Customer Reviews Circa Joan & David Callalily

Very pretty shoe. But did not fit me well. It was too long. I did not order a size down because the toe is narrow so I think a smaller size would be uncomfortable. I have a narrow foot and the medium width seemed okay. Better luck next time.

These are beautiful shoes. Size runs true and the fit is good. They do need a little breaking in so don't plan on spending the entire day running around the first day you wear them. Otherwise, simply gorgeous shoes.

Beautiful, comfortable. The only issue is it appears that over time the toe will crease from walking.

Beautiful shoes, my feet are a little wide for them but they fit like most others with the same style. These have a little more cushion than most so I rate them higher.

Had to return these. They are beautiful shoes, but the toebox is very tight. I checked an old pair of Circa Joan & David shoes I have and the size was the same, but the fit on them couldn't be more different. My feet felt jammed into the toebox and it just wasn't comfortable. However, she shoe is a deep midnight, the heel height is great for someone who can't walk around in very high heels and the little gap and buckle detail make these shoes stunning. Unfortunately, they are too narrow in the toe.

These shoes are beautiful, and astonishingly comfortable. Sadly, the color (Medium Natural) was way lighter and more yellow than the photograph indicates and, therefore, not what I'm looking for. I'm hugely disappointed to be sending them back, because otherwise these shoes are perfect.

Was hoping to get this shoe in wide, as it was tight in the toes, but did not see it being offered.

Nice looking shoe but had to return because heel was slipping and overall did not fit right. I did like the nice padding in the shoe and hope I can find another in their line that works.

I was very disappointed in the shoe quality for the money. Thin and cheap soles, from China. Also there is no way these were a WIDE. Very narrow...

I do not love these pumps. I do not want to offend any of the lovely Zappos shoppers who clearly love these shoes, but they seem almost matronly to me. I am not that young, and they are super comfortable, but something about them felt frumpy to me. They also came up kind of high on my heel. That little area of the heel cup fabric above the buckle strap seems higher than the tops of other heels and cuts into me. They are going back, oh well.

The heel height and padding are nice, as is the overall kook of the shoe. However, there is something in the heel, stitching I think, that gave me blisters on both heels after one day. I threw them away.

One of the other reviewers was right. The side buckle tears away at the hem of trousers. First wearing and I'm having to get trousers re-hemmed. I'll be returning these and hope for a full refund.

I have owned several pairs of Circa shoes over the years, as I love their styling, fit, and value. So I ordered a pair of these with no concerns, in the size that I always wear. Well, these are the most uncomfortable Circa shoes I have ever tried on - about a 1/2 size too small, but with gaps on the side of the heel. Yet narrow in the toe. And the upper looked pretty cheaply made - stitching on the seams inside felt like they would chew up my feet. The shoes were also extremely stiff, and did not feel like the quality of leather was such that it would soften up over time. These shoes are being returned.

If you're into role-playing the Wicked Witch of the West, then these are the shoes for you! The toe is much more pointy than it appears on the photos/video. Wicked Witch shoes are not my style. In addition these were so tight in the toe box, they hurt just trying them on! No way would I survive tromping through miles of hospital corridors every day much less 8.5 hours! Also of note: the strap is not adjustable despite what the info and video say. So, in light of that I'll be sending these shoes back, unless I run into the witch for whom they were obviously made. If that's the case, I'll give them to the witch and continue my search for a comfy kitten heel.

The photo is better than the product. This shoe has all the makings of a great everyday work shoe: walkable heel height, cushioned ball of the foot, nice style. But in person this shoe looks cheap, feels narrow in the toe box and wide at the heel and generally failed for me.

I bought these shoes in my size and tried them on and they felt true to size. The only problem I had was they were a little lose along the side. The description said that the strap could be tightened. I found this almost impossible to do because the leather was too new. I wore the a few times and then tried to tighten them, the leather was more pliable, but it is still impossible to tighten the strap. I took them to a cobbler and he said that the shoes were not made to be tightened. I am left with a pair of shoes that I am not able to use, after wearing them only twice. I wore them yesterday and they slipped off my heel so badly that I almost tripped.