of compliments on them over the last few months, which surprised me as I initially thought they might be too conservative. I wear a 7B normally; usually this brand runs a little narrow and slightly large for me, but with this pair the width was just right. The size was just a tad large and I was experiencing some heel slippage, but some heel slip inserts solved that problem exactly. I'm still wearing these halfway into pregnancy with twins because they're comfortable and not too high, which is a nice alternative to flats during pregnancy.

I was looking for a quiet shoe so that people would not hear me walking down the hall a half a mile away. This shoe is very quiet and is perfect for someone working in hospital administration. It's also comfortable and beautiful! I might have to get myself another one in a different color!

If you are thinking about buying these shoes, don't delay another second! They are absolutely beautiful and very, very well made. Although they look very elegant in the picture, they are even more spectacular in reality! Love, love, love them!

Very comfortable! I am seriously considering buying the natural colored shoes as well.

Love these shoes! Stylish and comfortable. Going to order in additional colors.

Beautiful shoe, low heel height, just what I was looking for since I bought this for a wedding and will be on my feet all day. I've worn them around the house and I think they will be comfortable and great looking at the same time. Shipping was incredibly fast and Zappos is always great about returns. Thanks

Absolutely gorgeous shoe. Comfortable - has a padded sole and there is some arch support! I usually have a hard time finding nice shoes that fit and are comfortable! These are great.

I bought this and the natural at the same time. The black pair was noticeably tighter; I think the natural pair had been a return so had been worn before. I wear an 8.5M and the shoe seems true to size. The pointed-tow style does mean that your toes are a little cramped, but not uncomfortably so. The arch is well supported. The padding in the footbed is excellent and makes the shoe comfortable. The construction is sturdy and the heel gives a secure stride. Perfect heel height for stylish professionalism. Very satisfied.

I have had these shoes for almost 24 hours and they are already the most comfortable pair of pumps I've ever purchased. Very true to size and extra cushiony.

Very comfortable shoe. Has extra padding through out bottom of shoe. Good height.

Most comfortable shoe I have bought in a long time. I am on my feet all day and when I wear these, I don't even know I am wearing heels!

Beautiful shoe. Fit great right out of the box. Very stylish for work and evening wear. Pretty good arch support to.

These shoes are even better when you are wearing them! I wanted something a little "edgy" and up-to-date. Every time I wear them I get at last 2 or 3 compliments. Bought them in black; they are just really sharp looking - with pants - dresses, whatever! Very comfortable as well!

These are gorgeous and sexy and I'm sure would be comfortable if they didn't run so small. The sole is thickly padded and the heel is just the right height. I think they would be comfortable even without hose since they have the side openings to breathe and the sole is a soft leather-like material.I am almost religiously a size 8.5 and these were very tight. I have to return them and was trying to buy the next size up, but they are unfortunately unavailable. I'm hopeful that they come back in stock soon!

I just received this pair of shoes and have to say they are extrememly comfortable and great looking. Well worth the money and I will certainly purchase more of this brand! Had many compliments in my two days of wearing them!

These shoes are very comfortable! They have a good amount of padding and arch support. Unlike some pointy-toes shoes, they are not tight around the toes. They feel true to size (mine are 7s). I am buying them in a second color.

Wildly comfortable and a great shoe for work! Padding on footbed is exceptional, and no rub marks or blisters at the end of the first day wearing them. Feels slightly larger than other size 9.5 shoes that I have, but I know I'll appreciate this room when then weather gets warmer.

These shoes look so much more expensive than they are. They look great with suits and have a very cushy footbed. I bought them in brown and black. The brown is particularly great-looking. I highly recommend them. True to size and width.

This shoes are so great looking! They seem to be very comfortable so far due to the great padding/cushioning in the sole. I feel that they run a bit big as I usually wear a 9.5 (and ordered that size) and these are a little big. Probably could have worn a 9. I believe another reviewer stated that the buckle on the side is adjustable, but it is only there for decoration and is non-functioning. I like these so much I may order a pair in red!